I tried bits of a fanfic I wrote (Steven King), a fantasy vignette (Dickens) and an erotic detective novel (Nabokov).
I guess that means I’m complex. Or undisciplined.
9.
SarahLoving
I submitted a bunch yesterday and received Margaret Atwood and George Orwell. I was so pleased that I chose to submit a third time and got….. DAN BROWN.
I now wear the Cone of Shame.
10.
Xero
I was told I write like Stephen King, who, it says writes like Lewis Carroll.
They are the undecipherable scribblings of a madman which, if we could decipher them, would reveal the stark horror and meaninglessness of existence, culminating in a time when godlike beings come to earth and devour our souls?
18.
Comrade Mary
I’ve submitted various rants and more modulated, helpful bits of writing and my results have been: Nabokov (The WHA? Flatter me much?), Stephen King (He’s a decent prose stylist with some flaws, but not a complete hack), Dan Brown (KILL ME NOW!), Nabokov (Oh, your flattery is salve for my burning soul. I’ll take it), King (Am I gonna be rich?), King (Oh man, maybe I’ll get rich), Lovecraft (Advising people gently and throughly on the best bike for them evokes eldritch horror? Um, OK), King (This link seems appropriate) and Dan Brown (NOOOOO!!! I don’t want money that much. Can’t the Old Ones kill me first?).
EDIT: Ands this comment came back as King. The lyrics for Opportunities? Dan Brown. I rest my case.
19.
Xecky Gilchrist
I got Chuck Palahniuk (submitted a day’s worth of my NaNoWriMo free-association.)
My friend submitted her entire MFA thesis, and got Vonnegut. I submitted 3 different selections of prose, and got Stephen King, Jack London, and Vonnegut.
Well I submitted two portions of a legal brief, one portion of the statement of fact that turned out to be Margaret Atwood (whom I have never read, partly because I didn’t think it would be fun) and portion of the argument turned out to be by Dan Brown (ouch!). Now don’t make fun.
22.
anthrosciguy
I took a web page of mine and pasted it. The result was “Lovecraft”. But pasting it section by section got “Lovecraft”, “Atwood”, or “Poe” for various sections of the same page.
23.
Rick Massimo
Unfortunately, driftglass put Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” in there and it came out James Joyce; Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18 came out Rudyard Kipling; Mark Twain’s “The Private history of a Campaign That Failed” came out Lovecraft, and O. Henry’s “The Gift of the Magi” came out Mario Puzo! (It should be noted that Vonnegut’s “Harrison Bergeron” came out Vonnegut.)
did that twice — with the first and last page of my most recent book, Newton and the Counterfeiter. I managed to replicate the experience of many above. The first seems to have been penned by Stephen King, the last by Dan Brown.
I’ll go shoot myself now. (Dan Brown is, imho, the worst writer living.)
Actually, if I could get King’s wealth and deeply envied productivity, I’d consent to live.
29.
Miss Mouse
I got Nabokov. I posted it on Facebook just to brag. :)
30.
Tyler
Three different sections of my masters thesis on labor law and baseball go Dan Brown, HP Lovecraft and Ian Flemming. Scarry.
Since this was on my blog yesterday I put it into the box:
After getting home at five in the morning, and leaving a note for Fritz saying I would be down for breakfast at 10:45, I had set the alarm for ten o’clock. That had seemed sensible, but the trouble with an alarm clock is that what seems sensible when you set it seems absurd when it goes off.
Archie Goodwin, “The Rodeo Murder,” Three at Wolfe’s Door
And the thing told me that was like Arthur Conan Doyle. I’m not sure Rex Stout would be flattered by that, but hey, at least the literary genre was the same.
36.
Bryan
Apparently, Kurt Vonnegut wrote like J.D. Salinger. Personally, my money was that he would write like Kurt Vonnegut, but what do I know?
37.
Comrade Mary
This site has actually made me laugh out loud several times. This is a rare thing.
(Edit: WTF is wrong with this page? The box replaces anything past the first part with a strikethrough & screws up the formatting.)
Other two it said Dan Brown (short comment on over-reliance on credit) & H.P. Lovecraft (two cents on Rand Paul & the civil rights act stuff). I had to look up who H.P. Lovecraft was.
40.
Skipjack
My unscientific survey detects bias. My selection of Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte apparently has the bot thinking she writes like Edgar Allen Poe, and Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte is a dead ringer for Oscar Wilde.
Plugged in one of my older snark pieces from my blog and came up with Vonnegut.
42.
Chad S
Lovecraft here.
43.
David in NY
OK, tried again with a section of an actual amicus brief in the Supreme Court — pretty technical. Came out with Daniel Defoe, which is not bad given my prior results.
44.
JD Rhoades
I gave it the first three chapters of my WIP and it gave me Nabokov.
I bunged in some random old blog posts of mine, and got mainly Dan Brown (seems to be the default), with a sprinkling of Kurt Vonnegut, a couple of mystifying H.P. Lovecrafts, one instance of Douglas Adams, and for an intemperate rant about your wingnuts savaging the NHS, P.G. Wodehouse.
All in all, I’m not complaining.
47.
David in NY
This poem by Richard Wilbur:
A Shallot
The full cloves
Of your buttocks, the convex
Curve of your belly, the curved
Cleft of your sex–
Out of this corm
That’s planted in strong thighs
The slender stem and radiant
Flower rise.
came out as James Joyce.
