What a shit day. Fortunately, we still have the Onion:
Avoid unkind generalizations like equating the jailing of ethnic minorities with some malevolent form of fascism.
Consider that we all have different perspectives stemming from things like age, ethnicity, or level of racism.
Recall that violently rejecting a tyrannical government goes against everything our forefathers believed in.
Find common ground by recognizing that some kids are huge assholes.
I used to hate protests because I hate crowds and I am always worried about crowds turning into mobs. That’s changed. It’s what we need.
Fuck civility.
EBT
The right removed themselves from polite society long ago. Enforcing their own choice isn’t uncivil.
Major Major Major Major
I enjoyed Man Who Has Never Seen Horseshoe Crab Before Understandably Freaking The Fuck Out as well.
JPL
As a member of a red state, I can tell you that What about the girls, What about the toddlers is a winning message, the rest not so much. Cole lives in WV and that will never flip, but GA has a good chance of electing a black woman and proud democrat as Governor. If you want protests, just remember that when we have a wacko governor. The message you and Anne get rid of Ice riles up the republican base.
The democratic base is riled up, but it’s not that big.
debbie
Fixed.
JPL
Also I can only access the updates through John’s twitter feed.
Mike in DC
I understand that if we march in white shirts and khakis, with tiki torches, we will be described as very fine people.
The Ancient Randonneur
Fuck Trump.
Fuck Civility.
Where are the girls?
Where are the toddlers?
Where are the infants?
Abolish ICE.
Fuck Trump.
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@JPL:
What if we also want to replace ICE with an agency that does what it’s supposed to do instead of rounding up children and putting them in camps?
A Ghost To Most
QFFT.
Mike in DC
@? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?:
Disband ICE, reform it, rehire only those who pass screening for implicit bias and white racial resentment and the presence of human empathy.
Roger Moore
@EBT:
Wasn’t it right wing icon Margaret Thatcher who said “There is no such thing as society”? How can anyone have removed themselves from something that doesn’t exist?
EBT
@? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?: Fuck that Abolish ICE, the things it does don’t need doing.
JPL
@The Ancient Randonneur: Just keep riling up that red state asshole base.
@? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?: Can we get elected first? just sayin
dmsilev
I don’t think it’s unreasonable to not care about being polite to people who proudly wore “Fuck your feelings!” shirts during the last campaign. Depending on one’s personal preferences, “As you sow, so shall you reap”, “do unto others as you would have them do unto you, “what goes around comes around”, “don’t dish it out if you can’t take it”, “stop whining, you pathetic mewler.”.
EBT
@JPL: The red state asshole base is already really goddamned riled up. Fuck ICE, send every last one to The Hague with complementary rope.
The Ancient Randonneur
@JPL:
The existence of black and brown people who don’t show the requisite amount of subservience riles them up. Fuck them and there feelings.
Major Major Major Major
I don’t have an opinion on whether a push to “abolish ICE” would rile up whose base or whatever, since that’s just something we can augur from polling data if we have to. But I do think it’s important to have a response to “and replace it with what?” As @EBT and @Mike in DC did. There are other possible responses too! But the challenge to the slogan is obvious and we should be prepared.
cmorenc
The best argument against public shaming confrontations of Trump Admin officials isn’t about civility at all – but rather about inadvertently distracting from media and public focus on what has proved a lethally fatal, unanswerable issue of the Trump Admin’s unacceptable cruelty, especially to children. Yes, they amply *deserve* colossal, irredeemable shaming over this of the sort usually reserved for child sexual molesters – but they have no shame and have repeatedly proved adept at turning attempts to shame them over behavior into a weapon of mass distraction from the core substantive damage they are doing with their actions.
Notice that the intense 24/7 media glare on the families and kids last week has become a bit more diluted this week, in part because of the shaming issue.
TenguPhule
The showers and ovens are visible on the horizon.
This is not hyperbole.
Via Wapo
JPL
@The Ancient Randonneur: They showed up for Ossoff, asshole. They’ll show up again along with the whites that care about issues that matter. The Atlanta mayor is great, but GA has a lot of republicans that only show up for issues like what you are pushing.
