Matt Taibbi takes to Rolling Stone to tell us about the lessons that the US military learned from the powerful bruising it received from Muhummad Ali’s refusal to fight in Vietnam: namely, that America should fight its wars with all-volunteer armies whose ranks were disproportionately drawn from the poor and desperate, which dissipated the political pressure that arose from drafting the rich, the powerful and the famous to fight.
Matt Taibbi takes to Rolling Stone to tell us about the lessons that the US military learned
Tabibbi was born in 1970 and yet claims that he and his buddies grew up with Ali as their champion. I don’t buy it. And he drastically oversimplifies the US military’s switch to an all volunteer army.
4.
Chyron HR
I wrote a song to commemorate him:
I BLESS THE RAAAAAINS
DOWN IN AAAAAFRICAAAA
5.
Gin & Tonic
It may be just me, but this kind of passive-aggressive posting (“There”) may be appropriate when some random asshole makes a comment about lack of a hoops thread, but I’d think you could do a little better to honor Ali and your readers who were, I’d bet, really in love with the man.
6.
JMG
Tiabbi, a writer I enjoy, is just wrong. We went to a volunteer military because the Army damn near disintegrated in Vietnam. Draftee armies don’t do well in colonial wars. In democracies, they cost pols votes. In dictatorships, they can cause system collapse, as with the Soviets in Afghanistan.
7.
germy
@Brachiator: I didn’t know Taibbi was so young. For some reason I thought he was older.
Also, typically (but not always) relatively well-off people found ways out of the draft.
(See: Trump)
9.
Botsplainer, Cryptofascist Tool of the Oppressor Class
Am in Yum Center now. The international outpouring of affection is HUGE! We went by the makeshift memorial in front of the Ali Center (been doing it all week) and it brings me nearly to tears every time.
@efgoldman: I think it was Cheney who was busy that day.
12.
germy
@The Golux: I think that’s what confused me. I think I merged father and son into one person in my mind… someone born in the late ’40s.
I’m old enough that I consider anyone who was ten years old when Lennon was shot to be a young person, no matter how much time has passed.
EDIT: Speaking of Lennon, I read somewhere that Ali met with John &Yoko and a promoter who was trying to reunite the Beatles for a charity event. Lennon & Ali had a mutual admiration thing going on.
@Amir Khalid: I don’t think any disrespect was intended; my guess is he’s slightly annoyed because one of the first responses to a fairly lengthy post he had just put up was, “Can we have an Ali funeral thread”?
Nothing wrong with that, per se, and I’m sure it wasn’t meant this way, but having experienced that myself, it’s a bit like presenting guests with a lovely platter of food and having them immediately demand pie.
23.
Face
it’s a bit like presenting guests with a lovely platter of food the same old HRC v. BS B.S. that we discuss every damn day and having them immediately demand pie a special thread for a special day for a special man.
FTFY.
24.
bystander
If I run into any recipes that require a bushel of tender feefees, I know where to find them.
The Vietnam experience profoundly shook up the Army. When I was commissioned in 1979, it was still reeling from that experience and it touched on almost every aspect of day-to-day military life.
@Gin & Tonic: I found it a little on the snotty side too. But we must remember that John’s knickers are still in an almighty twist from the last post, so he’s not his usual sweet self.
30.
eclare
Orrin Hatch? What am I missing?
31.
Quinerly
@eclare:
Exactly what I thought at first but Hatch is giving a nice eulogy. I’m smiling. I never smile about Hatch.
32.
eclare
@Quinerly: Yes, he’s answering my question. Just did a double take when he was announced!
@eclare:
Ali was a big Reagan supporter. There’s a famous quote. I won’t remember it exactly but when asked about why he was supporting Reagan he said that Reagan was keeping God in the classrooms and that was good enough for him. I’ll leave it at that. I don’t want to get started?
35.
raven
@eclare: All kinds of motherfuckers just love Ali now!
36.
lamh36
@eclare: Orrin Hatch…hm reminded of article that posed the question, what if Disease hadn’t essentially silenced Ali would “they” luv him still?
37.
gbbalto
@raven: L’ville paper says Hatch has been a friend for decades (who knew?) and was invited by his widow.
38.
raven
@gbbalto: I wasn’t referring to Orin. It’s all these other people who hated him when he stood up!
Nice eulogy by Hatch. Ali sought him out 28 years ago he said. We have to remember that Hatch and Teddy Kennedy were best buddies. That always amazed me.
40.
gbbalto
@raven: Got it. Curious about Hatch’s friendship, tho.
ETA – Thanks, Quinerly. Not able to listen myself just now.
41.
Quinerly
Friendship with Senator Hatch seemed to have been faith based….love of God. Muslim meets Mormon? What would Deadbeat Donnie say?
Pres Clinton, Billy Crystal, and family members up soon. I think NPR is carrying it. CNN was broadcasting it from the beginning. Think MSNBC started late.
47.
lamh36
@bjacques: ESPN has been showing it all day. TVONE also.
NBC national is showing it now as well.