48.
tt crews
I came up Isaac Asimov for a blog piece on a local redevelopment project. My daughter’s MFA thesis is H G Wells.
I put up my 10 year old son’s letter to his pen pal and he came out Stephen King. So…does my 10 yo write like King or does King write like a 10 yo?
49.
JD Rhoades
I gave it a blog post and it gave me Vonnegut. Then I gave it three chapters of SAFE AND SOUND and it gave me…Douglas Adams?!
50.
daryljfontaine
Fanfic from 1996: Chuck Palahniuk.
Long-ish comment from a gaming message board: Dan Brown.
This comment right up until the last colon: Also Chuck Palahniuk.
D
51.
jacy
I put in a passage from a published short story, a page from the mystery novel that’s at a publisher waiting for word, and a passage from the new novel I’m working on. I am apparently the bastard love child of James Joyce and Stephen King.
I’m still trying to figure out if that’s good or bad, at least from a commercial standpoint if not a literary one.
Yes, I needed one more useless thing to do that is a complete time suck and keeps me from doing any productive work. Sigh.
52.
debbie
Hmm. The first time, I got Nabokov. I then reposted the exact same text and got David Foster Wallace.
53.
Bill Murray
I compared the Beatles “I wanna hold your hand”, which came out as JD Salinger with “Let it Be” which came out as James Joyce, so I guess there was some growth during that career
54.
mr. whipple
HA! I got:
I write like
Kurt Vonnegut.
55.
JGabriel
Hmm. After being told I write like Stephen King, Dan Brown, and Arthur Conan Doyle, I posted the following in the I Write Like analysis field:
Looking into the rearview mirror, he realized that a car had been tailing him all along. He had never had any doubt he was being followed, but so far they had acted with masterly discretion. Today a radical change had taken place: they wanted him to know about them.
__
In the middle of some fields, about fifteen miles outside of Prague there was a tall fence with a car-repair shop behind it. He had a good friend there and needed him to replace a faulty starter. He pulled up to the entrance. It was blocked by a red and white striped gate. A heavy woman was standing beside it. Mirek waited for her to raise the gate, but she just stared at him, motionless. He honked his horn, but got no response. He looked out the window.
__
“Not behind bars yet?” asked the woman.
__
“No, not yet,” answered Mirek. “How about raising the gate?”
__
She looked at him impassively for a few more long sentences, then yawned, went over to the gatekeeper’s cabin, dropped into a desk chair, and turned her back on him.
__
So he got up out of the car, walked around the gate, and went into the service area to look for his friend the mechanic. The mechanic came back with him. He raised the gate himself (the woman was still sitting impasively in the cabin), and Mirek drove his car in.
__
“That’s what you get for showing off on television,” said the mechanic. “Every broad in the country knows what you look like.”
__
“Who is she?” Mirek asked.
__
He learned that the invasion of Czechoslovakia by Russian troops, which had made themselves felt everywhere, had changed her life as well. Seeing that people in higher places (and everyone was higher than she was) were being deprived of power, status, employment, and daily bread on the basis of the slightest allegation, she got all excited and started denouncing people herself.
__
“Then how come she’s still working the gate? Haven’t they even promoted her?”
__
The mechanic smiled. “They can’t. She doesn’t know how to count to five. All they can do is let her go on with her denunciations. That’s her only reward.”
__
Mirek was suddenly aware of someone a few steps away. He turned and saw a man in a gray jacket, white shirt and tie, and brown slacks. His strong neck and bloated face were toppped by a shock of artificially waved gray hair. He stood there watching the mechanic under the raised hood.
__
After a while, the mechanic noticed him too. “Looking for somebody?” he asked, straightening up.
__
“No,” answered the man with the strong neck and wavy hair. “I’m not looking for anybody.”
__
The mechanic leaned down over the engine again and said, “Right in the middle of Prague, Wenceslaus Square, there’s this guy throwing up. And this other guy comes along, takes a look at him, shakes his head, and says, ‘I know just what you mean'”
The people on your twitter feed are idiots. This isn’t analyzing your writing, it’s spitting out a random author. Hence the commenters above submitting the same posts and getting different authors, and why everyone in the blogosphere seems to write like a famous author and not, say, a five year old.
The key to understanding these “analyzers” that crop up every few months is the “mac journal software” up there. Notice how that’s a link? This is some advertiser’s cheap way of boosting its product’s Google ranking by exploiting the vanity of bloggers. You have been snookered, good sir.
I put a fragment of a story of mine and received Arthur C. Clarke. I just thought it was interesting because I haven’t seen anyone else receive that yet.
After repeated plays with this, with my graduate thesis, Facebook posts, and my manifestos, I have come back as writing like David Foster Wallace every time except for one (Dickens).
Sure it’s just a bogus meme to pass the time on a slow news day, so of course I pasted in a few posts. Got Steven King, Dan Brown and Vonnegut. Decided to quit with Vonnegut.
I also got David Foster Wallace for most of my submissions, except for once when I got James Joyce and once when I got Margaret Atwood.
So it’s a fun parlour game — who cares if it means anything? If nothing else, it’s intrigued me enough to want to read some of Wallace’s work.
85.
QuaintIrene
I typed in a short bit about my local garden center. Stopped by to get some sweet corn, peaches and nice jersey tomatoes.
Was told I write like Margaret Atwood.
As Elmer Fudd would say, ‘vewwy intewesting’
86.
