By now you are well aware that Sondland has basically destroyed any remaining narrative the Republicans had left in their defense of Trump, so we are on to the next inevitable stage, which is the smearing of Sondland and moving twoards “what’s wrong with quid pro quo.'”
The big thing to remember here, though, is that there is a reason the White House is trashing Sondland, and it’s not because they think they can impeach his testimony. It’s to send a message to those who haven’t testified. To date, everyone who has testified has been someone, who, although possibly Republican, has never been a member of the Republican apparatus. Rick Perry, Mike Pompeo, Mick Mulvaney, and the various chiefs of staff that Goldman called out by name during the hearings today have not.
So the message is clear, especially to folks like Pompeo, who want to run for office. Testify, and we will ruin you. It’s basically witness tampering by another name. But Perry and the others get it- if I testify, I am done in Republican politics. Even if you have to face consequences, you don’t want to end up like Big Pussy and getting a couple dozen to the chest and thrown off the Stugots.
Also, just an aside, if you are ever doing an image search for Big Pussy from the Sopranos do NOT forget to include the name of the show in your search- I will not make that mistake again.
Noah Brand
The way Fox has been running with Trump’s “I want nothing” line inspired me to make this: https://imgur.com/gallery/QpUbQRx
schrodingers_cat
Its not like Tangerine man is winning them races, look at Kansas and Louisiana. Why are all elected Rs still lock step with him. What are they afraid of?
rikyrah
@schrodingers_cat:
They are all compromised ??
Yarrow
@rikyrah: Yep. People like to pretend they’re afraid for their political futures. I think it’s more like they’re afraid for their futures in general. Whatever kompromat Putin has on them must be pretty juicy.
schrodingers_cat
@rikyrah: I expected more Rs to join Justin Amash. The sainted Will Hurd has not covered himself in glory in these hearings. He is even retiring, why not show some spine now.
Elizabelle
Hearings about to start again, although folks are milling around and not seated yet.
C-Span is streaming live. And the GOP do have their idiot signboards up. “It’s been X days since Adam Schiff knew the identity of the whistleblower …”
https://www.c-span.org/video/?466379-1/impeachment-hearing-laura-cooper-david-hale&live
Yarrow
Cooper and Hale are in their seats for the next hearing.
zhena gogolia
Just watched a clip of Maloney. I need a cigarette.
Yarrow
@Elizabelle: CNN is covering it.
schrodingers_cat
@Yarrow: Yes that’s what I am getting at they seem to be afraid of polonium tea, if you get my drift not the next election. Even those who are retiring have shown no backbone.
Elizabelle
The witnesses arrive. Laura Cooper looks resolute. This is a rather tough time of day to testify, don’t you think??
C-Span.
Impeachment Hearing with Laura Cooper and David Hale
debbie
@schrodingers_cat:
His primary voters.
Kamala.Harris.2020
And, of course, the final stage which is no doubt coming: “Sure, the President explicitly told people to bribe other people …. but he was just JOKING.”
NotMax
Never having seen the program (nor having the slightest curiosity to do so) am grateful you explained whence that moniker comes, even if have no knowledge of the context surrounding the character in question.
And… the committee has been gaveled back into session.
Elizabelle
@Yarrow: It’s the money and the cheating. And maybe some personal stuff too.
Yarrow
@schrodingers_cat: Yep. It’s kind of baffling unless you consider that they’re afraid for themselves and their families.
schrodingers_cat
@debbie: That doesn’t explain the reticence of those who are retiring to taken on Agent Orange.
Goku (aka Amerikan Baka)
@Yarrow:
Yeah, but these guys are Members of Congress with security details. Would Putin dare attack high profile elected officials or their families on American soil?
Or are you talking about kompromat that would be embarrassing or even put them in legal jeopardy, such as treason?
Yarrow
@Elizabelle:
Yes, especially since it was supposed to be at 2:30 pm.
NotMax
Fast becoming sick of the multitudinous refreshes before a comment shows up.
debbie
@schrodingers_cat:
It absolutely explains it. They want to keep their seat. If they are seen not to be vociferously supporting Trump, his supporters will see that they get a seat on the next train out of town.
Putin doesn’t have to do anything. Trumpies will take care of everything for him.
