Dodgers cave to culture war crank and senator from other side of country, disinvite venerable charity group from Pride Night: https://t.co/zjkzmiRTbm
— Defector (@DefectorMedia) May 18, 2023
Chris Thompson, at Defector:
The Los Angeles Dodgers this week publicly disinvited the Los Angeles Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence from participating in the team’s 2023 Pride Night, to be held at Dodger Stadium on June 16. The team originally planned to honor the activist group with something called the Community Hero Award, but after being confronted with what the team describes as “some controversy,” the Dodgers took the unusual step of announcing on Twitter that they’d removed the Sisters from “this year’s group of honorees.”…
Presumably the Dodgers had a pretty good idea who the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence were before this supposed controversy; after all, they had decided to give them a community service award. The Sisters have a history of charity and activism dating back to 1979, and the Los Angeles mission was launched in 1995. Members dress in flamboyant drag and give themselves funny, bawdy names—Sister GladAss, Sister Dana Van Iquity, Sister Betty Does—but their mission and works are straightforwardly good and necessary. The Sisters were essential activists and grassroots fundraisers of the AIDS epidemic era; in 1982 they made and distributed what was probably the first safe-sex pamphlet created by and for gay men, and member Bobbi Campbell (Sister Florence Nightmare) appeared on the seminal 1983 Newsweek cover that brought the epidemic to wider public recognition. They’ve raised millions of dollars in donations over the years for humanitarian causes, charities, and emergency grants, and helped bring attention to art projects, anti-war protests, suicide prevention efforts, homeless initiatives, and on and on.
On May 15, Senator Marco Rubio (R-State That Does Not Contain Los Angeles) publicized a letter he says he sent to MLB commissioner Rob Manfred, tattling on the Sisters for what he describes as “diabolical parodies” of Christian faith, and asking the commissioner whether he believes the Dodgers are being “inclusive and welcoming to everyone” when they honor an organization that “intentionally mocks and degrades Christians.” Rubio’s letter seemingly helped rouse fellow bigots to action, including Bill Donohue, the longtime head of the Catholic League, a group dedicated to waging right-wing culture war under the guise of fighting anti-Catholic discrimination. (“Group” is used loosely; the usual joke is that the Catholic League consists mainly of Bill Donohue’s fax machine, which is directly connected to the front page of the New York Post.)…
The intimidation campaign may have been straight out of the Reagan era, but it seems to have worked. Responding to the entirely manufactured offense of a scaly right-wing politician from the “Don’t Say Gay” state—a state located approximately 2,300 miles away—and a boomer nutbar pursuing a decades-old astroturfing campaign, the Dodgers disinvited a good and essential charity organization from participating in an event meant to celebrate the very communities they’ve worked to serve. In attempting to stave off phony controversy, the Dodgers now invite coverage (like this) of their cowardice. As we all know, you cannot have a successful Pride Night until your plans have received the approval of Marco Rubio and the Catholic League.
“Do not let people who hate us all decide that some parts of our community are more tolerable than others.” https://t.co/PIGBgjl1MK
— Mary Emily O’Hara (@MaryEmilyOHara) May 19, 2023
The Dodgers booted the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence. Then came a big-league backlash https://t.co/TLsjhVC7yP
— Los Angeles Times (@latimes) May 20, 2023
Nothing brings a community together like outsiders getting up in their business:
… About a third of Angelenos are Catholic, and many within the Dodgers franchise and its fandom are devout.
But outcry over the “drag nuns” began in the Midwest, with a call-in campaign led by the conservative advocacy organization CatholicVote [based in Madison, WI]. At the urging of the organization’s president, Brian Burch, followers flooded the ball club with outraged messages over plans to honor the Los Angeles Sisters with the Community Heroes Award at the team’s 10th annual Pride Night on June 16…
He went on to accuse the Sisters of “taunting the women religious who serve the poor in Southern California and around the world” — a charge the group rejects in the strongest terms…
Rather, the order draws inspiration from Catholic nuns — alongside religious sisters of many other faiths — serving the needy who are neglected by others because of their sexuality or gender expression, according to the Sisters and scholars and acolytes of the group.
“Many Sisters feel there’s a difference between what they’re doing and what drag performers do,” said Melissa M. Wilcox, a professor of religious studies at UC Riverside and author of “Queer Nuns: Religion, Activism, and Serious Parody.” “The Sisters are actually emulating nuns. They’ll say, ‘We’re nuns because we do the work that nuns do.’”
That work includes decades of charity, outreach, education and “bar ministry” in gay communities around the world. It also includes provocative monikers, such as Sister Porn Again and Sister Mary F— Poppins, as well as outlandish garb, chaotic pronouns and flip exhortations to “go forth and sin some more.
“I like to think of [the habit] as a bonfire or a lighthouse, so that light can shine out into places where there are no resources and there isn’t a strong community,” Sister Unity said…
“They’re the tricksters of the movement — they make us laugh, and laughing is powerful,” said Catholic activist Rosa Manriquez, who lives near Dodger Stadium. “I doubt there’s any nun worth her ruler and her rosary who’s upset about the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence.” …
But what could have been the ball club’s Bud Light moment transformed instead into an impassioned defense of one of the world’s most outré drag communities.