Comrade Mary
RedKitten, you may or may not have the time for Infinite Jest, but try A Supposedly Fun Thing I’ll Never Do Again, a collection of his (relatively) short pieces. That Wiki page includes links to several PDFs of various essays.
87.
k55f
@b-psycho: “I had to look up who H.P. Lovecraft was”….
He, obviously, was the greatest horror writer of all time.
(And I’m not saying that just because I put in a cover letter for a job and got back that I write like H.P.L.)
I had to look up who psycho was….
88.
Tara the antisocial social worker
I got Dan Brown.
I will now add a large block of exposition to this post in order to provide obvious foreshadowing of what’s going to happen next, while completely ignoring the ticking bomb in the next room.
89.
JGabriel
I think John Cain is right: I Write Like isn’t doing any analysis at all, it’s just spitting out random writer’s names.
.
90.
noncarborundum
Lovecraft, Poe, Wallace (thrice) and Joyce.
Lovecraft?
91.
expat
I plugged in 5 paragraphs from the 2000 US Supreme Court decision in Gore v. Bush, selected more or less at random (a chunk starting at Section II-A, just to avoid too many case citations) – result: Dan Brown
I think it’s for real.
92.
Thomas
Um…is there something wrong with the link? It takes me to an Amazon.com page for Kurt Vonnegut’s books!
I had never heard of this before five minutes ago, and wheeee! Very fun.
I put in three very different (I thought) passages, and came up David Foster Wallace each time — which was both a compliment, I thought, and odd, because I’ve never read so much as a page of David Foster Wallace. (I know, I know. I’ll go out to the woodshed later).
But then I put in something that I wrote in a good mood about an evening in the backyard with a fire going in my new firebowl — and boom! I’m JK Rowling!
Take away: I should work more on maintaining a good mood. But it will apparently be very hard.
I put in three different paragraphs from an e mail to my sister, The first two I got David Foster Wallace, the 3rd paragraph about our 4th of July party where I cooked for 18 was James Joyce…come to think of it the party was Joycean!
100.
Mark S.
I got two Lovecrafts, one Vonnegut, and one [gulp] Dan Fucking Brown! Jesus Christ, I don’t write that badly!
@Jager: I find it interesting that so many of the BJers appear to be getting Wallace…! Interesting, odd, completely meaningless. One of those, I suppose.
Reading through the comments, it looks like this thing is bullshit.
[This comment was written like David Foster Wallace]
104.
Joel
I ran my paper submission and got David Foster Wallace. I don’t know how well that goes over in the journals…
105.
David in NY
OK, so somebody else’s legal brief got David Foster Wallace, while mine got Margaret Atwood and Dan Brown (and a SCOTUS amicus got Daniel Defoe). Should I be pleased by comparison or no? The aim here is clear, persuasive prose.
106.
Felanius Kootea (formerly Salt and freshly ground black people)
David Foster Wallace here…
107.
C.S.Strowbridge
Stephenie Meyer?
Fuck you.
Also got Chuck Palahniuk, David Foster Wallace, and Arthur Conan Doyle.
108.
suzanne
All this David Foster Wallace talk is making me very melancholy.
RIP, DFW.
109.
Chad N Freude
I, too, got David Foster Wallace. Does that mean that that a lot of us here are capable of sometimes brilliant, frequently entertaining, and often tedious writing? Or does it suggest a limited writer base or analysis algorithm for the computer (don’t forget that it’s a computer doing this) analysis? And how can anyone be compared to Wallace without writing a lot of footnotes?
The very first thing I put in was a bit of a fanfic that I’d written, being a ten-year veteran.
Out spits “Stephenie Meyer”. And not only that, but I see that I got beat to it as well.
Talk about abject shame.
I stuck three blog posts through it as well. Two ended up as H.P. Lovecraft, the final as David Foster Wallace.
I still cannot bear the shame of the first analysis, though.
111.
Morbo
Neil Gaiman on the first try, then (ugh) Dan Brown on random sampling, but then I picked a piece that didn’t involve Templars and got David Foster Wallace.
112.
hitchhiker
Wait, is Dan Brown really considered a writer?
113.
Twisted_Colour
I put in a poem that I wrote about Garibaldi and got Mario Puzo. Is this racial profiling?
114.
noncarborundum
I copied & pasted everything on this page. In the aggregate, we all write like Arthur C. Clarke.
It’s gonna be counting sentence lengths and things- looking at structural elements. I don’t know how deep it goes, but I have a funny story about this thing…
Back at the beginning of this year, I switched from trying to draw a daily comic to WRITING that story, which I’ve got about 100K words down now. I kicked it off with some colorful exposition, which I pasted into the web toy.
Says I write like J.D. Salinger.
Salinger lived about half an hour from me, to the north, and I never knew it. And right when I decided to switch over to novel form- he DIED.
Fucker obviously haunted me because I was the only writer handy who was as reclusive as he was…
117.
handsmile
Feeling puckish, I just submitted David Brooks’ latest NY Times column into the algorithmic maw.
It spit out: David Foster Wallace.
Were that magnificent writer still to be walking amongst us (1), I can’t imagine which David would be more horrified by this literary insta-analysis.
I dare say it might also puncture that quick tickle of pride some of us might have felt when our own writing was deemed to be Wallace-esque.