Yarrow
@Goku (aka Amerikan Baka): The answer is yes to all of the above as to what Russia might have on these Republicans and what might embarrass them and/or put them in legal trouble. Re: Putin’s attacks, if they are no longer in office they don’t have security detail, etc.
Yarrow
@debbie: But some, like Will Hurd, have already announced they are retiring. What’s he got to lose?
Roger Moore
@schrodingers_cat:
They’re afraid of losing all the other stuff the party uses to ensure loyalty. It looks like they’re in a hopeless situation. If they back Trump, it will hurt them in the general election. If they don’t back him, it will hurt them in the primary.
But that’s not all they have to lose. If they remain loyal, they will get wingnut welfare when they’re voted out of office, and when the party starts winning elections again they can hope to run again or be appointed to some position in the next Republican administration. They lose all that if they go against the party, at least until such time as the party apparatus decides it’s time to turn against Trump as an institution.
zhena gogolia
Fuck! Every time I tune in it’s fucking Nunes!!!!!
Yarrow
You have got to be kidding. He’s back to Chalupa.
jl
Many people are saying the sinister and sneaky Never Trumpers gave him million dollar contributions just in order to gain his trust and then betray him. Poor Trump, he is always a victim.
Elizabelle
ALEXANDRA CHALUPA!
(sip)
schrodingers_cat
@debbie: They are retiring so won’t be running in the primaries for 2020. Why should they care about primary voters?
Yarrow
Does anyone know if there will be hearings next week? Or are they taking a break for Thanksgiving.
Elizabelle
@zhena gogolia:
It’s like Groundhog Day. In Hell.
Hunter Biden. (sip)
topclimber
Mad hats off to CS and Walt. And thanks to a much older friend for remembering the original.
Nunes in Sonderland,
How did you get to Sonderland?
Over the line and underhand
And now you’re up a tree.
Nunes hates Sonderland.
Off with his head that Sonderland,
Tweedle Dee Dee and also Dum
But not as much as thee.
Nunes in Sonderland,
Better you stay in Blunder Land.
Your face looks aghast and also lost
But mine shines gleefully.
schrodingers_cat
@Roger Moore: Yes to all that but just surprising that only one person has defected from their ranks until now.
David ??Booooooo?? Koch
@schrodingers_cat: because he doesn’t want to foreclose a lucrative slice of wingnut welfare (lobbyist, fox news contributor, think tank fellow, paid corporate speaker).
Ruff the Dog
Or to put it another way, Rudy’s not the only one with insurance. Some salesperson made his or her entire quota with this crowd.
schrodingers_cat
@zhena gogolia: He is so oily and gross.
Enhanced Voting Techniques
@Goku (aka Amerikan Baka): You guys are over thinking this, they are afraid their county club will black ball them and they will be cut off from their friends. This how these cult like groups like Flat Earthers work.
debbie
@Yarrow:
also @schrodinger’s cat:
I haven’t heard Hurd defending Trump like the others have. Did I miss something
ETA: It’s not realistic to expect them to come out aggressively against Trump.
jonas
Oh, they trotted this out some time ago: “But Obama and Biden put conditions on US aid to Ukraine, too! See? Same thing!” All they got left is “There’s nothing wrong with using foreign aid as a way of shaking down countries to produce dirt on your domestic political opponents.” Trump of course believed that in 2016 when he gleefully accepted Russia’s help in kneecapping Clinton, but they’ve moved on to saying all the quiet parts out loud now and don’t give a sh*!.
jonas
Oh, they trotted this out some time ago: “But Obama and Biden put conditions on US aid to Ukraine, too! See? Same thing!” All they got left is “There’s nothing wrong with using foreign aid as a way of shaking down countries to produce dirt on your domestic political opponents.” Trump of course believed that in 2016 when he gleefully accepted Russia’s help in kneecapping Clinton, but they’ve moved on to saying all the quiet parts out loud now and don’t give a shit.
Jay
@Yarrow:
it’s being over thought. These are not the pipple who made the koolaide, ( that was Newt and previous generations),
these are pipple who have drunk the koolaide all their lives while living inside of the Faux News Bubble.
yes, they truely believe that down is up, up is down, Treason is not supporting Putin and Jeasus fed the multitudes for a price and got a 20% tithe from the moneychangers in the Temple.