Maybe run on Medicare being stripped from them. Maybe run on where are the girls, where are the toddlers. Getting rid of ICE doesn’t resonate with them.
West of the Rockies
These are dark times… There is no denying.
Nicole
I still can’t believe some dumb sh*t on CNN claimed protesters in the 1960s were more civil. Every time I think we’ve reached peak stupidity…
JPL
The democrats need to run on issues.
Health Care
Medicare
Social Security
Tax cuts for the wealthy
How did Lamb win?
MisterForkbeard
@TenguPhule:
This is true, but not for the reason Trump thinks it is. Is someone next to him saying “No, sir! They’re saying…. Boo-urns! Burns!”
JPL
@Nicole: And then we had Nixon.
EBT
@Major Major Major Major: NOTHING! ICE is less than twenty years old. It does NOTHING THAT NEEDS DOING.
Matt McIrvin
I think we’re gonna lose no matter what, the deck is just too stacked and anything we do will be declared exactly the wrong thing that was our downfall, so we might as well just say what’s right and fuck the optics. When they shoot us all we die satisfied.
JPL
@Matt McIrvin: Conor Lamb. He ran on the issues.
M4
@EBT: I mean, it used to be part of another department, executing the same general responsibilities. I was just saying that itâs important to have an answer.
JPL
John, The site is really f.ked for me, since I can only get new posts from your twitter feed.
EBT
@M4: Then review each power and delegate them back to the original regulatory agencies? In practice most of what ICE actually does is racism though.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@EBT: Before ICE we had the Border Patrol(Justice), Customs(Treasury), and INS(Justice).
ETA: M4 pretty much got there before I did.
M4
@EBT: this isnât a quiz! I donât have an answer either.
Jeffro
@JPL:
I’m sure you meant, “the wealthy go back to paying their fair share” there.
Nevertheless…we’re Democrats, not Republicans: we can walk AND chew gum. Say it with me:
– Protect Social Security
– End job-killing tariffs
– Medicare for all
– No caging toddlers
– College and career training for all
– Respected in the world again
– Women’s rights are human rights
– Reign in ICE
– End corporate welfare
– Restore the rule of law
See? It only takes a couple extra seconds ;)
WereBear
Back from primary voting.
MisterForkbeard
@Jeffro:
Okay, but what if the toddler is president? Can we cage that one?
Nicole
@JPL: But let’s be honest, Nixon was about whites freaking out about the Civil Rights Act, which only got passed after an awful lot of incivility. We’re already living through Nixon Part 2, Moronic Bugaboo.
Quaker in a Basement
Perfect.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@Nicole:
Worst movie EVER!
schrodingers_cat
The site is still fucked up.
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@JPL:
I agree. Matt is being a real debbie downer tonight. I just think we can point to ICE’s abuses and run on issues that you pointed out at the same time.
Jeffro
@MisterForkbeard:
There’s an exception to every rule, ey?
JPL
@Nicole: They still are. I want them to stay home.
@EBT: Curious what state do you live in?
Mary G
Reposting from the last thread, because it’s still my mood:
Jeffro
@Nicole: @?BillinGlendaleCA:
Isn’t that why some folks call this whole sorry mess “Stupid Watergate”?
EBT
@?BillinGlendaleCA: We still have Border Patrol running around being inhuman fiends. Like I said last night:
Anyone who says âthis is not who we areâ is lying to themselves. This is precisely what america is. A grinding behemoth that chews up minorities and poor people and demolishes their lives. This happened under Obama, under every President, in just this way or (often) worse. The American ruling class has always remained the same, dedicated to a political project that necessitates imprisonment, wage slavery, etc. If youâre sicked by ICE wait until you find out what the rest of the government does.
EBT
@JPL: Born and lived in NC to adulthood then bounced around between TX, VA, AR and NC before landing here in CA (where I am about to move in a couple weeks out of)
JPL
@schrodingers_cat: lol I can link to the site through John’s twitter feed. It’s a conspiracy.
Mary G
No surprise here. I am marching on Saturday in Irving.