(1) Wyatt Mason, “Smarter than You Think,” The New York Review of Books, Vol. LVII, No. 12
118.
mclaren
According to this thing, I write like David Foster Wallace. Ridiculous. Wallace uses sentence fragments and obscure obnubilations replete with footnotes.[1]
[1] In some of his work. Footnotes appear mainly in his books, not his magazine articles.
it said i wrote like david foster wallace? i submitted nothing more than a rebuke of small government style “why should that be government’s job” garbage on a message board…
wow the less you try…the key to life.
120.
tworivers
H.P. Lovecraft once, David Foster Wallace three times.
Based on the opening lines of my novel-in-progress, I got Margaret Mitchell.
Based on a post I wrote last weekend, I got David Foster Wallace.
Both came to bad ends.
122.
wilfred
Good fun. After reading a lot of the comments I first put a few paragraphs from my dissertation where I define and explain some Arabic terms, and got Dan Brown. Then I put a long paragraph where I used the words -vault, curdling, bastion, dark and clammy – and got Lovecraft.
I think I get it.
123.
Albatrossity
Hilarious! I submitted three sections of a non-fiction piece that is out there waiting to be published. These three sections were three paragraphs each, and they appear consecutively in the work. Here are the results of that experiment.
#1 – Chuck Pahluniak (beats me, I never heard of him either)
#2 – Anne Rice
#3 – James Joyce
This may be the first time ever that Anne Rice and James Joyce have been mentioned together.
I don’t think that this analysis tool is ready for prime time…
124.
Paul in KY
H.P. Lovecraft for me too!
interesting note: I did not use the word ‘eldritch’ in my submitted writing.
125.
ed drone
James Joyce & David Foster Wallace (whoever he is — and yes, I checked, and still don’t know).
I tried some lyrics, and got James Joyce again. I tried a Kipling poem and got James Joyce. I tried the King James’ Bible and got James Joyce.
That last is a lie.
Ed
126.
ed drone
@Chris Johnson:
I entered your BJ comment and got that Wallace clown again.
Ed
127.
Death Panel Truck
I put in several chapters of my fabulous unfinished novel:
Chapter 1 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 2 – Steven King
Chapter 3 – Steven King
Chapter 4 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 5 – Chuck Palahniuk (who was born in the city I live in: Pasco, Washington)
Chapter 6 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 7 – Steven King
Chapter 8 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 9 – Charles Dickens.
Gotta say, that last one blows my mind.
128.
licensed to kill time
I put in three things I wrote.
The first was an email to family, it said I write like Dan Brown.
The second was a little tribute to Balloon Juice, it said I write like William Gibson.
The third was an email to my best friend, it said I write like David Foster Wallace.
The funniest is number one, because I self-censor heavily when writing to family, though I must admit it made my heart sink a little bit, being compared to Dan Brown.
4 different samples yielded 4 different results. poetry wound up interesting too. i got nabakov, joyce, atwood, brown, margert mitchell (probably the palm trees) and david foster wallace.
the site is a front for someone trying to sell you a book on how to submit proposals to publishers. i suppose it’s a step up from a vanity press, but i’d personally avoid giving them any more traffic.
…wait, they are trying to enlist you, amway style:
If you are interested in selling these eBooks on your own Web site, blog, or email list, you can Join our Affiliate Program! You will earn 50% of the retail price for each sale (excluding purchases you make yourself).
fuck’em. leeches. probably have a vanity arm as well.
130.
ral
No mention of Doc Smith??
Comments are closed.
Trackbacks
[…] via […]
Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!
protected static
Much weirdness… this post appears to have screwed up the display in Firefox (3.6.6 on WinXP). And it doesn’t show up at all in IE7…
D-Chance.
Someone broke the internets, Cole…
edit: all better. ‘Refresh’ing, in a way.
R-Jud
I submitted the recipe for the quiche I made tonight and it said I write like HP Lovecraft.
Tank Hueco
H. P. Lovecraft.
NobodySpecial
I write like I have no business writing.
dms
Well, using three paragraphs each from two different chapters of my unfinished book, I got two answers:
1. Steven King
2. Vladimir Nabokov
I much prefer the second.
Irony Abounds
Stephen King – if only I had even a tenth of his money.
Dr. Psycho
I tried bits of a fanfic I wrote (Steven King), a fantasy vignette (Dickens) and an erotic detective novel (Nabokov).
I guess that means I’m complex. Or undisciplined.
SarahLoving
I submitted a bunch yesterday and received Margaret Atwood and George Orwell. I was so pleased that I chose to submit a third time and got….. DAN BROWN.
I now wear the Cone of Shame.
Xero
I was told I write like Stephen King, who, it says writes like Lewis Carroll.
cleek
HP Lovecraft!
i wish i knew what that meant!
jwb
@dms: I tried five different passages from a single article and came up with five different authors. Go figure!
Jay in Oregon
I submitted an erotic short story I wrote and got Nabokov as well.
wobbly
No one writes like Kurt Vonnegut did back in the day.
Except Mark Twain.
Wow.
Josh
Apparently, I write like William Shakespeare.
English major win?
jwb
@SarahLoving: And if you submit your comment here, you end up back with . . . Margaret Atwood!
Jay in Oregon
@cleek:
They are the undecipherable scribblings of a madman which, if we could decipher them, would reveal the stark horror and meaninglessness of existence, culminating in a time when godlike beings come to earth and devour our souls?