Martin
@Yarrow: No support by the GOP to run for any other seat. No wingnut welfare – Fox News, think tank, etc. Basically, go get a job at the local Chevy dealership.
Mary G
@schrodingers_cat: Money.
All that is where they really make a killing, and if they’re disloyal to Twitler, they’re blackballed for life. And there’s nothing else they’re qualified to earn big bucks for.
?BillinGlendaleCA
@Kamala.Harris.2020: Donald Trump is well known for his sense of humor. Little known fact.
Johnny Gentle (famous crooner)
I know, I always feel ad for all those grossly overweight cats no matter how cute they may appear to be. That’s what you meant, right?
bluehill
@schrodingers_cat:
The most courage they can muster is to run away and retire. If they really wanted to do something, they would stay in office like Amash. Sad.
debbie
@?BillinGlendaleCA:
In a Queens kind of way, I suppose. //
MattF
One has to bear in mind that in the Trumpoid space-time continuum, Trump never lies. Never. Never, never, never. So, when Trump quotes himself on the subject of his own innocence, that’s proof of his innocence, and the subject is now closed. It’s taken me quite a while to grasp this method of reasoning, and I suspect I’ve thrown a few mental gears in the effort to do so— but that’s where we are.
Elizabelle
Every single one of these witnesses, even Sondland**, have been more qualified to serve as POTUS than Donald Fucking Trump.
He has never worked for any cause bigger than himself.
** Sondland is marginal, but he was smart enough to build his own business, and to hire and listen to his lawyers.
Kent
Those are afraid of being primaried by the MAGA faithful. It is a reasonable fear.
Mary G
Nunes will be blasting this tomorrow morning:
Roger Moore
@?BillinGlendaleCA:
Liberals just don’t appreciate the humor inherent to n****r jokes and making fun of reporters with disabilities.
Kent
They are afraid of losing the Fox News gravy train or the swampy lobbyist gravy train. Hard to get that lucrative lobbying job with any part of corporate America when Trump blackballs your ass and threatens to rage tweet against any company that hires you.
Roger Moore
@Mary G:
I’ll be sure to remember that the next time I consider voting for him.
Adam L Silverman
@Yarrow: It’s not Putin, it’s what is in David Pecker’s safe.
Kent
@Roger Moore: Right. I mean seriously? He was dating more than one woman at once? Which is all that really means despite the lurid headline.
Of course Nunes is going to subpoena both the mother and child now that it is out. Mark my words.
Keith P.
@Mary G: Trump might end up liking Hunter Biden after that move
Roger Moore
@Kent:
He was dating more than one woman at once and was failing to take adequate precautions to prevent a pregnancy. The whole thing is lurid and gossipy and completely irrelevant to whether his father would be a good president.
frosty
Much like the time I was looking up the specs on the boat anchors I’d bought. I do not recommend searching for “Super Hookers” on a work computer.
Adam L Silverman
@Yarrow: She really needs to get a restraining order.
Also:
Elizabelle
This was a great article. History and circumstances were not kind to Nixon’s defenders.
Washington Post, op ed by David Greenberg, a history prof at Rutgers
When should Republicans jump ship?
History could forgive Trump’s defenders. But we know it will reward his deserters.
Story’s way more complicated, and worth a click. Some politicians went down and lost elections and their reputations. Other defenders: Trent Lott, Pat Buchanan, Bob Dole — did just fine. It’s a mixed record.
germy
@frosty:
Gin & Tonic
@Adam L Silverman: Might just be me, but that gets less funny each time. And it started out as not-funny.
Ruckus
@Yarrow:
He may be a lot of things but vlad’s no idiot. He’s played the lot of them and he’s made sure they know he owns them.
Roger Moore
@Adam L Silverman:
I’m glad I’m not the only one who hears that name and thinks of those ads.
Adam L Silverman
@Gin & Tonic: Has to be you.//
Ruckus
@Mary G:
They aren’t qualified for the small bucks either.