The Ancient Randonneur
@JPL:
Yes, I am a very proud asshole. I’ll wear that name with great pride. I’m done worrying about the feelings of people who support a fucking white supremacist. I’m a white male with some financial resources. I could just sit down and stfu and I’ll be fine. But fuck that. Being polite doesn’t win election. Getting like minded people registered and to the polls wins election. But, please, continue to be polite to the vile racists and find the right message so they don’t get riled up. Fuck them and there feelings.
JPL
@EBT: Raised in MA and lived in TX, LA, CT, IL, TX and now GA. I am proud that I never voted for Nixon. Cole is not gonna flip his state, but we are close to electing a democratic Governor, which is why I am so passionate that we run on issues.
Went to high school with Lieberman’s wife.
TenguPhule
@?BillinGlendaleCA:
Paulie Shore as Trump.
TenguPhule
@schrodingers_cat:
WordPress will continue until morale improves.
EBT
@JPL: I am from the mountains of NC. Real hillbilly stock. Turned out the partner I was dating in Arkansas had a common relative with me like 7 generations back.
JPL
@The Ancient Randonneur: It could lose elections.. just sayin, but you keep feeling that way. I’m more concerned with winning on issues. The democratic party has issues, the repubs have hate.
kindness
Imho the Republican base runs around crapping it’s pants as policy. While I don’t whack hornet’s nests with a stick, I won’t go out of my way to piss off those who’ve already crapped their pants. But I do find it civilized to tell them crapping one’s pants is really toddlerish and they ain’t helping themselves. Screw them. Every single one of them will vote. We need to think more about motivating OUR side and not giving a whole bunch of concern about theirs. In my opinion.
EBT
@JPL: donnie has 88% approval with his party. His base can’t really get riled up much more.
JPL
Cole’s twitter feed has this
Wow.. Trump is not gonna be happy
Thoughtful David
I think one of the things to do as well is to surround all of the ICE offices, detention camps, and Tender Age Concentration Camps, and video, close up, everyone going in or out, and their vehicles. Get ICE officers faces and name badges. Get civilian employees’ faces and name badges. Also get the faces of the detainees they’re bringing in or out. Use one of the video apps that uploads the video directly to the cloud, so they can’t take your phone/camera away and destroy the video. Then save that information on a server in Canada or New Zealand or somewhere.
I’m not saying display it in the web or doxxing anyone, but just make sure we have it recorded and stored safely. And make sure they know we’ve got it. It may make some of the not-quite-so-evil ones think about what their future will be, if they ever leave the US borders and suddenly get a free trip to The Hague. And if the detainees faces are all recorded, it may make reuniting them easier as well.
M4
@JPL: how we conduct immigration enforcement is an issue.
Another Scott
If I were asked, I’d probably say something like:
– We (as a Party) need a simple national message. Something that can go on a bumper sticker. “America is Beautiful, not Fearful.” Something like that.
– Candidates need to run on local issues, while standing up for national principles. “We can fix our schools and our hospitals and help people in pain. And we have no business having a national policy of stripping children from their parents.”
– Civility is over-rated, but we have to remember that when our lizard brains are riled up then our pre-frontal cortex shuts down. We can be angry – and we should be angry – but anger isn’t sensible policy to address problems and find solutions.
– The main thing is, we can’t continue to let the GOP set the agenda and decide what they (and the press) are going to talk about. We need to talk about our issues and our policies and how we’re reaching out to voters.
Quinnipaic Poll:
We have the issues, we have the enthusiasm, we have the support. We need to not be distracted.
133 days to go. Eyes on the prize…
Cheers,
Scott.
JPL
@EBT: Approval does not necessarily equate to voting though. At least I hope so. What I’m seeing is the democrats in GA are going to vote and the repubs are kinda blah about it. That could change. Local politics is my thing, but I get a lot of feedback there. I’m north of Atlanta.
TenguPhule
@EBT:
Trump: Hold my fucking extra large milkshake.
/People should know better then to tempt fate like this by now.
lollipopguild
@JPL: Levatich is being shrill and uncivil, all of the bothsides people will be all over him.