Comrade Mary
I’ve submitted various rants and more modulated, helpful bits of writing and my results have been: Nabokov (The WHA? Flatter me much?), Stephen King (He’s a decent prose stylist with some flaws, but not a complete hack), Dan Brown (KILL ME NOW!), Nabokov (Oh, your flattery is salve for my burning soul. I’ll take it), King (Am I gonna be rich?), King (Oh man, maybe I’ll get rich), Lovecraft (Advising people gently and throughly on the best bike for them evokes eldritch horror? Um, OK), King (This link seems appropriate) and Dan Brown (NOOOOO!!! I don’t want money that much. Can’t the Old Ones kill me first?).
EDIT: Ands this comment came back as King. The lyrics for Opportunities? Dan Brown. I rest my case.
Xecky Gilchrist
I got Chuck Palahniuk (submitted a day’s worth of my NaNoWriMo free-association.)
freelancer
Lol,
My friend submitted her entire MFA thesis, and got Vonnegut. I submitted 3 different selections of prose, and got Stephen King, Jack London, and Vonnegut.
Apparently my co-blogger and friend Alex writes like fukkin Tolkien. Hoocoodanode?
David in NY
Well I submitted two portions of a legal brief, one portion of the statement of fact that turned out to be Margaret Atwood (whom I have never read, partly because I didn’t think it would be fun) and portion of the argument turned out to be by Dan Brown (ouch!). Now don’t make fun.
anthrosciguy
I took a web page of mine and pasted it. The result was “Lovecraft”. But pasting it section by section got “Lovecraft”, “Atwood”, or “Poe” for various sections of the same page.
Rick Massimo
Unfortunately, driftglass put Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” in there and it came out James Joyce; Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18 came out Rudyard Kipling; Mark Twain’s “The Private history of a Campaign That Failed” came out Lovecraft, and O. Henry’s “The Gift of the Magi” came out Mario Puzo! (It should be noted that Vonnegut’s “Harrison Bergeron” came out Vonnegut.)
Just sayin’ …
tjlabs
I put in two very different posts. The first one said I wrote like Stephen King, the other like H. P. Lovecraft. I’m starting to scare myself.
MAJeff
I got Vonnegut for my food writing and Joyce for an academic sample. Clarity is, apparently, not my strength.
Cat
This is so 1996. Markov chains have been guessing authorship of writings since around then.
Josh
I submitted a small piece of flash fiction I wrote and got Raymond Chandler (it was a 99 word complete story).
I then submitted the opening paragraphs of a short sci-fi story I wrote and got Isaac Asimov.
I think I’m good with that. Shakespeare and Chandler are OK, but my favorite Science Fiction author has always been Asimov.
thomas Levenson
did that twice — with the first and last page of my most recent book, Newton and the Counterfeiter. I managed to replicate the experience of many above. The first seems to have been penned by Stephen King, the last by Dan Brown.
I’ll go shoot myself now. (Dan Brown is, imho, the worst writer living.)
Actually, if I could get King’s wealth and deeply envied productivity, I’d consent to live.
Miss Mouse
I got Nabokov. I posted it on Facebook just to brag. :)
Tyler
Three different sections of my masters thesis on labor law and baseball go Dan Brown, HP Lovecraft and Ian Flemming. Scarry.
SarahLoving
@jwb: Good to know Maggie’s got my back.
General Stuck
Did a couple and they come up James Joyce. That’s cool since I like the Irish.
Allan
Vonnegut or Orwell, depending on the text.
b-psycho
Submitted a few blogposts:
–this one on BP & the escrow account wingers were calling a “slush fund” drew Shakespeare.
Linkmeister
Since this was on my blog yesterday I put it into the box:
Archie Goodwin, “The Rodeo Murder,” Three at Wolfe’s Door
And the thing told me that was like Arthur Conan Doyle. I’m not sure Rex Stout would be flattered by that, but hey, at least the literary genre was the same.
Bryan
Apparently, Kurt Vonnegut wrote like J.D. Salinger. Personally, my money was that he would write like Kurt Vonnegut, but what do I know?
Comrade Mary
This site has actually made me laugh out loud several times. This is a rare thing.
Example: the lyrics to Don’t Stand So Close To Me (which name drop Nabokov) come out as: JK Rowling.
Omnes Omnibus
With two different blocks of text I got Steven King and George Orwell.
b-psycho
(Edit: WTF is wrong with this page? The box replaces anything past the first part with a strikethrough & screws up the formatting.)
Other two it said Dan Brown (short comment on over-reliance on credit) & H.P. Lovecraft (two cents on Rand Paul & the civil rights act stuff). I had to look up who H.P. Lovecraft was.
Skipjack
My unscientific survey detects bias. My selection of Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte apparently has the bot thinking she writes like Edgar Allen Poe, and Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte is a dead ringer for Oscar Wilde.
General Stuck
Plugged in one of my older snark pieces from my blog and came up with Vonnegut.
Chad S
Lovecraft here.
David in NY
OK, tried again with a section of an actual amicus brief in the Supreme Court — pretty technical. Came out with Daniel Defoe, which is not bad given my prior results.
JD Rhoades
I gave it the first three chapters of my WIP and it gave me Nabokov.
I call bullshit.
b-psycho
Tried some song lyrics myself. Who knew Project Pat wrote like Steven King?
YAFB
I bunged in some random old blog posts of mine, and got mainly Dan Brown (seems to be the default), with a sprinkling of Kurt Vonnegut, a couple of mystifying H.P. Lovecrafts, one instance of Douglas Adams, and for an intemperate rant about your wingnuts savaging the NHS, P.G. Wodehouse.