Shalimar
@schrodingers_cat: Primaries. You still get a job as a lobbyist or commentator if you stay loyal and lose to a Democrat. Your career is over if you turn against Trump and get primaried out of office.
germy
One of the best Tom The Dancing Bug cartoons I’ve seen:
https://boingboing.net/2019/11/20/a-calvinesque-and-hobbesian-lo-8.html
Marcopolo
Still no way I am supporting him but glad to see this:
Shalimar
@schrodingers_cat: Hurd in particular has a long future heading intelligence agencies in future Republican administrations if he keeps playing ball now.
Mallard Filmore
I thought his safe was emptied out and the material destroyed. Then again it was only a rumor, and a helpful rumor whether true or not.
germy
Amid unexpected national attention, Tedra Cobb campaigns in Queensbury to unseat Elise Stefanik
Kicking off a week of campaigning, Cobb appeared at Chicken Coop Forge in a sometimes-disorderly event with about 100 supporters. She was sometimes aggressively questioned by members of a local group whose members call themselves the North Country Deplorables, who are outspoken supporters of President Donald Trump and Stefanik.
Cobb asked the handful of people from the Deplorables group to be respectful, but she promised to engage with them. “I will continue to talk to you and everyone else … We’re going to have many conversations and will try to find common ground, because that’s what we need in Washington,” the business consultant and former St. Lawrence County legislator said.
https://dailygazette.com/article/2019/11/19/tedra-cobb-i-did-not-see-it-coming
Yarrow
@Adam L Silverman: As if what is/was in that safe hasn’t made it into Putin’s hands. I’ve quoted this article many times, but Gluliani cleaned up the anthrax attack at American Media Inc.
AMI “hurriedly abandoned the building” and Giuliani’s company and then was going to occupy the building. What was in those safes and who has it? Giuliani says he has “insurance.” Is what was in the AMI safes part of that? Who else has seen it?
Gin & Tonic
@Roger Moore: Except that, of course, it’s pronounced differently, and is an actual Slavic word with its own meaning that has nothing to do with faux-Mexican foodstuffs.
These “jokes” are as funny as an antibiotic-resistant fungal infection.
JWR
@germy: Thanks for the Tom The Dancing Bug cartoon! I needed a laugh.
germy
@JWR: The Dancing Bug is one of the bright spots in this age of donald.
He’s done a whole series of the Calvin/Trump parodies. It should be a book.
Marcopolo
@Kent: Think it is also possible that some R’s who are retiring right now are hoping that maybe they can run for office after Trump is gone & politics move a little back towards normalcy. That’s cowardly & foolish—if they are hoping our politics might move back towards normalcy maybe they should put their shoulder to it.
JWR
@JWR: Especially now that liddle’ Jim Jordan is up again. Not yelling so much, but just as irritating.
Jay
https://www.vice.com/amp/en_ca/article/a35mya/nearly-all-mass-shooters-since-1966-have-had-four-things-in-common?utm_souhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.vice.com%2Fen_ca%2Farticle%2Fa35mya%2Fnearly-all-mass-shooters-since-1966-have-had-four-things-in-commonrce=vicenewscafbca&fbclid=IwAR3lUvzuWo8p6SSjgkzMz2mKTOrT47PdM8w0rGdPJdNHSxlJ1asfAhlUB9w&__twitter_impression=true
SiubhanDuinne
@zhena gogolia:
Once is happenstance.
Twice is coincidence.
Thrice+ is enemy action.
bluehill
There goes another talking point.
ET
Their calculation also has to include how much they have already damaged their chances in politics and GOP circles as well as how much (and how fast) will the GOP post tRump change. At some point tRump may prove so toxic even in GOP circles.
With that said the GOP has been very good over the last few decades about inculcating/brain washing their members to get in line or else. So nothing else – including the real world – may matter. Today’s GOP doesn’t reward an independent spirit.
Another Scott
@Gin & Tonic: Thanks for the info. I haven’t kept up with this part of the story so I have no idea who she is, and had no idea of the ethnology of her surname.
Cheers,
Scott.
JWR
Oh, agreed. Tom Tomorrow, too.
Matt McIrvin
@schrodingers_cat: If they stick with Trump, they might lose the general election. If they publicly break with Trump, they WILL lose the Republican primary. So they stay in.
SiubhanDuinne
@Elizabelle:
Take care of the sips and the gulps will take care of themselves.
Yarrow
@Matt McIrvin: Self and party before country.
