Since we are approaching the worst corn crop in decades, why don’t we do something smart like remove all the price supports and tariffs for sugar production, which would essentially stop encouraging food processors to use high fructose corn syrup, allowing the corn to be used elsewhere?
Reader Interactions
71Comments
Comments are closed.
cathyx
Do you want to bankrupt the farmers and food processors even more? They need their handouts.
mark
ahh, John Cole; so young, so naive
a hip hop artist from Idaho (fka Bella Q)
Because that would make too much sense?
Ron Beasley
The problem is HFCS is still much easier to use. It can be sent through pipes and transported via tanker trucks so you would probably have to tax the HFCS.
cathyx
@mark: But he’s cute when he’s naive.
burnspbesq
An even better idea: stop using corn to make ethanol.
the Conster
Then people wouldn’t develop diabesity and need pharmaceuticals, then where would the economy be, smart guy, huh?
Belafon (formerly anonevent)
Let’s see:
1. Reduce the number of ways corn can be sold,
2. Make the price of corn jump through the roof.
I suspect number 2 will always be the final answer. See oil.
Todd
Why do you hate America, Cole?
Villago Delenda Est
You’re not thinking, John, about the poor ADM executives who would have smaller bonuses.
You’re heartless, did you know that?
cathyx
@burnspbesq: Better yet, stop using corn to feed anything but cattle. It only serves to make humans fatter.
NonyNony
Why do you hate capitalism Cole?
Wazmo
Then that would impact those who sell Mexican/Passover-certified Coca-Cola, which commands a huge price premium.
The Ancient Randonneur
This is one area where you get bipartisan support and bipartisan opposition to these price supports. Geography and constituency play the deciding factor. Farm state Democrats and Republicans actually agreeing on something. Go figure.
Quicksand
Get your greedy government hands off my subsidies!
Litlebritdifrnt
@Ron Beasley: I remember them there tanker trucks in the X-Files Fight the Future….. I knew there was something funny about them.
Just Some Fuckhead
Even better idea: stop using corn to make popcorn. Use okra or celery instead.
Steve
Sugar is Cuban, ergo communist. Corn is American and patriotic.
Emdee
The old old story (and I read this when I was a teenager, back when we had to get our issues of Newsweek from Mr. Gutenberg himself) goes like this:
The sugar industry successfully petitioned (read “lobbied”) Congress to set a floor on sugar prices of 25¢ per pound. This was at a time when global sugar prices were somewhere around 5¢ per pound, a price at which the American sugar industry found it difficult to compete domestically.
Not too long after this, the corn growers figured out how to make high-fructose corn syrup, which they could sell profitably for 20¢ per pound (in sugar equivalence). As the granulated sugar industry had successfully argued then—and now—this stuff wasn’t “real sugar” so it wasn’t subject to the 25¢-per-pound floor. That’s when all the soft drink and industrial food processors shifted to HFCS, because it was 20% cheaper. That’s when we had the “Pepsi Challenge,” because Pepsi’s formula worked better with HFCS than Coke’s did. That’s when Coke reformulated for HFCS, giving “New Coke,” and all that stuff.
That’s also why soft drinks everywhere else in the world are always made with pure cane/beet sugar: outside of the US floor, it’s about 25% of the price of HFCS.
Or so the story goes. I have no citations, and this comment is worth pretty much exactly what you paid for it, caveat emptor, YMMV, and so on.
PeakVT
@cathyx: You’ll have to pry my fresh corn-on-the-cob from my cold, dead hands.
different-church-lady
I thought the whole damn problem was that we produced too much corn.
Citizen Alan
I remember predicting a few years back that we’d have food riots by 2020. I’m starting to feel that I was being optimistic.
David Koch
killing subsidies and regulations would be socialist
Richard
http://thehill.com/blogs/e2-wire/e2-wire/241601-lawmakers-sign-letter-urging-epa-to-lower-corn-ethanol-target
Elias
If corporations are people too, why can Mitt Romney own them? Enforce the 13th Amendment. You hear me businesses? You have nothing to lose but your chains.
Mjaum
Sort of off-topic-ish… I just read that americans, due to the draught, have started painting their lawns.
Green, one assumes.
Nah, there’s no global warming here. Nor any crazy people. No sir!
I just feel that this seriously misses the point somewhere. I feel like the whole world has turned into the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy…
bingbango
Cole and his paranoid “Global Food Riots” blathering continues unabated. Stay gloomy Cole. Sucks to be you.
