Medium Cool is a weekly series related to popular culture, mostly film, TV, and books, with some music and games thrown in. We hope it’s a welcome break from the anger, hate, and idiocy we see almost daily from the other side in the political sphere.
Arguments welcomed, opinions respected, fools un-suffered. We’re here every Sunday at 7 pm.
Tonight, let’s talk about heroes and villains!
This topic doesn’t need any more introduction than that, right?
Note: for those new to Medium Cool, these are not open threads.
Baud
Finally, a thread about me!
schrodingers_cat
@Baud: Come on, you are the Balloon Juice hero. Everybody likes Baud.
cope
Richard Boone as Cicero Grimes in “Hombre” is probably my favorite movie villain.
Melancholy Jaques
Judge Holden in Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian.
Please, dear Hollywood, please do not make film or series out of this novel.
Mr. Prosser
Dr. Christian Szell (Der Weisse Angel) in Marathon Man. “Is it safe?”
mrmoshpotato
I’m Batman!
(They must’ve had a blast filming the ridiculousness that was 1960’s Batman.
Joker and Mr. Freeze are excellent villians.
kalakal
So many to choose from. Iago, Steerpike, Uriah Heep…
I’m a fan of the over the top James Bond supervillans, my favourites being Goldfinger (Gert Frobe) and OddJob (Harold Sakata)
Special shout out to Jack Lemmon & Peter Falk as Professor Fate and Max
eclare
@Melancholy Jaques:
To continue on with Cormac McCarthy, Javier Bardem as Anton in No Country For Old Men.
https://youtu.be/38A__WT3-o0?si=No_JWetpSKnNR6hF
NotMax
George Sanders didn’t often get the opportunity but when a script called for it he excelled in playing the suave, urbane villain . See, for example, 1941’s Man Hunt.
band gap
Villanelle (played by Jodie Comer) in Killing Eve
kalakal
Richard Attenborough was absolutely chilling as Pinkie in Brighton Rock and Christie in 10 Rillington Place
And of course Orsen Welles as Harry Lime
mrmoshpotato
@kalakal:
Yes, yes, and yes.
Leto
You rang?
AliceBlue
Dennis Hopper as Frank Booth in Blue Velvet.
Melancholy Jaques
@eclare:
McCarthy could really write evil.
A Ghost to Most
Elmo deserves a suitably Bond-villain-esque ending.
Peke Daddy
Superman in the comic “What’s So Funny About Peace, Justice And The American Way?”
Eunicecycle
@kalakal: I was going to nominate Uriah Heep, as my favorite villain.
khead
“You see, Mr. Gittes, most people never have to face the fact, that in the right place, at the right time, they’re capable of ANYthing!” – Noah Cross
lowtechcyclist
Bogie was a great ‘knight in tarnished armor’ sort of hero in movies like The Maltese Falcon, Casablanca, and To Have and Have Not.
And I love the roles Peter Lorre played in Bogart movies, especially as
Rocky RococoJoel Cairo in Maltese Falcon. Less a villain than a “slimy weasel” as Dan Catherwood put it.NotMax
Must mention Henry Fonda in Once Upon a Time in the West.
Moving down to B-level, Shelley Winters in Bloody Mama.
And at C-level, Tura Satana in Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!
BellaPea
I’m into familiar territory here , but I always liked the chemistry between Thor and Loki in the Marvel movies. There’s a kind of sadness with Thor that he just can’t reach his brother to make peace, and Tom Hiddleston’s Loki comes close but never totally gives in. It’s a really brilliant portrayal by both of them, they really look like real brothers who share a history.
SFBayAreaGal
@kalakal: I loved Peter Falk and Jack Lemmon in The Great Race
mrmoshpotato
@lowtechcyclist: Have you seen Hitchcock’s British version of The Man Who Knew Too Much?
lowtechcyclist
@mrmoshpotato:
No, I’ve only seen a couple of Hitchcock movies, and that wasn’t one of them.
lowtechcyclist
Nobody’s mentioned Darth Vader yet?
laura
man, Alan Arkin as the really bad guy in Wait Until Dark will forever be my skeeriest bad guy. Behold: https://youtu.be/9WoIUWsYzEI?
Baud
I think the post body initially said villains, not heroes and villains.