All in all, I’m not complaining.
David in NY
This poem by Richard Wilbur:
A Shallot
The full cloves
Of your buttocks, the convex
Curve of your belly, the curved
Cleft of your sex–
Out of this corm
That’s planted in strong thighs
The slender stem and radiant
Flower rise.
came out as James Joyce.
tt crews
I came up Isaac Asimov for a blog piece on a local redevelopment project. My daughter’s MFA thesis is H G Wells.
I put up my 10 year old son’s letter to his pen pal and he came out Stephen King. So…does my 10 yo write like King or does King write like a 10 yo?
JD Rhoades
I gave it a blog post and it gave me Vonnegut. Then I gave it three chapters of SAFE AND SOUND and it gave me…Douglas Adams?!
daryljfontaine
Fanfic from 1996: Chuck Palahniuk.
Long-ish comment from a gaming message board: Dan Brown.
This comment right up until the last colon: Also Chuck Palahniuk.
D
jacy
I put in a passage from a published short story, a page from the mystery novel that’s at a publisher waiting for word, and a passage from the new novel I’m working on. I am apparently the bastard love child of James Joyce and Stephen King.
I’m still trying to figure out if that’s good or bad, at least from a commercial standpoint if not a literary one.
Yes, I needed one more useless thing to do that is a complete time suck and keeps me from doing any productive work. Sigh.
debbie
Hmm. The first time, I got Nabokov. I then reposted the exact same text and got David Foster Wallace.
Bill Murray
I compared the Beatles “I wanna hold your hand”, which came out as JD Salinger with “Let it Be” which came out as James Joyce, so I guess there was some growth during that career
mr. whipple
HA! I got:
I write like
Kurt Vonnegut.
JGabriel
Hmm. After being told I write like Stephen King, Dan Brown, and Arthur Conan Doyle, I posted the following in the I Write Like analysis field:
Milan Kundera will be pleased to know he writes just like Stephen King.
(Yeah, it’s a long quote, but I included it so other people could test it for themselves.)
.
Joseph Nobles
I got H.P. Lovecraft (from an essay on Gertrude’s guilt in Hamlet), then David Foster Wallace, Chuck Palahniuk, and Ursula Guin.
Obviously I need to publish.
jah
so it goes.
Bill E Pilgrim
I write like Vonnegut.
No one could have predicted that.
Catsy
I fed it the story blurbs from these two photos and it said Stephen King.
I fed it this rant and it said Edgar Allen Poe.
I have no idea what this says about me.
Bill Murray
@JGabriel: I copied that in and got Kurt Vonnegut
John Harrold
I submitted four different things and I got three different answers:
Vladimir Nabokov
David Foster Wallace (twice)
Mark Twain
Being only semi-literate I’ve only read Twain, so I have no idea if he is similar to the other two.
John Cain
The people on your twitter feed are idiots. This isn’t analyzing your writing, it’s spitting out a random author. Hence the commenters above submitting the same posts and getting different authors, and why everyone in the blogosphere seems to write like a famous author and not, say, a five year old.
The key to understanding these “analyzers” that crop up every few months is the “mac journal software” up there. Notice how that’s a link? This is some advertiser’s cheap way of boosting its product’s Google ranking by exploiting the vanity of bloggers. You have been snookered, good sir.
YAFB
As a control experiment, I fed it Palin’s latest Facebook post.
I don’t know what she’s paying her ghostwriter, but yes, it came back Dan Brown.
So did her GOP Convention VP acceptance speech.
Her latest Tweet? Stephen King.
Bill E Pilgrim
Yeah okay. I just pasted in a chapter of Vonnegut, Slaughterhouse Five, and it came back:
“You write like Raymond Chandler.”
I think we have an updated magic 8 ball here, basically.
YAFB
@John Cain:
Spoilsport.
Steele
I put a fragment of a story of mine and received Arthur C. Clarke. I just thought it was interesting because I haven’t seen anyone else receive that yet.
General Stuck
@John Cain:
Oh yea, Mr. Know-it-All. now you gonna tell us the Easter Bunny isn’t real? Fuddy dud!
Bill E Pilgrim
@John Cain: Dan Brown writes like a five-year-old, and he’s a famous author.
More common than you might think.
Hart Williams
I don’t know how much credibility I can cede this parlor game.
I just went back over a week’s worth of blogs, and posted nice big chunks of prose. Thus far I write like
William Gibson
Edgar Allan Poe
H.P Lovecraft
James Joyce
I’m not THAT big a chameleon.
Probably more useful to go to the Post Modernist Generator and whip up some REAL garbledy-gook. :-)
Hmmm. Wonder who THEY write like?
IrishGirl
I put in a blog post and was told: David Foster Wallace. Accurate or not, I’ll take that compliment and run with it.
suzanne
Awww. Apparently I write like David Foster Wallace.
***sniffle***
Steve
I tried excerpts from two different legal briefs I wrote today and got David Foster Wallace both times.
Comrade Mary
So trying out this analyzer is a supposedly fun thing you’ll never do again?
LT
David Foster Wallace. Never read him.
suzanne
After repeated plays with this, with my graduate thesis, Facebook posts, and my manifestos, I have come back as writing like David Foster Wallace every time except for one (Dickens).
Fewer footnotes, though, I SWEAR.
Tom Hilton
@LT: Me too, except I have read him (Infinite Jest, a couple times).
