You may recall that two Georgia election workers, Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss, had sued Giuliani for the harms they endured after he falsely declared Freeman and Moss had tampered with ballots in 2020.
The trial that has just concluded was not about whether Giuliani had done the deed. He both admitted to the facts in question and so completely failed to meet his obligations in the discovery phase of the trial, which led the judge in the case to render a default judgment in favor of the plaintiffs. This trial was all about damages: how much America’s embarrassment owed for his sins.
This afternoon, after less than two full days of deliberation, the jury has given its answer: Giuliani owes $148 million to Moss and Freeman — $33 million in direct damages for the defamation; $40 million for emotional harm, and $75 million in punitive damages.
As Josh Kovensky writes at Talking Points Memo, Rudy made it easy for the jury:
It’s a stunning damages amount, one which reflects not only the vicious campaign of harassment that Giuliani unleashed by falsely claiming that a video showed the two tampering with ballots at a Georgia voting center, but the extent to which Trump’s consigliere went out of his way to make things as bad as possible for himself. Giuliani earned Howell’s wrath throughout the pre-trial phase by repeatedly ignoring evidence requests from Freeman and Moss’ attorneys. During the trial itself, Giuliani stood outside the courtroom and repeated the claims which led to the defamation claim in the first place, further enraging the judge.
Oh–and Giuliani hasn’t got the lolly. Not even close. Odds are he’ll have to make a whole bunch of cash between now and then to merely die broke.
Oh–and in the biggest surprise since the dog bit the man–his former client does not have his back, as Kovensky reminds us with this chef’s kiss:
Giuliani reportedly begged Trump himself for cash over the summer to cover his legal bills, but the former president refused.
Yup.
Everything Trump Touches Dies.
Image: David Teniers, Two beggars on the outskirts of a village, between 1660 and 1670.
schrodingers_cat
The Republican party is still alive and kicking.
piratedan
the only thing I believe to be true is that all of the lawyers will get paid before the ladies do…
It would be nice if these judgements allowed assets to be seized and frozen instead of the likelihood of appeals that are sure to follow.
The Kropenhagen Interpretation
@schrodingers_cat: Give it time. It’ll be hard to cure the less attentive half of our population of their brand loyalty.
Jim, Foolish Literalist
I’ve been wondering why this case wasn’t brought against trump. This makes it sound like I should’ve added “yet”
Does the judgement against Rudi make a case against trump stronger? Some kind of precedent?
Baud
👍
Suzanne
I hope the court seizes all of his assets, empties his bank accounts, and he can go be a Walmart greeter.
Baud
@piratedan:
The lawyers are paid at the same time as the client.
Judgements can be used to seize assets. Rudy has a right to appeal.
MattF
TFG doesn’t have that kind of money. Where ‘that kind’ means ‘that much’ and ‘that sort’. Maybe Rudy’s Saudi pals could help out.
TBone
Maga tears deliciousness. I have the Gritty on a riding mower t-shirt 😎 and just rewatched Christine Nangle for extra schadenfreude. Happy Friday!
OlFroth
The people who sent the e-mails, made the phone calls, and showed up at Freeman and Moss’ homes are guilty of criminal offenses. Harassment by communication or address, threats of physical violence against public officials, etc. Rudy is now impoverished, but those who acted on his words should face charges once they’re identified.
Betty Cracker
Has anyone squandered so much unearned goodwill so thoroughly? Maybe Trump will let him live in a cabana hut.
Die broke and mad, Rudy.
NorthLeft
As a spokesman for Trump once said after the 2012 election and he fled from Romney’s wake,
”Mr. Trump does not associate with losers.”
Bye bye Rudy.
Anotherlurker
One of Rudy’s tricks as mayor was to round up homeless and ship them out of state. I hope he experiences the treatment that he gleefully meted out to vulnerable people.
lowtechcyclist
@Suzanne:
Which would have the fringe benefit of scaring a few people away from whatever Wal-Mart he was serving as a greeter at.
Joseph Patrick Lurker
I never bought into the idiotic claim that Rudy was America’s mayor, but he’s definitely America’s scumbag.
Emily B.
Thing is, Rudy’s just going to try to hire himself out for more evil deeds in order to get out of the financial hole. (Although who would hire him?)
trollhattan
Need to rewatch his Borat scene. Punking the punk.
Rudy Can Fail
Leto
@Suzanne: Considering he doesn’t have a pot to piss in, as soon as he gets a pot I hope the court seizes it. If he dies a penny-less pauper, that’s still too fucking good. Fuck Ghouliani, and the rest of the shitbags.