Anyway, not really a traditional villain, but the first thing that came to mind was Yul Brenner in Westworld.
Kristine
Michael Nyqvist as Viggo Tarasov in the first John Wick movie. The epitome of the charming thug
Michael B. Jordan’s Killmonger in Black Panther.
Melancholy Jaques
All of the villains on The Wire were great: Avon, Stringer, Omar, Marlo, the Greek, Maurice, and in his own way, Rawls. In fact, most of them were so well played, it’s hard to think of them as villains.
NotMax
Going in a completely different direction, Snidely Whiplash as well as Dick Dastardly & Muttley.
;)
kalakal
He usually played a cad rather than a villain but I always loved Terry Thomas
I once read an interview with Jackie Chan where he said his biggest regret was he couldn’t play a villain, as he was one of the few Chinese international film stars at the time he had to be the good guy
geg6
I loved Paul Newman and Robert Redford in their roles when they played a pair of heroes who were sort of villainous. I can watch Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid or The Sting over and over and never tire of them.
kalakal
Hans Gruber would like a word
Gary Oldman as Stansfield in Leon
piratedan
The Xenomorph in Alien with Ripley as the Hero.
NotMax
Ooh, ooh! James Cagney in White Heat, Edward G. Robinson in Little Caesar, Paul Muni in Scarface.
eclare
@Melancholy Jaques:
That’s what was so great about The Wire, multi dimensional characters. All the sinners, saints…
hueyplong
Don’t want to get all repetitive about the great ones listed above (Szell, Harry Lime, Noah Cross, the 2 Franks, et al), but I’ll add a few:
Angela Lansbury in The Manchurian Candidate
Both Kirk Douglas and Jane Greer in Out of the Past
Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight
Charles Laughton in The Big Clock (if you haven’t seen this one, you’re in for a treat)
Margaret Hamilton in The Wizard of Oz
The Red Pen
I thought The Suicide Squad was a fun movie and the follow-on Peacemaker series was also fun.
One thing I never see mentioned is that Peacemaker (in the movie) is an anti-villain. Pop culture is rife with anti-heroes (people love them) but anti-villains are really rare.
An anti-villain is a character who has all the makings of a hero, but does evil things anyway.
geg6
@kalakal:
Can’t disagree with that. Snape, who is also a villain/hero (which is sort of my favorite kind of character) is also masterful. Rickman was the best!
Gloria DryGarden
@lowtechcyclist: the children love darth Vader, always many boys costume up as darth for the school costume parade.
NotMax
Did someone say Heroes and Villains?
;)
What Have the Romans Ever Done for Us?
@kalakal: I was just going to say how hasn’t anyone mentioned Allan Rickman yet?
WaterGirl
@Baud: Actually, the title said Heroes and Villains. After the post went up I realized I had left heroes off in the (very short) text of the post. So i remedied that!
Then got a phone call before I could mention that in an early comment.
Kudos to you for careful reading! :-)
Baud
@WaterGirl:
I thought this was part two of a Heroes and Villains series and I missed the first part.
SFBayAreaGal
Spike in Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Star Trek the Next Generation from an episode called The Drumhead, Admiral Norah Satie played by Jean Simmons.
Deep Space Nine: Kai Winn Adami played by Louise Fletcher
Nurse Ratched also played by Louise Fletcher
What Have the Romans Ever Done for Us?
@piratedan: Also the Paul Reiser character in Aliens.
CaseyL
Thinking about the heroes and villains of my childhood, because those left the deepest impressions.
I watched the TV series Batman as a young girl, and Julie Newmar’s Catwoman fascinated me. A “baddie” who was witty, and reveled in being Bad, and beat the good guys? She was my hero.
I was also enamored of Professor Loveless in the original Wild WIld West, as played by Michael Dunn. Wild Wild West also had one of my favorite Good Guys: Artemis Gordon. Even as a tween, I realized James West was supposed to be the hero heart-throb, but – even as a tween – I preferred Gordon for his inventiveness, intelligence, and sarcastic wit.
A villain who scared the young me was Rosa Klebb, in From Russia With Love (I can’t remember when or how I watched it; surely I was too young to see it in theaters when it was first released?). The knives in her shoes, activated with a click of her heels, scared me silly.