JPL
@M4: True, but getting rid of ICE is not. I know that sounds contradictory, but it’s how you frame it. Where are the girls, and where are the toddlers.
lamh36
TW…is da SHS REALLY getting SS protection?
Muthaphucka FOR WHAT?
James E Powell
I never hated protests but I still wonder whether they do any good.
I prefer civil disobedience. Things that cause the system to come to a stop.
EBT
@JPL: The real question isn’t how much of the GOP likes him, it’s how big is the GOP now, compared to two years ago.
EBT
So we can point and laugh at someone else for once; here is analysis of Brexit from the US Embassy in London. https://twitter.com/davemacladd/status/1011636382786314240 (The source is a documentary on channel 4 called “Inside the Embasy”)
JPL
@EBT: It’s shrinking.
James E Powell
@Matt McIrvin:
Yore more Eeyore than me! And that’s no mean feat. But I agree that we should not let cable news dickweeds tell us how to register our objections to what Trump & the GOP are doing.
We must always keep in mind that the Villagers don’t really have any objections to what Trump & the GOP are doing. If they did, they’d do something to stop it. But they really don’t, do they?
M4
@JPL: just sounded like you might have been veering into ârun on policy, not âidentity politicsâ!â territory.
EBT
@JPL: That has been my take as well, but I was hoping someone had some hard and fast numbers to salivate over.
JPL
@M4: It’s all about the framing.
DCrefugee
@lamh36:
The optics. The base. Tomorrow’s outrage.
M4
@JPL: I personally think âabolish Immigration and Customs Enforcementâ sounds a lot like âabolish immigration and customs enforcementâ and might not be an awesome slogan! But I could be wrong, I often am.
schrodingers_cat
@JPL: I have to fill in my nym and other details again and again despite asking the site to remember it.
schrodingers_cat
@M4: How about, make them accountable. We can’t totally get rid of immigration and border enforcement.
West of the Rockies
@EBT:
My understanding is that the party has shrunk… Fewer people self-identity as Republican. Just today, Steve Schmidt renounced party affiliation with the GOP. (I for one welcome this news: he is flawed, but eloquent; he can talk to and about Republicans with some authority.)
Anyway, 88% of 28% of the country strongly supports Trump. That’s not really all that special.
CarolDuhart2
‘JPL: Governors races aren’t really about immigration issues, are they? Perhaps she should just say that she’s concerned about the kids and leave it like that.
For years, liberals have been intimidated by talk about “soft on crime, drugs”, to the point where even speaking up was considered dangerous to electoral process-and in the wake of the 1960’d upheaval, it was probably prudent. Clinton in 1992 and 1994 had to carefully thread the needle on this stuff. But cringing in fear gets nothing in return anymore, not when the other side cages babies and refugees. All it gets us now is David Axelrod and (RIP) Alan Colmes Democrats who still live in fear and are also ineffective as well.
DCrefugee
@JPL: Looks like it’s a Twitter-only thing. Googling fails to reveal any news or other site with this quote except on the Twitter machine, and one of the posters retracted it…
Another Scott
TheHill:
Good, good.
Eyes on the prize…
Cheers,
Scott.
Ladyraxterinok
@JPL: Read yrs ago that Liebermann took part in a freedom ride during Civil Rights Movement. Do you know if this is correct?
JPL
@M4: My son often wears his Science is not a liberal conspiracy tee. Last weekend four people in his local Publix stopped him, two in a Fresh Market. In my local Publix, the check out gal said it was time for her to pay attention. She had no idea about the tariffs.
M4
@schrodingers_cat: I think thatâs a great idea. I am not so sure we want to use the âabolish ICE!â framing if what we actually want is to reform ICE. Also, simplistic unachievable sloganeering is not my most favorite thing. We saw what happened to the people who spent eight years screaming ârepeal Obamacareâ once they caught that car.
Iâve already seen lefties making a stink about how democrats in congress wonât repeat this new shibboleth.