Ben Franklin
Imagine the economic repercussions…..
Less falsely diagnosed ADHD
Fewer type II Diabetics
A more resilient physiology for the Body Politic.
We can’t survive that disaster.
gnomedad
@Just Some Fuckhead:
Popokra? Popcelery? What?
Seebach
I expect corn supports will go away when hemp is legalized. So, after the collapse of the US or if Obama has a really awesome lame duck period.
Ben Franklin
@Seebach:
Only after the cannabis is denuded of any trichomes.
tuna
Some hedge fund is now looking into buying up all the cane sugar and holding it off the market until it’s costs as much as the corn stuff.
Michael
Grand Idea Mr Cole. Especially since those bastards at American Crystal Sugar (beet sugar) are locking out their union workers. Coincidentally, I was one of those union workers many years ago and we were underpaid then in the face of record profits and I’m sure the same holds true today. Screw them.
danah gaz (fka gaz)
@Mjaum:
You too? For some reason I keep thinking of that passage (I think it was in Mostly Harmless) where the Guide explains the economic collapse of whole planets due to the proliferation of shoe stores.
Don’t ask me why.
Jay S
@Mjaum: Cliff Mass makes a good case that the current US weather pattern is not caused by global warming here.
It appears that this US weather is too extreme to be blamed on the current measured global warming.
ETA Cliff Mass is not a global warming denialist.
Mjaum
@Jay S: Um. Right. Because if it is too extreme, then it can’t be global warming. After all, global warming happens in easily measured, non-variable, unchaotic ways.
Want to buy a bridge? Or two? I’ll throw in a tunnel for free. After all, you’d only be paying for nothing, right? That’s cheap!
(I spent some time on PJmedia earlier. I think I broke something. It may have been my sarcasm. Or my irony. So sorry.)
Mjaum
@danah gaz (fka gaz): Forty Two. That’s why.
Edit: No can use emote asterisk thingies. Waaaah!
The Other Chuck
@cathyx: @cathyx:
Actually, corn is pretty lousy for cattle too, since corn-fed cows typically have to be pumped full of antibiotics.
Cermet
@Jay S: Yet this is exactly what climate change calls for from its models – all weather types occur more often and longer. No one ever said that a climate model is anything but a software program constructed by human minds that provides a rough set of global average numbers for the model earth – luckly, math and the universe seem to have a real relationship. Yes, these models do in fact show tends in the real climate (never weather) that do occur for the Earth. Yet, these models never will be, and never were exact matchs to real global weather – just give global averages that track very close to what really does happen. As always, people can not seperate weather from climate. That is never an issue for people who read with an open mind.
Spatula
I take pleasure in the fact that most of the states suffering most from the current drought/heat are as Red as the flames that shall soon consume them and their four door pick em up trucks.
Omnes Omnibus
@Just Some Fuckhead: If it worked, it would the most useful thing ever done with either celery or okra. (I know it ain’t gumbo if it ain’t got okra, but I leave the slimy little okra bits in the bowl. A dill pickle spear works better in a bloody mary.)
Linda Featheringill
@Jay S:
Blocked weather systems:
Yes, they’ve happened before and will happen again. However, as global warming progresses, when heat is trapped in an area the temperatures can climb higher than they used to.
BTW: In Oklahoma, average highs for July and August is about 95 degrees F. [Forgot where I got that number.] So when the temps there are 10-15 degrees higher than that for days on end, is that not an indication of more heat being in the system?
SteveinSC
If we were to use the same amount of land that we farm and live on (18 per cent is arable) and used solar cells we could generate an average daily electrical power (counting zero for night in the average) more than an order of magnitude greater than our daily consumption. The solar cells are effectively of infinite lifetime, so no matter how much energy it takes to make them, we will always recover the cost. Major problem is storage for night-recovery, but then at night we don’t use that much energy, so maybe the new battery technologies could help. I.e. 2005 U.S. energy consumption 1×10**20 joules. Solar half day at 1000 watts per square meter peak, 20 percent solar cell efficiency and 1/pi average day and night is 4×10**21 joules per year using 18% of non-arable land.
Maude
@Jay S:
35
Is that like a high pressure dome? NOAA has a nice diagram of one on their site.
El Cid
Some look to the near future and see global food riots, because they’re gloomy; others look to near future and see global food raves!