WaterGirl
@Baud: hahaha
No you didn’t, but that was funny.
NotMax
@hueyplong
Criminally underrated film. Elsa Lanchester’s ditzy dial goes to 11.
Brant Lamb
Harry Dresden. (Bogie in the Maltese Falcon meets Gandalf the Grey)
HumboldtBlue
Ray Shoesmith, villain? Anti-hero?
He’s the lead character in an Aussie show I have mentioned before — Mr. Inbetween.
mvr
@khead: Yes, I thought of that movie right away. Hero (who is whom I actually thought of first) is pretty messed up but still does the job.
Yutsano
Mark Hamill as the voice of the Joker. It’s so strange how he just nails that role.
What Have the Romans Ever Done for Us?
Don’t know who the actor was but since we’re in the tail end of the year with Christmas not far off, Mr. Potter from It’s A Wonderful Life is a pretty good villain. Also Jeff Bridges in The Jagged Edge.
scav
For complex villains, there is the pair Marquise de Merteuil and the Vicomte de Valmont (Glen Close & Alan Rickman en plus) in Dangerous Liaisons.
Gloria DryGarden
Kenneth Branagh as the “friend ” in othello.
Winona Judd , I think in the age of innocence, across from Daniel day Lewis, and Michelle Pfeiffer. She was so conniving. My neighbor talked to about her character, the Steele under velvet gloves.
hueyplong
I get fixated on movies, but it’s possible the best villain ever was in a TV series– Gus Fring in Breaking Bad.
lowtechcyclist
Harvey Korman as Hedley Lamarr in Blazing Saddles.
NotMax
All the leads (excepting adorable Katie Johnson) in The Ladykillers.
Also too, Alec Gunness in Kind Hearts and Coronets.
mrmoshpotato
@lowtechcyclist: Peter Lorre’s character is a sinister bastard from what I remember.
prostratedragon
Hank Quinlan in Touch of Evil. Serges Bauer in Gaslight (Either Boyer or Walbrook, but the former has a deliberate obtuseness that ignites me).
@NotMax:
There’s a fine Elsa Lanchester film festival out there to be compiled.
Splitting Image
This is a Beach Boys thread, right?
Heroes and Villains
Robert Mitchum in Night of the Hunter is a great villain.
Charles Boyer did a good turn in Gaslight.
Ozymandias in The Watchmen (comic book) is pitch perfect.
Hitchcock deserves his own category, especially because it’s not immediately obvious in many of his films who the villain is, or even exactly what crime has been committed. Vertigo and Psycho are particularly good examples of that.
Michael Palin starred in a politcal drama series in the early ’90s called G.B.H. which has an entire collection of evil bastards to choose from. It’s hard to track down, but it’s your only chance to see Michael beating someone nearly to death with a tennis racket. Tom Georgeson is in it, which reminds me that A Fish Called Wanda (which he was also in) also has an entire collection of evil bastards to choose from.
prostratedragon
@What Have the Romans Ever Done for Us?: Potter was played by Lionel Barrymore, who had real range.
Kristine
@NotMax: Love those movies.
prostratedragon
@scav: Malkovitch played Valmont opposite Close. Colin Firth played him opposite Annette Bening in another version. I’d say their movie was good, the one with the former two great.
Goku (aka Amerikan Baka)
@Baud:
I love this scene
Richard Benjamin has this “Oh, shit!” reaction as he realizes his friend has been shot for real by the Gunslinger and he’s in danger, while the Gunslinger has that menacing, amused smile on his face
prostratedragon
Laura Palmer’s killer. He’s drawn so that he gives indications almost immediately and early in the second season gave me a moment where, if I’d been in the room, it would have taken everything I had not to knock him off his chair. Things go downhill from there.
WV Blonde
@Brant Lamb: Agree wholeheartedly! He agonizes constantly whether the blackened denarius has begun to corrupt him (or the Winter Knight’s mantle), but still strives to do the right thing.
NotMax
@Kristine
Before anyone pops in with a correction, it’s Dennis Price as the nefarious one in Kind Hearts and Coronets but the Guinness name is more recognizable (he plays eight roles!)
zhena gogolia
@lowtechcyclist: OMG, man, you have to watch as many Hitchcock movies as you can get your hands on!