Scout211
Is something wrong with David’s Bluesky post? I keep getting a Cloudflare error message. But only on that post. But then I had to close my browser to get to any other thread. Is it just me?
Suzanne
@Leto: Agreed.
Im just astonished, tho. Like, Alex Jones owes his victims a shit ton of money, and yet he still lives somewhere, has a car, flies on planes presumably. Did he stash money away? It sucks.
Sloegin
$75m punitive is quite the sum for being an obstinate ass during the entire legal proceeding.
You love to see it.
BC in Illinois
I have a suggestion for a humane solution to the Rudy Giuliana impoverishment problem.
Take away all of his money, to bring some measure of justice to Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss. Sell everything he has hidden . . .
BUT, leave him an income to live on.
I would peg it at the crazification percentage — 27%. Twenty seven percent of the American people live on $39,824.00 or less.
He would feel himself ill-used, but it’s not poverty. It’s just life, Mr. G.
NotMax
This.
;)
eclare
Rudy could have stayed retired, collected whatever pensions he has, gone on the wingnut speaker circuit, but no, he gave all that up to be close to power. It reminds me of the next to last scene in Fargo. Was it worth it?
OlFroth
The only punishment a wealthy person understands, is the punishment that makes him a poor person.
OlFroth
@BC in Illinois: That would be welfare. Certainly allow him the basics (flop house room, ramen noodles) but make him toil for it.
mvr
There will be a lot of “how far he has fallen” news stories, but the truth is he was always an asshole.
Baud
I bet Four Seasons Total Landscaping would hire him to cut some ads.
Scout211
Rudy Guiliani is super mad at Kal Penn, guest host on The Daily Show this week. For This segment
[The Guiliani part starts at about 2:20]
Jackie
@Suzanne: Walmart isn’t stupid enough to hire him.
trollhattan
@Suzanne: Riches to rags seems very rare in the 21st century. Parachutes galore, I suppose.
ETA “I’m putting you under house arrest.”
“Okay your honor, my house happens to have seventeen bathrooms, so all good. Can I use my lake?”
Leto
@Suzanne: this reporting was from just after Thanksgiving:
Sandy Hook families offer to settle Alex Jones’ $1.5 billion legal debt for at least $85 million
Apologies for pasting so much, but that last paragraph… just absolutely fuck that restructuring officer. If you can basically pay that fucker 2x the pay, he has the money to pay the families. Motherfucker shouldn’t receive a damn penny for the next 23 lifetimes.
trollhattan
@Leto: That’s fucking $1.5 million a fucking year. How will he squeak by?
TheronWare
Breaking news: Binder on classified intel went missing under tRump.
Baud
@Suzanne:
@Leto:
@trollhattan:
Bankruptcy separates past assets from future income, as of the date the petition is filed. Even if 100% of his past assets were paid to creditors, as long as Jones can earn millions for his insanity, he can’t be impoverished.
Baud
@TheronWare:
I’ve been wondering about the dearth of “but her emails” type stories about Trump. We’re into primary season. Isn’t the NYT concerned about national security anymore? Has Comey retired from writing op/eds?
cain
@Suzanne: Seriously, do you really want to see this guys face at a walmart trying to greet you? The people at walmart is his people anyways – within 6 months he’ll have a grift operation going.
West of the Rockies
@Betty Cracker:
Maybe Cosby lost a similar amount of good will?
trollhattan
Sharing this story because so many things combine that I think it needs to go back to the scriptwriters. Ahem Tennessee, a tornado, a trailer, some surprisingly lucky weirdos, and the Lord!
Engage
One of those kids will become an Ivy. It is ordained.
mrmoshpotato
Fixed. Also, now gender neutral.
trollhattan
@TheronWare: Wasn’t in a box in the Mar a Lago shitter?
Harrison Wesley
@TheronWare: He just had to outdo Romney’s binders full of women, didn’t he?
frosty
I just opened a bottle of Chandon. Ms F asked “Are we bad people for celebrating this?”
No, I don’t think so!
Dan B
@piratedan: I’ve read, from commenters of unknown legal expertise, that the amount of the judgement must be put in escrow during an appeal.
True / not true?
Harrison Wesley
@cain: At Halloween, of course. At any other time, of course not.
Baud
@frosty:
You are the best people for celebrating this.
mrmoshpotato
@cain:
Well, if you have a bucket of rotten produce with you at the time…
mrmoshpotato
@frosty: A resounding “No. No, you are not.”
trollhattan
@frosty: “Other side” go out front and shoot their ARs into the sky with their wins; bubbly is how decent people do it.