Adam L Silverman
@Mallard Filmore:
@Yarrow:
My understanding is that the safe has been reported empty. What hasn’t been reported is what Pecker or his immediate subordinates, specifically those with law degrees, did with the information in it.
Gin & Tonic
@Another Scott: Alexandra and Andrea are sisters, US-born but of Ukrainian heritage. Andrea is a journalist who works with Sarah Kendzior (I know some of you have opinions on Sarah.) Alexandra was a researcher for the DNC. She was among the people raising early alarms about Paul Manafort when he was hired by Trump, because (like lots of people) she was aware of his work for Viktor Yanukovuch. Manafort has not forgiven or forgotten, and has all his allies trying to make Alexandra’s life difficult.
Mary G
Speech Laura Cooper gave to the Ukrainian Women’s Congress 12/7/2018:
She goes on to promise that America has Ukraine’s back. These Giuliani/Sondland shenanigans must have infuriated her. It really is remarkable that none of these multitudes of witnesses leaked any of this for months until the IG blew the whistle on the attempt to bury the whistleblower complaint without notifying Congress.
Another Scott
Meanwhile, Reuters:
But, but, that’s unpossible! Donnie said trade wars were easy and he had this one all wrapped up. He said so months ago!!11
Least surprising news, ever. :-/
The “pump and dump” traders must love the stock market gyrations he’s causing. There are a few volumes full of charges of that stuff going on, if any prosecutor cares to look, I’m sure.
Grrr…
Cheers,
Scott.
Another Scott
@Gin & Tonic: Ah.
Thanks again.
Cheers,
Scott.
Mo' Salad (--bd)
The first five times I read the headline, I read Omarosa. She actually might be a fun witness to call…
janesays
HAHAHA… out of curiosity, what exactly did you expect to get in your original attempt at that search?
Mary G
Good news:
Stephen Miller is gnashing his teeth in his coffin.
bucachon
Watching the prime time hearings. Republicans keep making the point that the aid was released. But why was it released? If trump was concerned about corruption, what did he learn to change his mind? And more broadly concerned about corruption, I’d love to hear a Republican asked what other examples of trump fighting corruption could they name?
bluehill
@Yarrow: Stark contrast to the courage exhibited by civil servants like Cooper and the patriotism of Vindman. They don’t ask for this but put aside their own concerns to protect their country.
CaseyL
Why does the GOP stick with Trump?
Occam’s razor says it’s because they support everything he does.
He is enabling the GOP to pack the courts with radical reactionaries who will roll back a century of progressive precedent.
JWR
One of the Rs just spent his time talking about Trump’s decision to move the Javelins, (something Obama refused to do!), was the right thing to do, and which……. has nothing to do with the subject of this hearing, dammit!
Maybe a sign of surrender?
Mary G
bluehill
@Another Scott:
Sold his puts today. Loaded up on calls for Friday’s announcement that they are making a lot “progress.”
Jay
@Mary G:
meanwhile,
https://www.google.ca/amp/s/slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/11/supreme-court-criminalize-immigration-advocacy-sineneng-smith.amp
debbie
@bluehill:
Trump is turning every Republican into obsessive liars just like him. They have to know their legacies are toast.
Jay
Roger Moore
@CaseyL:
Not necessarily everything, any more than you can say any member of a political party supports everything their party leader does. But they clearly support enough of it that they’re willing to accept the stuff they don’t like to get the stuff they do. As somebody said about Trump’s racism, it doesn’t mean that all his supporters are as racist as he is, but it means they’re willing to accept it.
debbie
@Gin & Tonic:
Thanks for this information.
Jeffro
@Elizabelle: I don’t even know who that is, but I’m sippin’
bluehill
@debbie: That’s what worries me. Bad stuff seems to happen when you got nothing left to lose.
JWR
Now Stefanik is going on about the Obama/Trump divide on the Javelins, (Obama didn’t send them, Trump did), and other meaningless blather, at least as far as anything having to do with this hearing.
debbie
@JWR:
Is she still snidely saying Obama only sent blankets? Hey chick, burns like that only work once.
Jay
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1087511?__twitter_impression=true
Jeffro
@CaseyL: They stick with him because by and large they get what they want (judges, tax cuts, white supremacy) without having to pay a price for it.