Villago Delenda Est
Burt Lancaster in Seven Days in May. He and Kirk Douglas played off each other brilliantly.
zhena gogolia
James Mason in North by Northwest. “Rapid City, South Dakota.”
NotMax
Suppose due must be given any of the Number 2s in The Prisoner.
zhena gogolia
@CaseyL: That was the great Lotte Lenya.
Villago Delenda Est
@zhena gogolia: James Mason in The Blue Max. While Jeremy Kemp played the immediate villain, Mason was in the background pulling the strings.
scav
@prostratedragon: Oops! sorry. Must have misfired that neuron where Rickman played it on stage. Which I might have killed to see. Malkovitch was right up there though.
zhena gogolia
@Splitting Image: Oh, yes, Charles Boyer in Gaslight! Boyer seems to be largely forgotten today, but he was a very great actor. See also Love Affair (hero in that one, although a playboy).
Polish The Guillotines
Hero: Hardy Krueger in “Flight Of the Phoenix.”
“But James Stewart…” you say. I say, “Nope. Hardy Krueger.”
Villain: HAL 9000.
zhena gogolia
@zhena gogolia: And Raymond Burr in Rear Window! Without any lines!
zhena gogolia
@Villago Delenda Est: Mason is always a fabulous villain.
HumboldtBlue
The Child Snatcher.
That motherfucker scared me but also pissed me off, I always wanted to punch him.
eclare
Lindsay Crouse as Margaret in House of Games.
Just look at that parking lot
The Shakespeare play Titus Andronicus was made into a movie in 1999 with Anthony Hopkins and Jessica Lange. There are plenty of villains to be found ,but the worst was Aaron played by Harry Lennox. Toward the movie’s end , when Aaron is to be hanged, he gives a speech that ends with
“ I have done a thousand dreadful things
As willingly as one would kill a fly,
And nothing grieves me more heartily indeed
But that I can not do ten thousand more”.
I believe that qualifies him as a villain.
eclare
@zhena gogolia:
Excellent!
mrmoshpotato
@zhena gogolia: He does have lines. Not many, but he’s not silent.
prostratedragon
@scav: That must be wonderful on the stage. You’re lucky to have seen Rickman in it.
funlady75
Orson Wells the villain in The Stranger…with Loretta Young
kalakal
@NotMax: Isn’t Dennis Price the villain and Alec Guinness the victim(s) in Kind Hearts & Coronets ?
ETA Just saw that NotMax has pointed this out already
prostratedragon
@Polish The Guillotines: It certainly was the engineer who knew how to get them out of their predicament. But the pilot’s slowly dawning realization of how that knowledge was acquired is also worthy.
Mr. Bemused Senior
Leo McKern for sure. Can we also count Clang, the High Priest (Help).
kalakal
Ian Mckellan’s Richard III great on stage and on film
As a hero Branagh’s Henry V was superb
kalakal
@zhena gogolia:
The two smoothest men in cinema history. The casting of Grant & Mason was inspired
moonbat
A fun one would be Gary Oldman as Zorg in The Fifth Element.
One of my favorite exchanges in the film:
Father Cornelius: “You’re a monster, Zorg.”
Zorg: (after an almost coy pause) “I know.”
mrmoshpotato
@funlady75:
Yes. And Edward G Robinson is great too.
moonbat
@kalakal: Agreed. I saw the film in Edinburgh almost by accident in 96 and he was absolutely chilling. Of course the Nazi-ish getup helped some.
kalakal
Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast is really nasty
Bob Hoskins in The Long Good Friday
Gloria DryGarden
Ok, so heroes
Frodo, Samwise, Gandalf, and Aragorn.
Also, in A Discovery of Witches, especially the book trilogy, I think of Diana and Matthew as heroes. There’s a whole range of folks , imperfect humans and beings, a whole mixed bag, who end up having each other’s backs with such fierceness, they are all heroes, in a way. Although it appears to be a book about vampires, witches and creamy creatives, I think it’s really a book about ethics, history, medicine and law.
queen Elizabeth is almost a villain in this book.
CliosFanBoy
DC comic’s villains are more interesting than 99% of their heroes.
moonbat
So for a hero I’d throw Clive Owen as Theo Faren in Children of Men. A completely disillusioned man who suddenly finds hope and mission in the child of another woman. He’s tops.