M31
ha ha ha you rancid piece of shit, pay up
JoyceH
DC is home to the jury pool most likely to sympathize with wronged black female civil servants, so I expected a hefty judgment. Just wish Rudy had the money to be taken away.
Leto
OT but I don’t think we’ve covered this reporting today:
The mystery of the missing binder: How a collection of raw Russian intelligence disappeared under Trump
This is new reporting. If the Russians, and others, are able to more effectively target the US with disinformation, it’ll be because their asset stole more than we’ll ever know. For those of us that will live long enough to see it, I fully expect to see a Trumpov statue erected in Moscow. Or Kyrgyzstan. Like… the scope of this continually makes my mouth hang open in stupor.
Scout211
A lively discussion on the early morning thread. But the story deserves lots of discussion.
Delk
Somebody let the Clash know.
Baud
@Leto:
How can it be that access to that file isn’t monitored in some way?
The IRS has better security.
Leto
@Baud: I hear you. I just… don’t like the answer.
Leto
@Scout211: sorry, first chance today to do more than just read the post. I hope Jack can use this in the FL documents case in some shape/manner. Hopefully he already knew this.
Baud
@Leto:
My answer wasn’t 100% accurate. A bankruptcy plan can allocate some portion of future income to repayment of debt. But the amount won’t make Jones poor.
Harrison Wesley
@Leto: Agree. I was born many centuries too late; my sentence would have been “Leave with nothing or die on the spot.” I’m funny that way.
Anoniminous
@trollhattan:
God also killed 5 other people in Tennessee including a 10 year old.
So the Maths Have It: God is a net +4 murderer.
Scout211
@Baud: The entire investigative report is worth a read. The (former) president requested it because he wanted to declassify it and use it in some way. Parts were redacted and copies were made but the original is nowhere to be found. Lots of Trump aides pointing fingers
The (former) president can declassify any documents he feels like declassifying, right? He told us this over and over so it must be true.
marklar
Looking forward to Rudy’s debut on Cameo. To add insult to injury, have George Santos out-charge and out-earn him.
Geminid
@Leto: I’m curious as to why this story is only coming out now.
JoyceH
If I were Freeman and Moss, I would immediately file suit against Trump and Fox and every venue that promulgated the defamation. Some of them will probably pony up big bucks to get out from under.
Baud
@Scout211:
Thanks.
NobodySpecial
You say everything Trump touches dies, I say everything he embraced was already dead.
Baud
@Anoniminous:
Were those people named Lord?
Mr. Bemused Senior
Today is a good day.
RepubAnon
@lowtechcyclist: Or, they might drop by to ask which aisle the Find Out products are in.
eclare
@RepubAnon:
Hahaha…
David 🌈 ☘The Establishments☘🌈 Koch
trollhattan
@RepubAnon:
Aisle 8B, facing the Festivus decorations.
Chip Daniels
@Baud:
Four Seasons Total Landscaping would hire him to cut some <s>ads.</s> grass.
billcinsd
Didn’t Elise Stefanik request that the DOJ investigate Beryl Howell recently?
Steeplejack
@Baud:
Can legal judgments be discharged in bankruptcy?
Geminid
@eclare: Mark Meadows made a similar choice. He had a safe Congressional seat when he signed on to be Trump’s Chief of Staff. Meadows might have been a Senator by now; Ted Budd had less going for him than Meadows would have, and Budd won Richard Burr’s seat last year.
Now Meadows is in the shit. He’s fighting Fulton County Prosecutor Willis’s indictment, and Jack Smith will likely force a guilty plea from him before this is over with.
Baud
@Steeplejack:
Depends on the type of judgment. I believe intentional torts like defamation can’t be. But not sure.
Mr. Bemused Senior
@Steeplejack
uscourts.gov
Emphasis added
eclare
@Geminid:
Yep.
Scout211
Yes, but because he is cooperating, it won’t be as bad as it should be for him.
Martin
@Mr. Bemused Senior: Yeah, this is what prevented Alex Jones from getting out from his judgement – jury found his acts were willful and malicious so the bankruptcy judge wouldn’t discharge the debt.
Not sure if the jury found his defamation willful and malicious, but I would have to think so given the size of the award.
Martin
So, IDF killed 3 hostages and two shipping firms are now avoiding the Red Sea. Everything going just great.
Mr. Bemused Senior
@Martin: IANAL, but the punitive award suggests so. We can but hope.
Mike in NC
Just caught the network news about Rudy Nosferatu. He’s probably already dead broke. Good!