This is why it’s so important to pound on GOP officials at all levels and pin them down (whether from our own candidates, or from the media): “do you agree with policy X, statement Y, tweet Z from the president, Representative GOPerson?” Even their silence is a mark against them, if properly amplified.
Jeffro
@JWR: She’s the second one – the guy from Texas (not Ratliffe) was also going on and on about it.
Seems their backup defense is “Ukraine has no better friend than Donald J trumpov…especially compared to the black guy”. Oh, OKAY
gene108
@schrodingers_cat:
Kochs, Mercers, etc. pay well for doing very little, plus lucrative jobs in lobbying, as long as you don’t piss off the wrong people by going against the Republican Party.
Amir Khalid
@janesays:
I actually tried that search. Suffice it to say that most of the results were not family-friendly.
Duane
@bucachon: The notion Trumpov was concerned about Ukraine corruption is preposterous. An investigation by people suspected of being corrupt might be corrupt, but Trumpov doesn’t care. He’ll gladly use any means to win.
Roger Moore
@Duane:
Trump’s only interest in corruption is how he can get a piece of the action.
JWR
@debbie: Is she still snidely saying Obama only sent blankets?
Oh yes, of course! Fortunately, the next D up went through a list of non-lethal items, saying, “these things don’t sound like blankets, do they?”
Jay
Yarrow
@Adam L Silverman: I know what’s been reported. I think there are good reasons to question the reporting.
JWR
@Jeffro: Their backup defense, or Plan B, ain’t gonna work.
Jay
@JWR:
arn’t they on plan T by now?
Elizabelle
Virginia Heffernan, in the Los Angeles Times:
A Republican line no one believes: Trump hates corruption, especially in Ukraine. Yeah, no
Jim Jordan was just plugging that one again. Yeah, no.
Elizabelle
And, Fuck the Fucking New York Times just buried the lede and glided right past in their headline.
Vindman’s Lawyer Asks Fox News to Retract Espionage Allegation
A guest? It was JOHN YOO. Probably one of their sources.
A guest. Right. His name (and reputation) is well enough known to merit inclusion in the headline. Except, it’s FTF NY Times.
JWR
@Jay: LoL! It’s hard to tell what they’re up to this afternoon, except wasting time talking to their audience of 1 (one).
Ella in New Mexico
Nunes again, projecting what the Republicans are doing onto Democrats. Sigh.
He’s so boring.
JWR
Oh Devin. Why won’t you please just get the f*ck off?
Dev Null
@?BillinGlendaleCA: Does the new site have an upvote somewhere?
If so, I have yet to find it. Consider yourself upvoted …
Dev Null
@Adam L Silverman: what was in David Pecker’s safe, you mean?
Might still be, I s’pose. And if a document might still be in Pecker’s safe …
jk
Brian Williams: Sondland delivered a “blowtorch testimony”
chopper
@Yarrow:
the wingnut welfare circuit isn’t likely to welcome turncoats with open arms, i assume.
FelonyGovt
@Elizabelle: The way Lt. Col. Vindman is being treated is one of those things that hurts my soul. SO angry.
chopper
@jonas:
it’s gonna end up (at some point, likely before they try to argue it was all a mass hallucination and it never actually happened) being something like “it’s fine to make demands of other countries for the nation’s benefit and it was trump’s closely held religious belief that keeping biden out of the white house was to benefit the nation”.
bucachon
@Duane: exactly. I want to hear a Republican give an example of trumps interest in corruption. They say he cares about. Give examples
Another Scott
@zhena gogolia:
For those who haven’t seen him going after Sondland, the clip is here.
Excellent.
(via Evan Hurst at Wonkette)
Cheers,
Scott.
Bill Arnold
@Jay:
Interesting, and good (maybe), to see that piece on the nbcnews site.
That has the appearance of some sloppy … tradecraft. Might be worth some digging, but people are obviously already on it.
Bill Arnold
@chopper:
Quoted for amusement. Fixed, it’s more like
Warblewarble
For the listener,who listens in the snow, And nothing himself beholds Nothing that is not there and the nothing that is. The “I want nothing” that is just keeps on coming. Pence, Barr,Mulvaney, Pompeo,tRUMP the whole rotten tRUMPthuglican gang Prison 2020.