HumboldtBlue
Patty McCormack — Rhoda: The Bad Seed
Villago Delenda Est
@CliosFanBoy: Can’t disagree. One of the things that Silver Age Marvel did was shake up heroes but good, making them much more multifaceted. Tony Stark had an alcohol problem, Bruce Banner had an anger problem, Peter Parker had girl trouble.
Tehanu
You beat me to it. James Mason is my favorite actor all-time because he was great in everything – hero, sidekick, terrifying villain, pathetic old man, whatever.
Oh yes, I’d forgotten how scary he was!
Gloria DryGarden
@Villago Delenda Est: it’s fun when the characters have real human foibles, and are so relatable.
prostratedragon
@kalakal: the one Hoskins played is kind of interesting, though still definitely a villain. If the one in Sexy Beast had been met by a well-timed stopping kick when he charged up that staircase it would have been much easier. “I thought he was a burglar.”
Gloria DryGarden
Did anyone ever see Jean de Florette? Incredible movie. French w subtitles, at the Indy theaters. No heroes, but the two brothers were definitely villains, in an ordinary way, that was painfully relatable.
I was warned to have someone to talk to right after, and not to drive right away. And so it was.
prostratedragon
Mookie and Da Mayor in Do the Right Thing. They saved a few lives.
zhena gogolia
@mrmoshpotato: I was too lazy to check. I was sure some BJ pedant would correct me if I was wrong.
mrmoshpotato
@kalakal:
And real sexy! No, wait, just nasty.
mrmoshpotato
@zhena gogolia: You threw me for a loop, so I had to check. :)
Annamal
Recency bias but Agatha Harkness of Agatha All Along (I completely understand Marvel burnout but this was a really entertaining campy watch) came into her series as a genuinely interesting villain (how she emerges from the series would be spoilers). She chews scenery like it’s going out of style, has her own theme song, has a long and complicated history of wrong-doing and an awesome swishy coat.
Having a female character occupy this particular moral space isn’t particularly common.
zhena gogolia
@Tehanu: I often think James Mason is my favorite actor of all time.
HumboldtBlue
@prostratedragon:
Yeah they did.
Polish The Guillotines
@prostratedragon: Fair point. Great movie.
SFBayAreaGal
@Villago Delenda Est: They were so good.
WaterGirl
Am I right in thinking that this whole thread has been about heroes and villains in film? And not a single book has been mentioned?
I can’t decided whether we should have another of these about heroes and villains in books, in fiction, or if this means there is no interest in discussing fiction.
billcinsd
@Just look at that parking lot: The Reduced Shakespeare Company does Titus Andronicus as a cooking show
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rhiv70hBZ08
mvr
@WaterGirl: FWIW, I was thinking of mentioning a book hero, but then I decided this was just about movies.
billcinsd
Heroes: Flaming Carrot, The Tick
Real Life Heroes: Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Raoul Wallenberg
Villains: Pigboy/The Deadly Bulb, Peter Lorre’s murderer in M
Real Life Villains: Reinhard Heydrich, Josef Mengele
Chris
I think Sean Connery and Michael Caine’s characters in The Man Who Would Be King are probably the best done villains of all time, simply in terms of making you feel for the villains.
Lots of movies make you sympathize with the villains, but they almost always do that by pulling their punches. Oh yes, they’re villains, because they’re (gangsters, thieves, assassins, wev), but they never hurt anybody who’s innocent. Oh yes, they’re villains, but everybody they’re fighting is even worse than they are. Oh yes, they’re villains, but they were forced into it by circumstances. Oh yes, they’re villains, but sometimes a villain’s what the world needs, huh?
By comparison to most of Hollywood, The Man Who Would Be King goes all-out. They’re really bad people, according to almost any moral code you care to mention. They’re colonialists. They’re rapists. They’re thieves. They’re deserters. They’re blasphemers. They’re killers. And there isn’t some colonial pulp villain like the Thuggee cult around to serve as the Greater Evil and make them look good. And there isn’t any compelling reason why they would have had to do anything they did. They’re just the worst. They absolutely deserve to be strung up from the nearest tree as much as any fictional characters that ever lived.