Bill Arnold
@NorthLeft:
Loser Mr. Trump must absolutely hate associating with himself, ever day, 24 hours per day.
Martin
@Mike in NC: He’s still got his properties.
For now.
Jeffro
@Emily B.: 🎶 “evil deeds…DONE DIRT CHEAP…🎶
wait
”DONE INCOMPETENTLY AND CHEAP!”
nah, doesn’t have the same flow
🤣🤣🤣
Martin
Like I said, it’s going just great.
Baud
@Martin:
The arrest is great. He could have been promoted.
Mr. Bemused Senior
Given the outcomes Trump’s various associates are facing, I wonder what the people working on his campaign are thinking at this point. I doubt they are all true believers; some [perhaps many] are in it for themselves and must be getting nervous.
trollhattan
Donny Never Stop Grifting Trump looking at a new grift (via Digby)
I assume “undeveloped federal land” includes empty places like Yosemite NP, Grand Teton NP, Big Sur, Cape Cod….
Sanjeevs
NYT finds a story that can’t be both sidesed – so they deliberately find a different story and somehow link it to the first.
Baud
@trollhattan:
That’s not new. I recall making fun of that before.
Dangerman
@Jackie: On the positive side, Walmart would have no problem selling rotten fruit, they wouldn’t need maintenance to clean up dog shit off the floors (“Martha, get a bag and matches”), etc
cain
@trollhattan:
It took me a moment to realize the baby’s name is Lord. I was trying to figure out why she kept saying Lord.
Baud
@Sanjeevs:
NYT 2028
hueyplong
@Mr. Bemused Senior: Yes, punitives were awardable because his actions were willful and malicious, so it’s not looking good for Rudy in a hypothetical bankruptcy.
TS
So many have been convicted of civil and criminal offences because of their support for trump yet it makes no difference to the rest of his supporters. It is a true cult in every possible way
Chip Daniels
@cain:
That’s why God targeted their house for destruction, because blasphemy.
Some folk just can’t take a hint.
Geminid
@Scout211: Meadows has a good defense attorney who should get him a relatively good deal. That is, so long as Meadows does not hold back on what he knows.
Cassidy Hutchinson, Meadows’ former Chief of Staff, says she last saw the classified file on the “Crossfire Hurricane” investigation (the one that Leto brought up at #52) in Meadows’ safe and believes he took it with him.
In the wrong hands, that unredacted file could cause as much or more damage than any of the files in the Mar-a-Loco documents case. Meadows had better have a good story on that one.
mrmoshpotato
@Betty Cracker:
See Bush, George Walker.
Also see, September 11 attacks.
Sister Golden Bear
@Geminid: Hope the FBI installed a spy cam on Meadow’s fireplace.
Brachiator
Giuliani used to be a prosecutor. I presume that most of the cases he won were solid. I presume that he understands the law.
I don’t understand why he and others are so eager to become Trump’s toadies, and for practically no reward.
And I don’t understand why he was so willing to hurt other people simply to feed Trump’s ego, when he must have known what the consequences might be.
This is not the banality of evil. It’s the imbecility of evil.
Mr. Bemused Senior
@Brachiator: It puzzles me too. Why do people suck up to Trump? Usually it doesn’t turn out well for them.
Martin
@Geminid: I sure hope he didn’t have a fireplace in his office he wanted burning every day.
eclare
@Mr. Bemused Senior:
I know, I don’t understand it at all. Ego? TFG has fucked over everyone else his entire life, but I’m so special that he will be nice to me?
Martin
@Mr. Bemused Senior: He gives them permission to be assholes, and they REALLY want to be assholes.
Martin
@Sanjeevs: Not a fake problem.
Baud
@Mr. Bemused Senior:
@eclare:
I think TFG has become a sort of network node that connects the various parts of the right. People want to be close to that.
Geminid
@Sister Golden Bear: Meadows could have left that file in his safe and told Cipillone(sp?), the White House Council where it was. Or carried it over to Cipillone himself. That certainly would have been a safer course. Meadows knew how sensitive the file’s “sources and methods” information was.
This story raises a lot of questions with no clear answers. Maybe we’ll get some more details now that it has broken.
Tony G
@Betty Cracker: The sheer stupidity of the people who have chosen to attach themselves to Trump continues to astonish me. Rudy, for no good reason, was anointed as “America’s mayor” more than 22 years ago. All he had to do at that point was get paid for speaking engagements while “writing” a few ghost-written books full of platitudes. But he had to serve as Trump’s consigliere. I hope that he ends up living in a cardboard box.
lowtechcyclist
@Baud:
I’d settle for its making him middle class, IOW 50th percentile of income.