LT
Looks like they’re on a DFWallace kick right now.
another county heard from
I tried submitting several things, and got:
* Stephen King
* David Foster Wallace
* Dan Brown
Either I’m more inconsistent than I think, or this thing is BS.
Though for the record, I hope it’s wrong about Dan Brown.
LT
Just put in E. E. Cummings’ “anyone lived in a pretty how town”—David Foster Wallace.
J Price Vincenz
Vonnegut for me, too.
Karen in GA
David Foster Wallace, of course. And Harry Harrison, also too.
Soylent Green is people!
Comrade Mary
OFFS. They’re giving away DFW like he’s Halloween candy and I get Isaac “smart guy but no prose stylist” Asimov? Not fair.
Could be worse. Could be Geddy Lee.
EDIT: And I just served up more DFW bait — THIS freaking comment — with a FOOTNOTE — and what do I get? Dan Mother Mary Magdalene-fucking Brown.
I quit the Internets.
Libby
Sure it’s just a bogus meme to pass the time on a slow news day, so of course I pasted in a few posts. Got Steven King, Dan Brown and Vonnegut. Decided to quit with Vonnegut.
RedKitten
I also got David Foster Wallace for most of my submissions, except for once when I got James Joyce and once when I got Margaret Atwood.
So it’s a fun parlour game — who cares if it means anything? If nothing else, it’s intrigued me enough to want to read some of Wallace’s work.
QuaintIrene
I typed in a short bit about my local garden center. Stopped by to get some sweet corn, peaches and nice jersey tomatoes.
Was told I write like Margaret Atwood.
As Elmer Fudd would say, ‘vewwy intewesting’
Comrade Mary
RedKitten, you may or may not have the time for Infinite Jest, but try A Supposedly Fun Thing I’ll Never Do Again, a collection of his (relatively) short pieces. That Wiki page includes links to several PDFs of various essays.
k55f
@b-psycho: “I had to look up who H.P. Lovecraft was”….
He, obviously, was the greatest horror writer of all time.
(And I’m not saying that just because I put in a cover letter for a job and got back that I write like H.P.L.)
I had to look up who psycho was….
Tara the antisocial social worker
I got Dan Brown.
I will now add a large block of exposition to this post in order to provide obvious foreshadowing of what’s going to happen next, while completely ignoring the ticking bomb in the next room.
JGabriel
I think John Cain is right: I Write Like isn’t doing any analysis at all, it’s just spitting out random writer’s names.
.
noncarborundum
Lovecraft, Poe, Wallace (thrice) and Joyce.
Lovecraft?
expat
I plugged in 5 paragraphs from the 2000 US Supreme Court decision in Gore v. Bush, selected more or less at random (a chunk starting at Section II-A, just to avoid too many case citations) – result: Dan Brown
I think it’s for real.
Thomas
Um…is there something wrong with the link? It takes me to an Amazon.com page for Kurt Vonnegut’s books!
ellaesther
@Thomas: The URL is iwl.me – find your own way, young Thomas!
ellaesther
I had never heard of this before five minutes ago, and wheeee! Very fun.
I put in three very different (I thought) passages, and came up David Foster Wallace each time — which was both a compliment, I thought, and odd, because I’ve never read so much as a page of David Foster Wallace. (I know, I know. I’ll go out to the woodshed later).
But then I put in something that I wrote in a good mood about an evening in the backyard with a fire going in my new firebowl — and boom! I’m JK Rowling!
Take away: I should work more on maintaining a good mood. But it will apparently be very hard.
ellaesther
@RedKitten: Me too! I now feel morally obligated to actually read him.
Kristine
I write like Neil Gaiman, apparently.
I will sooo take it.
Phoenician in a time of Romans
I did five posts of my own words from my defunct blog.
1 Mark Twain, 1 Margaret Atwood, 3 David Foster Wallaces.
Now I’m scared.
machine
David Foster Wallace.
Jager
@ellaesther:
I put in three different paragraphs from an e mail to my sister, The first two I got David Foster Wallace, the 3rd paragraph about our 4th of July party where I cooked for 18 was James Joyce…come to think of it the party was Joycean!
Mark S.
I got two Lovecrafts, one Vonnegut, and one [gulp] Dan Fucking Brown! Jesus Christ, I don’t write that badly!
ellaesther
@John Cain: No – really? And here I thought I really wrote like David Foster Wallace and/or JK Rowling.
My heart – broken!
ellaesther
@Jager: I find it interesting that so many of the BJers appear to be getting Wallace…! Interesting, odd, completely meaningless. One of those, I suppose.
Mark S.
@Mark S.:
Reading through the comments, it looks like this thing is bullshit.
[This comment was written like David Foster Wallace]
Joel
I ran my paper submission and got David Foster Wallace. I don’t know how well that goes over in the journals…
David in NY
OK, so somebody else’s legal brief got David Foster Wallace, while mine got Margaret Atwood and Dan Brown (and a SCOTUS amicus got Daniel Defoe). Should I be pleased by comparison or no? The aim here is clear, persuasive prose.
Felanius Kootea (formerly Salt and freshly ground black people)
David Foster Wallace here…
C.S.Strowbridge
Stephenie Meyer?
Fuck you.
Also got Chuck Palahniuk, David Foster Wallace, and Arthur Conan Doyle.
suzanne
All this David Foster Wallace talk is making me very melancholy.
RIP, DFW.