JPL
@CarolDuhart2: In GA the repubs are running on the illegals. One has a pickup truck.
lamh36
Omnes Omnibus
@M4:
EmoProgs gotta EmoProg.
EBT
@M4: Honestly? If it turns out ICE sold more than a few of those girls in to sexual slavery, ICE won’t have anywhere the broad popularity that the PPACA has with the voting public. Doesn’t hurt that removing ICE won’t cause a huge dinger to folks healthcare either.
JR
I think Democrats (and candidates generally) would be wise to completely ignore major media outlets as an information source. You can still broadcast via the media, just don’t consume it. *Especially* the editorial component. Even when favorable.
EBT
@JPL: Bus guy lost the primary in like 5th place.
Omnes Omnibus
Test comment
lamh36
@West of the Rockies: self-identify, but still vote exclusively Republican. So does that really count as “shrinking” really?
JPL
@Ladyraxterinok: That’s actually true. I never met him in person, but I did know his wife.
She was a few years ahead of me, but came to my house because of my older sister. The church that I went to took in her family when they came to the states and her father started the local synagogue. That was fifty plus years ago.
Another Scott
@JPL: All the GOP can do anymore is run on scaring people. There are ways to win in spite of that, but yelling louder at them in return usually isn’t a big part of the tactic.
HistoryOnTheNet:
Wallace lost. We can defeat Trump and his minions and get back on a sensible path. But we have to work for the future we want – not just yell about it.
Cheers,
Scott.
JPL
@EBT: Brian Kemp is in a runoff against Cagle. Kemp has the pickup truck. Cagle is the one they have on tape saying he only voted to take money from public schools to fund private schools, because of the election.
Cagle also was caught having an aide under his desk, and his excuse was she was tying his shoes. Kemp is the gun guy and the pickup truck that can take the illegals to the border.
Hope this was not tmi.
lamh36
Trying my best not to call them all DUMB FUQs on here. But here’s Joy Ann with a better analysis…
Thread here: https://twitter.com/JoyAnnReid/status/1011777200784396288
M4
@EBT: right, but itâs good to have an implementation already agreed upon.
Omnes Omnibus
@lamh36: Like you said: Dumb fucks.
Marcopolo
@Another Scott: Pretty much agree with this. While the situation at the border & Trumpâs foundational lies about immigrants are abhorrent, it is the singular issue that still gets the R base rabidly lathered up. So sure letâs address & condemn that but ALSO talk about R attacks on affordable healthcare, how they want to dismantle SS, Medicare & Medicaid to pay for their tax cuts for the wealthy & corporations, and hammer them for the damage Trumpâs trade/tariff policies is/will cause to farmers, folks working in manufacturing, and anyone who will be paying more for stuff like cars & washing machines…
Just my 2 cents.
Iâll be damned if I only focus on the shiny object the Trumpublicans want me to focus on.
Platonailedit
@Another Scott:
The dem base has to put as much energy into voting as it does on outrage. Value your vote. Every two years, not just every four years.
Peale
@M4: the problem is that the groups the slogan is most popular with are activists who represent very few actual voters. Maybe potential voters someday, but not people who can actually vote.
I do want to smash ICE. Drawn down its numbers. It has to be done before almost any other reform. Part of the problem we have now is that every positive immigration reform since 1965 has needed to include stepped up enforcement levels in order to get enough conservative votes to pass. And sometimes, enforcement is all that passes. Thatâs on steroids with Trump. Wanna save 500,000 DACA folks? Build a wall and fund his 100k immigration cop force. That connection needs to be broken. Take ICE down to 1999 levels first. Then weâre we can try to pass immigration reforms. Weâll end up needing to agree to increase those forces again to get it anyway, so for once letâs not start from the hypermilitarized levels we have currently.
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@lamh36:
We probably won’t know whether the GOP has truly shrunk until a few election cycles have passed. My gut says that it has but I wouldn’t bet the farm on it. We need to keep focusing on voter turnout and doing whatever we can to voice our opposition to this regime’s horrible actions.