To him, that would feel like poverty, which would at least be something.
Mr. Bemused Senior
@Tony G: cardboard box? …
Luxury.
wjca
@Mr. Bemused Senior: Perhaps they figure that they’re so brilliant they can get the benefits while avoiding having TIFG stiff and destroy them. Inflated ego — gets ’em every time.
lowtechcyclist
@Martin:
Nailed it. Trumpism in a nutshell.
WaterGirl
@Geminid: What I read earlier was that Cassidy H. had seen Mark Meadows take the big binder out of the building on the last day. Which is even more horrifying.
WaterGirl
I think Mark Meadows must know he’s going to prison, and he’s fighting really hard to make sure it’s federal prison and not GA state prison.
Geminid
@Martin: Yeah, Meadows burned a lot of stuff. I assume it was materials that would incriminate him or make him look bad. But the Crossfire Hurricane file covered events that occurred long before Meadows went to work for Trump. So what was Meadows’ interest in destroying it?
And Meadows’ chief of staff was the one who testified about the document burning, but she didn’t say Meadows burned this supposedly thick file. She believed he took it with him.
Like I say, this story raises a lot of questions whose answers I can only guess at right now.
Chief Oshkosh
@Leto: Yeah, butter emails.
Has anyone asked Comey about this? Or did we go ahead and staple his lips together? Either would be great.
Miss Bianca
@Leto: maybe it’s time to.bring back debtors prison for special cases like these.
artem1s
Gonna be lots of speculation about who did and didn’t want the info unclassified. Maybe that’s part of the Russian PSYOPs. Anyone can be made to look bad when your spinning conspiracy stories. Comey for instance. It would be irresponsible not to speculate whether there was proof in there that he planned his little October surprise at the bequest of Daddy Vladdy. I could see TIFG wanting that info out there.
Since the CIA or NSA or whoever is never going to release the content of the unredacted documents the assumption will be anything and everything was in there including the burial place of Jimmy Hoffa, hiding place of the Holy Grail, and the origin of the Magic Bullet.
Dorothy A. Winsor
I think often these days of a quote from The Great Gatsby.
That’s the Trump administration. Careless people.
Matt McIrvin
@trollhattan: When I was in elementary school, the joke about bogus campaign promises in student council elections was that someone would promise “Coke will come from the drinking fountains”.
This is on the “Coke will come from the drinking fountains” level.
Lyrebird
The mobs outside their house? Not sure if they will be identifiable, though I agree.
Some of the people who delivered threats are now defendants in the GA RICO case with DA Willis. Good.
And the damages being unanimously approved – that is some of the best news of this week, this year. Those two women deserve nothing less.
kalakal
Does this mean Ghouliani will have to switch to a cheaper brand of hair dye?
That’ll be a good look, he’ll leave a trail wherever he goes like the slug he is
barbequebob
@Chip Daniels: Plus living in sin and making whoopie out of holy matrimony
Jackie
Open thread? The link shows the breakdown of how the House Dems saved the GQP’s ass multiple times this year.
Ruckus
@Brachiator:
I don’t understand why he and others are so eager to become Trump’s toadies, and for practically no reward.
And I don’t understand why he was so willing to hurt other people simply to feed Trump’s ego, when he must have known what the consequences might be.
They see a reward in being a shit. That’s why they like ShitForBrains. Because if they feed SFB’s ego, that might get them within the ring of fame. Likely they did not know that stupidity and illegality do not equal fame.
gene108
Seems to me the defendant in a civil trial can escape paying damages indefinitely with appeals and taking advantage of a legal system designed to cater to rich fuckwads.
Seems like an utterly useless system to hold the rich and powerful to any kind of accountability.
Chris Johnson
@Brachiator: I think I know why Rudy went the way he did. He famously busted the Italian Mafia… using the Russian Mafia. Which implies he’s been connected to Russia for a VERY long time. He did this while Trump was operating in New York… with Epstein. I’m gonna say they’re all mobbed up and it’s strictly Russian since way back, and that’s why Rudy is the way he is.
Russia isn’t what it used to be. They’ve got more important battles to fight, and it’s not going well. Even to save face (and they do not care about that unless it’s to get results for the motherland) they don’t care about outsiders fighting their battles overseas. Rudy’s on his own, and that’s why this can happen now when it couldn’t happen before.
Jinchi
Trump opened up opportunities for graft and corruption. Rudy and the rest planned to be at the front of the line for under the table money coming in to work the system or selling access to TFG.
A rare few, like Jared Kushner, hit the jackpot.