Chad N Freude
I, too, got David Foster Wallace. Does that mean that that a lot of us here are capable of sometimes brilliant, frequently entertaining, and often tedious writing? Or does it suggest a limited writer base or analysis algorithm for the computer (don’t forget that it’s a computer doing this) analysis? And how can anyone be compared to Wallace without writing a lot of footnotes?
Zoogz
The very first thing I put in was a bit of a fanfic that I’d written, being a ten-year veteran.
Out spits “Stephenie Meyer”. And not only that, but I see that I got beat to it as well.
Talk about abject shame.
I stuck three blog posts through it as well. Two ended up as H.P. Lovecraft, the final as David Foster Wallace.
I still cannot bear the shame of the first analysis, though.
Morbo
Neil Gaiman on the first try, then (ugh) Dan Brown on random sampling, but then I picked a piece that didn’t involve Templars and got David Foster Wallace.
hitchhiker
Wait, is Dan Brown really considered a writer?
Twisted_Colour
I put in a poem that I wrote about Garibaldi and got Mario Puzo. Is this racial profiling?
noncarborundum
I copied & pasted everything on this page. In the aggregate, we all write like Arthur C. Clarke.
Ming
David Foster Wallace, twice, and Isaac Asimov.
Chris Johnson
It’s gonna be counting sentence lengths and things- looking at structural elements. I don’t know how deep it goes, but I have a funny story about this thing…
Back at the beginning of this year, I switched from trying to draw a daily comic to WRITING that story, which I’ve got about 100K words down now. I kicked it off with some colorful exposition, which I pasted into the web toy.
Says I write like J.D. Salinger.
Salinger lived about half an hour from me, to the north, and I never knew it. And right when I decided to switch over to novel form- he DIED.
Fucker obviously haunted me because I was the only writer handy who was as reclusive as he was…
handsmile
Feeling puckish, I just submitted David Brooks’ latest NY Times column into the algorithmic maw.
It spit out: David Foster Wallace.
Were that magnificent writer still to be walking amongst us (1), I can’t imagine which David would be more horrified by this literary insta-analysis.
I dare say it might also puncture that quick tickle of pride some of us might have felt when our own writing was deemed to be Wallace-esque.
(1) Wyatt Mason, “Smarter than You Think,” The New York Review of Books, Vol. LVII, No. 12
mclaren
According to this thing, I write like David Foster Wallace. Ridiculous. Wallace uses sentence fragments and obscure obnubilations replete with footnotes.[1]
[1] In some of his work. Footnotes appear mainly in his books, not his magazine articles.
fucen tarmal
it said i wrote like david foster wallace? i submitted nothing more than a rebuke of small government style “why should that be government’s job” garbage on a message board…
wow the less you try…the key to life.
tworivers
H.P. Lovecraft once, David Foster Wallace three times.
Mustang Bobby
Based on the opening lines of my novel-in-progress, I got Margaret Mitchell.
Based on a post I wrote last weekend, I got David Foster Wallace.
Both came to bad ends.
wilfred
Good fun. After reading a lot of the comments I first put a few paragraphs from my dissertation where I define and explain some Arabic terms, and got Dan Brown. Then I put a long paragraph where I used the words -vault, curdling, bastion, dark and clammy – and got Lovecraft.
I think I get it.
Albatrossity
Hilarious! I submitted three sections of a non-fiction piece that is out there waiting to be published. These three sections were three paragraphs each, and they appear consecutively in the work. Here are the results of that experiment.
#1 – Chuck Pahluniak (beats me, I never heard of him either)
#2 – Anne Rice
#3 – James Joyce
This may be the first time ever that Anne Rice and James Joyce have been mentioned together.
I don’t think that this analysis tool is ready for prime time…
Paul in KY
H.P. Lovecraft for me too!
interesting note: I did not use the word ‘eldritch’ in my submitted writing.
ed drone
James Joyce & David Foster Wallace (whoever he is — and yes, I checked, and still don’t know).
I tried some lyrics, and got James Joyce again. I tried a Kipling poem and got James Joyce. I tried the King James’ Bible and got James Joyce.
That last is a lie.
Ed
ed drone
@Chris Johnson:
I entered your BJ comment and got that Wallace clown again.
Ed
Death Panel Truck
I put in several chapters of my fabulous unfinished novel:
Chapter 1 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 2 – Steven King
Chapter 3 – Steven King
Chapter 4 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 5 – Chuck Palahniuk (who was born in the city I live in: Pasco, Washington)
Chapter 6 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 7 – Steven King
Chapter 8 – David Foster Wallace
Chapter 9 – Charles Dickens.
Gotta say, that last one blows my mind.
licensed to kill time
I put in three things I wrote.
The first was an email to family, it said I write like Dan Brown.
The second was a little tribute to Balloon Juice, it said I write like William Gibson.
The third was an email to my best friend, it said I write like David Foster Wallace.
The funniest is number one, because I self-censor heavily when writing to family, though I must admit it made my heart sink a little bit, being compared to Dan Brown.
twiffer
4 different samples yielded 4 different results. poetry wound up interesting too. i got nabakov, joyce, atwood, brown, margert mitchell (probably the palm trees) and david foster wallace.
the site is a front for someone trying to sell you a book on how to submit proposals to publishers. i suppose it’s a step up from a vanity press, but i’d personally avoid giving them any more traffic.
…wait, they are trying to enlist you, amway style:
fuck’em. leeches. probably have a vanity arm as well.
ral
No mention of Doc Smith??