CarolDuhart2
Most candidates are focusing on healthcare and daily life. Your state senator isn’t going overboard on this. Let rank and file Democrats who aren’t running for anything take care of this. Caging kids isn’t something that should be just let go because it just might get that angry white lady madder than usual.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@Marcopolo: I mentioned this story in the late night thread, about a guy and his mom helping out with his brother’s landscape business and a woman who told them they should all be deported. The link wasn’t up at the time, but here’s the story.
EBT
@lamh36: Independants are liking donnie less and less. I wonder if that change coincides with more people moving from GOP but doesn’t like donnie, over to Independant (as opposed to independant which was GOP but chickenshit about it).
Omnes Omnibus
@CarolDuhart2: My Rep., Mark Pocan (whose reelection isn’t remotely in doubt), is working hard on it. Congress is actually responding intelligently. Maxine and Ted are being loud; it won’t hurt them. Manchin is being careful; we want him rather than a GOPer.
lamh36
EBT
@M4: Looking at the border can go back to border patrol, and nothing can have the de facto federal SWAT force powers ICE currently has.
Another Scott
@?BillinGlendaleCA: It’s kinda freaky how much she looks like my late mother. :-/
:-(
Cheers,
Scott.
JPL
@?BillinGlendaleCA: In the olden days, that would be news, but now we have Maxine.
For those keeping up with MA politics, Baker’s son is trying to claim he was asleep when he groped the woman on the plane. I doubt his father stands behind him on this one, but who knows.
lamh36
FUQ HER!
Melania Trump set for second trip to immigration facilities @CNNPolitics https://cnn.it/2yHsdq1
Mary G
We have a Cantor-Brat upset going in NY-14
With 68.4% of the votes in, Ocasio is beating the pants off Crowley:
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 9,308 56.9%
Joe Crowley* 7,038 43.1%
MagdaInBlack
@lamh36:
This is why there is no point trying to reason with these cult members.
None. Zero. Zip. Zilch.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@EBT: The Border Patrol wasn’t any different than ICE. They didn’t get any new powers when they moved to DHS.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@JPL: It was news here in LA last night.
TenguPhule
@?BillinGlendaleCA:
Stupidity and Bigotry aren’t superpowers?
James E Powell
@lamh36:
President Obama emphatically insisted that Americans are one people. From the ’04 DNC keynote to his last SOTU he was emphatic on this point. White Americans just as emphatically rejected him & the vision of America as diverse & inclusive. This is the political issue of our time and it is not being addressed as directly as it needs to be.
The press/media have been dancing around racism for years with euphemisms, bothsiderism, and a rock hard rule – as Charles Pierce always says – that it is never about race.
B.B.A.
@Mary G: Holy shite. The NYSDC will have to work extra hard to rig the Gov primary in the fall. //
debbie
@? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?:
Sigh.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@TenguPhule: No, they already possessed those powers.
B.B.A.
Boys tweet #AbolishICE. Men tweet #AbolishCBP.
Mary G
@Mary G: Thread from her, how we should do it – focus on people who’ve never voted:
The kids are all right.
debbie
@lamh36:
Can’t wait to see her “secret” message to us.
TenguPhule
@James E Powell:
They rejected the bread and salt. They shall receive the flame and the scourge.
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@?BillinGlendaleCA:
That witch of a woman is the one that should be deported. If I had been there and she put her middle finger in my face I would have been tempted to grab it and brake it. What a rotten piece of shit.
Mary G
@B.B.A.: Andrew Cuomo is running left as fast as he can.
Dorothy Winsor
Are there interesting primary results yet? I don’t know enough about most of the races going on today to interpret the bits I’m hearing.
ETA: I scanned some comments above mine and see what I asked for. BJ is ahead of me.
lamh36
TenguPhule
@lamh36:
Damn. I only managed to stockpile 4 bottles.
Back to the Japanese stuff then.
Starfish
@Peale: Get everyone elected, and just defund ICE. Give them enough money to have one SUV per state. Fix the rule about the 100 mile thing that the ACLU suggested or do something like ban gun stores in the same border and see how quickly Republicans reduce it. ;)
patroclus
Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s dissent in the Muslim ban case is epic and monumental – I strongly urge all to read it!