If anything else, that should tell you the impact that Muhammad Ali had on folks internationally.
The all inclusive public ceremony was planned by Ali and his family for almost 10 years, according to reports. Ali apparently thought of it as an “educational” experience it’s multicultural, multi-faith, multi-political affair. Ali understood that this occasion may just be watched by millions and was an opportunity to teach.
48.
eclare
@lamh36: The breadth of speakers has been phenomenal…
Looking at Ali’s family -he had strong genes. The kids and grandkids. …. you can see Ali in them
52.
hovercraft
@eclare:
It’s an interfaith service Hatch to represent Mormons.and they were friends apparently.
53.
Baud
Didn’t watch most of it, but watching Billy Crystal now. Good stuff.
54.
oldgold
Chrystal, Gumbel and Clinton were very good.
55.
MazeDancer
Joining all those mentioning Billy Crystal. Brilliance. Magic woven words. Clearly he and Ali loved each other.
Hope vids are available soon.
56.
hovercraft
I lived the story about Ali asking Crystal at Howard Cosell’s funeral if he thought he was wearing his hairpiece in the closed casket, and them giggling like two school boys in church.
Crystal used to do a pretty good imitation of Ali in his act.
58.
muddy
@Betty Cracker: Only that wasn’t a really a lovely platter of food, it was just another extended scolding. I too would ask hopefully for pie if offered another plate of that.
59.
Betty Cracker
@muddy: Y’all feel free to tell Cole how to run his blog. I was just trying to explain to Amir why I don’t think he meant any disrespect to Ali.
60.
J R in WV
I loved Ali, understood his positions, except for the boxing on after he was wealthy.
But, really, I understand that too, it was something he could do better than everyone else. He must have loved that…
The Champion of all time.
Comments are closed.
Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!
germy
What the Pentagon learned from Muhammad Ali
Brachiator
Information on how to Watch Muhammad Ali funeral live
Brachiator
@germy:
Tabibbi was born in 1970 and yet claims that he and his buddies grew up with Ali as their champion. I don’t buy it. And he drastically oversimplifies the US military’s switch to an all volunteer army.
Chyron HR
I wrote a song to commemorate him:
I BLESS THE RAAAAAINS
DOWN IN AAAAAFRICAAAA
Gin & Tonic
It may be just me, but this kind of passive-aggressive posting (“There”) may be appropriate when some random asshole makes a comment about lack of a hoops thread, but I’d think you could do a little better to honor Ali and your readers who were, I’d bet, really in love with the man.
JMG
Tiabbi, a writer I enjoy, is just wrong. We went to a volunteer military because the Army damn near disintegrated in Vietnam. Draftee armies don’t do well in colonial wars. In democracies, they cost pols votes. In dictatorships, they can cause system collapse, as with the Soviets in Afghanistan.
germy
@Brachiator: I didn’t know Taibbi was so young. For some reason I thought he was older.
(Born in 1970 is “young” to me)
germy
@efgoldman:
(See: Trump)
Botsplainer, Cryptofascist Tool of the Oppressor Class
Am in Yum Center now. The international outpouring of affection is HUGE! We went by the makeshift memorial in front of the Ali Center (been doing it all week) and it brings me nearly to tears every time.
The Golux
@germy:
Could you be thinking of his father, Mike?
germy
@efgoldman: I think it was Cheney who was busy that day.
germy
@The Golux: I think that’s what confused me. I think I merged father and son into one person in my mind… someone born in the late ’40s.
I’m old enough that I consider anyone who was ten years old when Lennon was shot to be a young person, no matter how much time has passed.
EDIT: Speaking of Lennon, I read somewhere that Ali met with John &Yoko and a promoter who was trying to reunite the Beatles for a charity event. Lennon & Ali had a mutual admiration thing going on.
Elizabelle
@Botsplainer, Cryptofascist Tool of the Oppressor Class: Glad you are there. Can you send some pics, after the fact?
Muhammed Ali looks so good and honest and strong, looking back from 50 years forward. Rare, somewhat, in that aspect.
We must do a Louisville meetup one of these days. L’ville and Asheville are on the radar for post-Barcelona life.
Amir Khalid
I take it Muhammad Ali wasn’t one of your major personal heroes.
Punchy
Sacha Baron Cohen died?
Humboldtblue
Serena Williams finds a unique way to deal with the Trumps of the world.
Sweet mother of athletics she is one stunningly beautiful woman.
Elizabelle
@Punchy: Please, no. Not Ali G’s time yet.
He has much outrage still to commit.
Plus two kinda tiny kids (for now).
raven
@Gin & Tonic: What are you saying?
Dork
“Ali Funeral Open Thread” sounds like a post devoted to the bloviations involving a golf or tennis tournament honoring Ali’s passing.
PaulWartenberg2016
where have you gone
Muhammad Ali
Our nation turns its lonely eyes
to you…
Botsplainer, Cryptofascist Tool of the Oppressor Class
@Elizabelle:
I’ll do up an imgur later. Delayed…
Betty Cracker
@Amir Khalid: I don’t think any disrespect was intended; my guess is he’s slightly annoyed because one of the first responses to a fairly lengthy post he had just put up was, “Can we have an Ali funeral thread”?