Linda Featheringill
@Linda Featheringill: #42
Referring to average highs in Oklahoma:
http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/climate/getnorm.php?id=lwto2
[It’s just a table. Don’t bother if you don’t care. It’s all right.]
some guy
another banner day for Al-Qaida today, with summary executions in Alleppo today.
smell the freedom!
trollhattan
@John Cole,
A few months back you asked the collective what topics should the front pagers be looking at that you weren’t focusing on already, and I think I responded climate change and the Farm Bill reauthorization, so here’s a twofer.
trollhattan
@Spatula: But it’s Obama’s fault. Pate density is quite high in red states.
Belafon (formerly anonevent)
@danah gaz (fka gaz): Actually, that was Restaurant at the end of the Universe.
El Cid
@some guy: Was Al Qa’ida involved? Or is that “Al Qa’ida” as a generic term?
Ocotillo
Hey while we are at it, let’s normalize relations with Cuba and buy their sugar to use for ethanol.
pluege
this is repug nation; novel ideas that make sense – NOT WANTED!
Heliopause
You don’t understand, John, we’re as dependent on corn as the Irish were on potatoes. If this drought keeps up a couple more years we’ll all have to emigrate to China. In a hundred years they’ll celebrate the 4th of July as a quaint little ethnic festival.
Hypatia's Momma
@Linda Featheringill:
In order for the historical average to be 95F, then some days are going to have to be higher than 95F and some lower.
Cain
@Heliopause:
If we could get the red staters to move and leave the liberals here that would be best. Those guys will be quite comfortable in China except for not being able to own guns.
Jesse Ewiak
Sorry, you’re still not good enough for Jason Kuznicki over at LOOG.
Another Halocene Human
@Quicksand: millionaires in Florida are dying for your support
Another Halocene Human
@Michael: The US gov has actively been on the side of the companies in crushing private sector unions since 1980. (It’s been crushing farm worker unions since the 1940s.)
Another Halocene Human
What if the US government gave labor the same treatment as anti-abortion activists give abortion rights, slowly making more and more illegal until their activities are so hampered that people just plain get boxed in and give up … and nobody noticed?
Americans don’t not want unions any more than women don’t want access to reproductive services in red states, but they have no access to effective ones in either case. Working class GOP voters are the prom night dumpster babies of our political hellscape.
Another Halocene Human
@Jesse Ewiak: Watching them discuss why government needs to intervene in the crop commodity markets is so cute.
Being a libertarian means being able to congratulate yourself on being such a deep and insightful thinker for finally sussing out what the rest of us learned before we were 17?
Bruce S
Why do you hate America?
joel hanes
Our host asks the musical question:
why don’t we do something smart like remove all the price supports and tariffs for sugar production?</em?
Because Debbie Wasserman-Shultz, corrupt corporatist "New Democrat" and currently DNC chair, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Big Sugar, and is mobbed up with the Cuban expatriate right.
tybee
@Just Some Fuckhead:
mmmm. fried okra.
tybee
@Emdee:
that’s pretty close to what i recall as well.
i worked for “big sugar” for some years in the 90’s.
to understand sugar prices and controls, you also need to know one name: fanjul
Joe K
@Spatula:
Have some for us poor lefties stuck in those states, eh?
chopper
well.
chopper
here’s the drought map, projected through october.
note the only improvement is in the desert southwest and portions of the rockies where little is grown. note also the huge swaths of drought include pretty much the entire wheat and corn belts.
John M. Burt
Price supports are basically a back-door way of adding a little “command economy” mojo to the “free market”. The corn situation shows that there are indeed worse things than a command economy based on what people need, which is a command economy based on making profits for a chosen few.
James Hulsey
@Mjaum: drought, not draught.
http://www.english-for-students.com/Drought-and-Draught.html
Other that that, you’re spot on. I’m about to spend the year dead for tax purposes.
Don
The sugar price floor has cost us jobs and manufacturing too. There’s abandoned candy facilities in Chicago where operations have been moved to Mexico not for labor reasons but because of that artificially increased sugar price. Make it out of the US and you don’t have to pay as much. Various facts and figures here: http://sugarreform.org/
I joke with my wife that we were meant to be. She works for a trade association representing confectioner manufacturers (they spun off the above linked PAC) so they dislike big sugar. I grew up in South Florida and have environmental leanings so I despise them for all the destruction they wrought on the Everglades.