Aleta
lamh36
Mary G
Wow – Oklahoma:
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@Mary G:
She was endorsed by groups such as the Justice Democrats, who are affiliated with the Young Turks. I’m mildly suspicious, but if she’s a good candidate that a lot of people want and will beat the Republican then I can’t complain
? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?
@TenguPhule:
Hasn’t Japan been hit with tariffs too?
Matt McIrvin
@Platonailedit: Every year! In most places, there’s usually something going on in the odd years, even if it’s just voting for the School Board or Register of Probate or something. Keeping your hand in makes it that much less likely that they’ll yank your registration in some bullshit inactive-voter sweep, and it also means you keep track of where your polling station is and how to vote. And sometimes these local races affect your life more than national elections do.
gbbalto
Well, what is our alternative immigration policy? I get the impression that most of us don’t want open borders, so what do we propose to replace what we’ve got?
I’m trying to think of an alternative, but have no great wisdom to offer. However, if we want to change the policy, we need to have an alternative to propose, otherwise Trump/Repubs will just keep claiming that we want open borders, full stop.
Sorry, no great thoughts here, but we need something.
Omnes Omnibus
@gbbalto: Continuing prior policy which fucking worked.
gbbalto
@Omnes Omnibus: Did it? We had lots of migrants come in to do work that Americans wouldn’t do (mostly because they couldn’t run a household on the shit wages) but they were always one wrong move away from suddenly being shipped out. That only worked for their red-blooded American employers who could underpay them or shaft them with no consequences. It didn’t work so well for the migrants.
ETA: Or rat them out if they got uppity
Omnes Omnibus
@gbbalto: It sure as fuck worked better than Trump’s policies are. The big concern, I thought, was the asylum applicants. Are we fighting about US immigration in general,? I wasn’t aware.
clay
@Mary G: Is this good or bad? What kind of Dem is Crowley?
gbbalto
@Omnes Omnibus: We need a general amnesty for undocumented immigrants (a hard sell for other than the Dreamers, I suspect) but then what?
ETA: I absolutely agree about asylum seekers fleeing horrible situations. But what should the policy be for immigrants otherwise? Certainly a reform of the green card quota system.
Omnes Omnibus
@gbbalto: Do you also want a pony?
seaboogie
@EBT: ICE reminds me of security guards – if you canât get into the police force because you fail to meet their standards, then security guard. If you want to be a police, but are at heart too much of a racist asshole for even the cops, then ICE is your answer.
gbbalto
@Omnes Omnibus: I want a proposal that actually has a chance of working. This country has been dodging the issue for decades. Now we have the full on reactionary policy. What do Democrats propose instead?
Villago Delenda Est
@Roger Moore: People danced in the street upon learning of her death.
What a wonderful legacy!
?BillinGlendaleCA
@? ?? Goku (aka Amerikan Baka) ? ?: Witch wasn’t the word that came to mind when I saw the story on the 11pm news last night, though the word did rhyme with witch*. I’m sure she was just economically anxious.
*h/t to Barbara Bush.
jl
@gbbalto:
” This country has been dodging the issue for decades. ”
I think more accurately, the Congressional GOP has blocked a solution to the issue for at least a decade. Even W had reasonable good-faith proposals, but rest of the GOP didn’t want to give up the racist wedge issue.
Why don’t you offer your ideas on an immigration proposal?
Omnes Omnibus
@gbbalto: Nah, you propose. I said the previous system seem to be functioning.
gbbalto
@jl: @Omnes Omnibus:
The previous system did not function well for undocumented workers!
General amnesty for everyone who is already here. As I said, may be a hard sell for other than Dreamers.
Proper consideration for asylum seekers per international treaties and U.S. law.
Green cards with a guarantee of being able to become a citizen within a reasonable amount of time.
We have nothing clear out there. I welcome any input that you can provide.
Matt McIrvin
@gbbalto: Do you want “if I were king”, or some policy that we think would actually have some chance of being politically viable?