Nothing wrong with that, per se, and I’m sure it wasn’t meant this way, but having experienced that myself, it’s a bit like presenting guests with a lovely platter of food and having them immediately demand pie.
Face
FTFY.
bystander
If I run into any recipes that require a bushel of tender feefees, I know where to find them.
Iowa Old Lady
@efgoldman: I grew up in Detroit during the Howe era. Even my Maple Leafs fan father admired Howe.
jharp
@Botsplainer, Cryptofascist Tool of the Oppressor Class:
Sounds very cool.
Sadly, I could not make the trip today.
Villago Delenda Est
@JMG: This.Right.Here.
The Vietnam experience profoundly shook up the Army. When I was commissioned in 1979, it was still reeling from that experience and it touched on almost every aspect of day-to-day military life.
raven
@Villago Delenda Est: And the stupid fuckers learned zip.
muddy
@Gin & Tonic: I found it a little on the snotty side too. But we must remember that John’s knickers are still in an almighty twist from the last post, so he’s not his usual sweet self.
eclare
Orrin Hatch? What am I missing?
Quinerly
@eclare:
Exactly what I thought at first but Hatch is giving a nice eulogy. I’m smiling. I never smile about Hatch.
eclare
@Quinerly: Yes, he’s answering my question. Just did a double take when he was announced!
Quinerly
@eclare:
Me too.
Quinerly
@eclare:
Ali was a big Reagan supporter. There’s a famous quote. I won’t remember it exactly but when asked about why he was supporting Reagan he said that Reagan was keeping God in the classrooms and that was good enough for him. I’ll leave it at that. I don’t want to get started?
raven
@eclare: All kinds of motherfuckers just love Ali now!
lamh36
@eclare: Orrin Hatch…hm reminded of article that posed the question, what if Disease hadn’t essentially silenced Ali would “they” luv him still?
gbbalto
@raven: L’ville paper says Hatch has been a friend for decades (who knew?) and was invited by his widow.
raven
@gbbalto: I wasn’t referring to Orin. It’s all these other people who hated him when he stood up!
Quinerly
@gbbalto: @gbbalto:
Nice eulogy by Hatch. Ali sought him out 28 years ago he said. We have to remember that Hatch and Teddy Kennedy were best buddies. That always amazed me.
gbbalto
@raven: Got it. Curious about Hatch’s friendship, tho.
ETA – Thanks, Quinerly. Not able to listen myself just now.
Quinerly
Friendship with Senator Hatch seemed to have been faith based….love of God. Muslim meets Mormon? What would Deadbeat Donnie say?
raven
@gbbalto: I agree.
MomSense
I’m sorry I couldn’t watch. My grandmother loved him so and would have been glued to her television today.
Origuy
The Guardian is live-blogging it if you can’t watch.
bjacques
BBC World is carrying it live. Amazing.
Quinerly
Pres Clinton, Billy Crystal, and family members up soon. I think NPR is carrying it. CNN was broadcasting it from the beginning. Think MSNBC started late.
lamh36
@bjacques: ESPN has been showing it all day. TVONE also.
NBC national is showing it now as well.
If anything else, that should tell you the impact that Muhammad Ali had on folks internationally.
The all inclusive public ceremony was planned by Ali and his family for almost 10 years, according to reports. Ali apparently thought of it as an “educational” experience it’s multicultural, multi-faith, multi-political affair. Ali understood that this occasion may just be watched by millions and was an opportunity to teach.
eclare
@lamh36: The breadth of speakers has been phenomenal…
rikyrah
This home going has been beautiful.
Thanks Cole.
rikyrah
@lamh36:
I love that he planned this service.
rikyrah
Looking at Ali’s family -he had strong genes. The kids and grandkids. …. you can see Ali in them
hovercraft
@eclare:
It’s an interfaith service Hatch to represent Mormons.and they were friends apparently.
Baud
Didn’t watch most of it, but watching Billy Crystal now. Good stuff.
oldgold
Chrystal, Gumbel and Clinton were very good.
MazeDancer
Joining all those mentioning Billy Crystal. Brilliance. Magic woven words. Clearly he and Ali loved each other.
Hope vids are available soon.
hovercraft
I lived the story about Ali asking Crystal at Howard Cosell’s funeral if he thought he was wearing his hairpiece in the closed casket, and them giggling like two school boys in church.
debbie
@MazeDancer:
Crystal used to do a pretty good imitation of Ali in his act.
muddy
@Betty Cracker: Only that wasn’t a really a lovely platter of food, it was just another extended scolding. I too would ask hopefully for pie if offered another plate of that.
Betty Cracker
@muddy: Y’all feel free to tell Cole how to run his blog. I was just trying to explain to Amir why I don’t think he meant any disrespect to Ali.
J R in WV
I loved Ali, understood his positions, except for the boxing on after he was wealthy.
But, really, I understand that too, it was something he could do better than everyone else. He must have loved that…
The Champion of all time.