Reader Interactions

40Comments

  1. 10.

    Mike in NC

    This is one of my favorite Christmas songs, even though it always makes me a little sad, reminding me of Lennon’s murder, Reagan’s ascendance, and Reagan’s calculated indifference to Lennon’s murder, in approximately that order.

    Ah, memories: In December 1980 I was a newly-minted naval officer and had just reported aboard my first ship, a rustbucket based north of San Francisco. We were gathered around the wardroom table one morning when news of John Lennon’s murder came on the TV. The captain (a crusty old LDO in his 50s) looked up from his breakfast and muttered, “they ought to shoot all those goddamn hippies!”. The rest of us nearly choked on our coffee at that remark.

  2. 12.

    Trentrunner

    I know Reagan is a shit generally and six ways to Sunday, but what exactly was his “calculated indifference” to Lennon’s murder?

  3. 14.

    handy

    @Trentrunner:

    Reagan’s response, when asked about the murder, was basically, “Well, we need to stop these things from happening.”

    Inspiring words, Mr. President-Elect.

  4. 17.

    Villago Delenda Est

    @Mike in NC:

    I was freezing my ass off as a crusty old 2LT (two months later I’d get the huge promotion to 1LT, good bye, butterbar!) on a field training exercise in Germany, in the middle of a snowstorm in Hessen, just north of Frankfurt, in the Taunus mountains. News traveled quickly, but was confirmed by a local German newspaper that gave some additional details. I was the local German linguist, such as was available, so was asked to do some translation.

    Bottom line: no Beatles reunion possible. We all were sad, as everyone was old enough to have first hand knowledge of the band then.

  5. 20.

    Fucen Pneumatic Fuck Wrench Tarmal

    @Villago Delenda Est:

    the strange thing is, the boomer drugs are now for boners, cholesterol, and sleep, but you still can’t separate them from the perspicacity they acquired as children. woe be to the culture that wants to evolve without them, or at least, without feeling like there needs to be some pretense of indebtitude.

    i can’t wait until there are beatle soundtracked alzheimer drugs.

  6. 22.

    Schlemizel

    @Thoughtcrime:
    Its not unheard of for people to fall overboard when at sea but usually fatal – particularly when they have something heavy tied to their ankles.

  7. 24.

    joeyess

    The shot of that guy at :59 seconds into that video is one of pure, hopeless rage.

    Oh my, what have we done?

  8. 28.

    neo no one

    Happy Xmas (War Is Over) is even worse than Wonderful Christmastime. If John were alive, you would all agree.

  9. 29.

    someofparts

    Reagan’s calculated indifference to Lennon’s murder

    How on earth did I miss this. What happened?

  10. 31.

    The Fat Kate Middleton

    My favorite song for this time, too – but did anyone actually watch this video? What we do to children … sweet Jesus.

  11. 32.

    JPK

    @handy: What I recall is him being asked about it as he hurried from one place to another, the question shouted by a reporter. He did his later familiar routine of cupping a hand to one ear, as if he couldn’t hear, then shrugging and smiling and waving. It seemed unbelievably insensitive to me, but maybe I was overreacting.

  12. 36.

    forked tongue

    John Lennon was the most overrated figure in all of rock and roll, and this is an awful song, as are all Christmas songs ever written except for “Fairytale of New York.”

  13. 37.

    Steve M.

    “Happy Xmas” came out when I was 12. I loved it, but Greg Lake’s “I Believe in Father Christmas,” which also came out in the early ’70s, is the one that stuck with me. My inner hippie couldn’t coexist with my inner grump.

  14. 38.

    MaryRC

    Loathe this song, just loathe it. The smug and self-congratulatory finger-pointing. “What have you done?” The dirge-like tune, the unimaginative and inane lyrics, but most of all those kids squealing “AH ah AH ah”. “AH ah AH ah” … WTH kind of lyrics are those? From someone who had created some of the best pop songs of his generation? If it wasn’t a Christmas song and stores and elevators everywhere didn’t need something to fill the spot between Feliz Navidad and Have a Holly Jolly Christmas, we’d never have heard of this thing.

  15. 39.

    Savage Henry

    You said Happy Holidays! WAR ON CHRISTMAS! WAR ON CHRISTMAS! I’m reporting you to Bill O’Reilly

  16. 40.

    vheidi

    After an excrutiating trip to the p.o. (to which I need to return) I need a flame war about War is Over?
    Season’s greetings, all

Comments are closed.