And yet somehow the scene where Connery realizes that he’s fucked up everything and asks for forgiveness, and Caine grants it to him wholeheartedly, and Connery just says “everything’s all right then” and goes out to his death singing “The Song Of Man” still manages to get me like few moments in film.
I’m really not sure why, and I’m tempted to put it entirely down to the fact that Sean Connery and Michael Caine are simply two of the most charismatic actors ever to grace Hollywood with their presence, and their chemistry with each other is first rate, too.
RevRick
@WaterGirl: When I saw the post, my first thought was Captain Ahab from Moby Dick.*
*Mennonite theologian John Howard Yoder called Moby Dick the missing book of the Bible.
Chris
As far as the heroic side;
This doesn’t say much about any of the actors’ individual characters, but I do believe there’s a position of Ultimate All-American Hero Actor that was occupied first by Humphrey Bogart, then by John Wayne, then by Harrison Ford.
Really can’t say who takes up the mantle after Ford, though.
wjca
Unlike the folks who get serious here, I’m going with Blazing Saddles. The heroes (Bart, the Waco Kid, and, IMHO, Mongo) are silly but fun. But what makes it for me are the villians: Territorial Attorney General Hedley Lamarr (Harvey Korman), Taggart (Slim Pickens), and Governor William J. Le Petomane (Mel Brooks). They aren’t super scary. But they are like real life villains: not real bright and laughable inept. They remind me of the bozos around Trump. They can do a lot of damage, but mostly are unable to get out of their own way.
Chris
@kalakal:
James Bond villains are just fun when they’re done right, which is why Goldfinger is the very best of them. A close and more recent second is Elliot Carver from Tomorrow Never Dies. Jonathan Pryce is clearly having the time of his life.
@A Ghost to Most:
The world is definitely screaming out for another Bond villain in the tradition of the most over-the-top Roger Moore era villains like Stromberg and Drax. The insane capitalists who’d risen so far they didn’t even want money anymore, they just wanted to destroy the whole world so they could reign over what was left of it as gods.
Even without Musk, the fad of lavish post-apocalyptic bunkers for nervous billionaires, who keep asking whether they should use shock collars or something more exotic to make sure their servants don’t turn on them, would be enough to justify this.
Chet Murthy
Villain: How about Tyler Durden ? In the spirit of @Chris:’ comment, he just wanted to burn it all down and rule in the ruins, eh?
Gloria DryGarden
@WaterGirl: I definitely mentioned 2 book series that were also made into movies.
And mostly one begins by reading “lord of the rings”
and “a discovery of witches” seems way more accessible in book form.
#98. But you may have the pie filter on me, so I don’t really exist.
NotMax
@kalakal
Also Ben Kingsley in the series Perpetual Grace LTD. Monstrous underneath a thin-as-onionskin veneer of rectitude.
Chris
@lowtechcyclist:
I love Darth Vader on his own merits (and how could I not, the Star Wars originals will always be my three favorite movies of all time), but I kind of dislike the fact that he started the fad of villains needing a tragic origin story.
Which eventually came around full circle to poison the Star Wars sequels, IMHO. Not that there wasn’t plenty wrong with these things. But pretty much the only way you could make Kylo Ren interesting was to not give him a tragic origin story, and make him a contrast to his grandfather rather than a total rehash. And that was what the middle movie was at least trying to do, going through the motions of a redemption arc before pulling it out from under you and showing that this isn’t that kind of movie and he isn’t that kind of villain. But then the next movie hastily backtracks on all of that, to recycle the same plot beats as Vader.
Chris
@SFBayAreaGal:
If we’re doing DS9, Gul Dukat remains possibly the greatest villain in Star Trek.
NotMax
@Chris
Weyoun?
Chris
@Gloria DryGarden:
No, but I’ve read the books, originally as a teenager and a few times again since.
What strikes me in the age of Trump is how much Pagnol really captures that small-town combination of parochial, mean, and apathetic that turns these places into breeding grounds for Trumpism. The entire story is about a guy working himself to death whose problems could’ve been solved in a moment if anybody in the community had bothered to tell him just six words, but they don’t, because 1) he’s an outsider and you don’t help outsiders, 2) the guy who wants his land is an institution in the local community, and 3) mind your own business.