If I were king, I’d opt for something very close to open borders. Basically, let people come in and get on a path to citizenship if there’s no particular evidence that they’re major-league criminals. The character of the US would permanently change… so be it. Citizenship would still depend on at least a declaration that they’re committed to the pluralism enshrined in the Constitution, which would put them ahead of many native-borns today. The US might be motivated not to create situations that propel a lot of refugees.
I know that’s not going to happen and even proposing it makes people freak out and countermobilize, like gay marriage in 2000.
gbbalto
@Matt McIrvin: I would settle for politically viable. No point in “if I were king.” You are right about the political difficulties. Not sure how to get around them.
Chetan Murthy
@Major Major Major Major: M4, uh, since youi’re an SF local, could I ask you a Q? I’ve gone to a number of marches, but I’m shit-ass-no-good at making posters. Do you know a shop I could go to, that’d print a poster? AdvThanksance
jl
@gbbalto:
Thanks. I think you are making a mistake in terms of what the Democrats have to do. The GOP has a simple strong message because they are willing to lie ruthlessly. Immigration will always be a contentious issue, with complicated interests that cross-cut usual partisan interests. So, if you are saying that the Democrats need a fully articulated and detailed plan that they need to sell like the GOP does, that is impossible, since the GOP just lies nonstop.
I think the Democrats need to do a better job countering GOP lies. And they need a simple message that outlines the direction and guiding philosophy of their proposals, and simple messages for their most important major proposals. But they shouldn’t try to get into all the weeds.
I don’t know about the technicalities of immigration so I have to talk in general terms.
I think the HB visa programs need to be reformed. I think the programs that ship in, for example, Bulgarian workers for Trump properties for three or six months should be ended. I don’;t understand the need for that. I think high skilled HB visas should be reformed to make them less like indentured servitude, those people should be given green card and be free to change jobs if they want as quickly as possible.
Agriculture needs a carve out of some kind for guest workers. I don’t like guest worker programs, but I think for some types of labor it might be a necessary evil that we make as less evil as possible. I think they will be needed unless the US passes laws that protect that work enough to make it socially respectable and reliable way to make a working class living, I don’t think the US is willing to do that, thought I think it should.
jl
@Matt McIrvin: Economically I don’t see a problem with open borders, or something close to it. Socially, i don’t see a problem either, if the US were willing to provide adequately funded social services, and English as a second language education.
I think modern problems with international criminal activity like human trafficking, dangerous drugs, and terrorism as main impediments to having something close to an open borders policy.
The US had essentially an open borders policy for most of Latin America, including the dire Mexican threat (/snark) until well into the 20th century. Despite the hate and lies about Hispanic immigration, we had open borders for a century after we took the land and the US did just fine.
Duane
Civility left the fucking room when republicans barfed up Trump. Until the stinking pile is cleaned up civilty said fuckem.
EBT
@?BillinGlendaleCA: Pretty sure I expressly said that earlier in this thread.
Gravie
We have a weekly protest here in our small (less than 100,000) Central Oregon city. The last couple of weeks have focused on the family separation policies and that stolen children. One of the greatest things is the number of passing cars who honk, wave, and otherwise show their support. The drivers and passengers always look ecstatic that someone is saying it.
Wag
@Jeffro:
â Reign in ICE
Um, I think you mean rein in ICE. If ICE is allowed to reign, weâre all fucked.
Hkedi [Kang T. Q.]
@jl: Thank you for that thought jl. I never considered it that way, but YES! if you are willing to ignore all of the contradictions it’s really easy to put forward a coherent message. 9,999 times out of 10,000 it will get murdered by a nasty fact, but if you ignore the facts it’s easy!
I’m not being snarky. Almost always an easy answer has an argument in bad faith or thought at the root (Or Both!). I’ve never considered it from that angle.
KSinMA
@patroclus: Darn tootin’! God Bless Justice Sotomayor!!!
?BillinGlendaleCA
@EBT: That’s certainly not what I got out of what you were saying, you said that we should go back to the Border Patrol, there is no difference between ICE and the Border Patrol.
sukabi
@lamh36: Ice is abusing lawyers now. If she can’t get assault charges against him, a civil suit might be in order.