Take the same shitty mindset, turn it completely rancid and turbocharge it with a media apparatus that’s screaming an up-to-eleven version of it into everybody’s ears, and oh yeah, that’s the modern red states all the way. (All over the West, too, not just in America).
I never would’ve remembered them if you hadn’t brought it up, but oh yeah, those guys are prime villain material, and tragically topical for this day and age.
Chris
@WaterGirl:
I would 100% be there for another thread strictly about book heroes and villains.
Chris
@wjca:
It may not be a serious movie, but it’s still one of the greatest American movies of all time.
Chet Murthy
@Gloria DryGarden: I saw both Jean de Florette and Manon des Sources. My memory is that Daniel Autueil and Yves Montand were the baddies in the first film. And there’s a twist involving Autueil’s character and Depardieu’s, at the end, but I won’t give it away. And in Manon des Sources, Autueil is again the baddie.
They were -lovely- films. Just lovely.
Chris
@Chet Murthy:
Oddly enough, Tyler Durden has somehow gotten both less and more relevant over time.
On the one hand, his world is completely unrecognizable even from the point of view of a mere ten years later. Is there anything more First World Problems than a guy whining that his white-collar middle-class well-paid job is just empty and he doesn’t know what deeper meaning to give his life, maaann? Everybody who entered the workforce after 2008 wants to break that whiny asshole’s nose.
On the other hand, is there anything more 2024 than “I’m a white guy experiencing a crisis of masculinity and I’m going to satisfy it by celebrating the beauty of violence and wrecking the whole world until it’s forced to acknowledge me?” That guy is a Trump-voting Proud Boy incel two decades before that was even a thing.
Chet Murthy
@Chris: My thoughts on the movie -exactly-. Nailed it in one!
Gloria DryGarden
@Chet Murthy: d’accord! Yes, I saw both, and I Do remember that twist.. it made it all the more chilling. I loved these films. But such personal villainy.
and of course, naturellement, I am a Gerard depardieu fan.
bjacques
Missy (Michelle Gomez) from Dr. Who! Basically the same hilarious wigged-out character from The Green Wing but with super powers.
Chet Murthy
@Gloria DryGarden: I loved him in JdF, and also in Cyrano. It’s all turned a bit into ash in my mouth, with the recent revelations of his rapes.
Bruce K in ATH-GR
@RevRick: Citing Captain Ahab makes me think of Charles Durning as Doc Hopper. His quest is a lot like Ahab’s, if you can recognize that his white whale is a frog who just wants to go to Hollywood and sing and dance and make millions of people happy.
(Which makes The Muppet Movie the first movie to tell the story of Moby-Dick from the point of view of the whale. The second, of course, being Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan.)
Durning obviously knew that his character was supposed to be cartoonishly reprehensible, and he was apparently a good sport about it.
And while I’m on the topic, how about Tim Curry as Long John Silver in Muppet Treasure Island?
Gloria DryGarden
@Chet Murthy: oh no¡! I seem to have missed this. When you’re a star, you might get away with it… shit.
he was in Hamlet, with Kenneth Branagh, I think, wasn’t he one of rosecrantz and guildenstern?
did he get prosecuted? Merde.
this is like hearing that Neil gaiman was doing stuff, and also when we heard Marion zimmer Bradley- god i loved her books- was doing heinous things to children, some sort of sexual abuse and trafficking. Real life villains.
SomeRandomGuy
@schrodingers_cat: I vastly prefer BPS – it’s a *useful* metric, while “baud” just refers to state changes.
No offense, Baud.
NotMax
One more.
Ron Perlman masticating every piece of scenery as Lord Vox in <The Adventures of Captain Zoom in Outer Space.
;)
Tandem
@SFBayAreaGal: You are so right about Kai Winn. Louise Fletcher made her so chilling and creepy that even all these years later, I still have to force myself to watch the episodes in which she has a large role. I did enjoy watching her get duped by Gul Dukat towards the end of the series though.
Chris
@Chet Murthy:
I don’t follow him that closely, but the last I heard of him was in the Hollande administration when he announced he was giving up his French citizenship and becoming Russian.
Yeah. He’s one of those guys.
The rape revelations are all but inevitable when you see him in that light, really.