Other power players quickly got involved. The American Civil Liberties Union blasted the Dodgers on Twitter, saying it would pull out of Pride Night if the club did not reverse course. L.A. County Supervisor Lindsey Horvath vowed to do the same, while L.A. City Councilmember Eunisses Hernandez, whose district includes Dodger Stadium, condemned the move.
On Thursday, the Los Angeles LGBT Center issued an ultimatum: Readmit the Sisters or cancel Pride Night altogether. That evening, as the Dodgers lost 16-8 to the St. Louis Cardinals, the club seemed poised to reverse course.
For the Los Angeles Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, the support came as the biggest shock of all.
“We’re not used to people going to bat for drag queens,” Sister Unity said. “The reason [people did] is not because of our prominence in the community in terms of our spectacle but because of the work that we do.” …
Even a columnist at USA Today called the Dodgers’ action “a remarkably cowardly move“!
The Mayor of Anaheim ups the ante:
🏳️🌈 I’m inviting the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence to join me for @Angels Pride Night at Anaheim Stadium on June 7. Pride should be inclusive and like many, I was disappointed in the Dodgers decision. #CityofKindness #Anaheim
— Mayor Ashleigh Aitken (@AshleighAitken) May 20, 2023
Baud
BREAKING: Dodgers sign exclusivity deal with Bud Light!
Yutsano
I’m struggling to understand why it took this wonderful sentence to get me to realise that Lil Marco is indeed a lizard person.
James E Powell
One suspects that maybe Dodgers ownership & management are in accord with right wing crazies. Quite a few professional sports franchise owners were major donors to Trump both times.
RaflW
Good friends of mine are huge Dodgers fans (they live in the LA area, both work off-camera in film production). We met up in Houston last night over a fantastic seafood dinner. One topic was this. They’re pissed, and think a lot of other fans are too.
My longtime friend said the Dodgers were screwing up the legacy of Jackie Robinson by caving in to homophobic discrimination heading into Pride season. They’re cis-het, btw. But clearly get what a cluster this is, and bad precedent giving in to a powerful majority group (Catholics) claiming “victim” status at a time when it’s obvious that LGBTQ people — especially T — are being attacked by government.
My friend W- – was particularly adamant in calling b.s. on the religious ‘persecution’ of a majoritarian Christian group. We didn’t discuss lil’ Marco, but his performative bible-versy Catholicism is itself pretty manipulative and gross.
Benw
The fucking Dodgers have really shot an air ball here when a little backbone could got them a hole in one.
Baud
They should just start calling it Shame Night.
Trivia Man
Talk about Rainbow Washing… “we’ll pay lip service to inclusion but only in the most superficial way possible. And only If it’s ok with the most exclusionary groups around.”
Baud
I wonder if they’ll ban “controversial” religious groups during Faith Night.
Anotherlurker
I’ll bet that if Dodgers current ownership were in charge in the 1940s/1950s Jackie Robinson would have been bounced from the team at the first racist complaint
Fucking cowards.
NotMax
It’s been downhill since Da Bums abandoned Brooklyn. Perhaps even since they shortened their name from Trolley Dodgers.
bbleh
Good on the Sisters and allies for fighting back! Rubio and the CL are bullies and the Dodgers are being obedient seconds, and both tend to be surprised when their chosen victims fight back. More of this!
Edmund dantes
I forgot who but I thought some other groups pulled out as soon as the sisters got disinvited.
Ruckus
@Baud:
I always thought that was Butt Light…..
Dan B
I knew Bobbi Campbell. The last time he was in Seattle he gave me a big wet kiss in the middle of a busy street in broad daylight. A character.
Ruckus
My father used to pay for a box at Dodger Stadium.
If I still had one it would remain empty and I would ask for my money back.
As a senior citizen who was born in the city of Los Angeles and whose mother was born in the same hospital and whose grand parents ALL lived within the city limits I think I have a right to be pissed at this.
I believe that I will inform the Dodgers that I am pissed as hell at this, that I absolutely do not support them and that they suck donkey balls.
Baud
OT, but Biden is awesome.
https://v.redd.it/83yt8lh0t71b1
TheOtherHank
@Ruckus (re: comment #13): No, that’s how Trump wanted to cure covid
Redshift
@RaflW:
The appalling thing about the Catholic League (well, one appalling thing) is that it isn’t part of the church, it’s always been one conservative activist puffing himself up by claiming to to speak for it.
WaterGirl
Next time the Catholic Church is invited to participate in something, they should be disinvited because of the decades-long pedophilia scandal.
Steve in the ATL
@Benw: literally!
Suzanne
LMAO. Wrong city to be bigots, LA Dodgers.
WaterGirl
Perhaps the Pope could step up and give the sisters some kind of award.
Scout211
Commentary by LA Times sports collumnist, Dylan Hernández
satby
@Baud: I get a log in page 😕
Suzanne
@WaterGirl:
I still refer to them as the Child Rapist Protection Racket.
It wins me many friends.
Baud
@satby:
Try this.
ETA: It seems to be rated mature for some reason.
Sister Golden Bear
This and Bud Light caving to bigots are why a lot of LGBTQ+ people are leery of rainbow washing. Corporations are eager to take our money, but quick to abandon us when it matters.
Mallard Filmore
@Baud:
Have to check the program to see if atheists and Satanic Temple are listed.
satby
@Baud: nope, I’m supposed to log in to prove I’m over 18. That never happened with reddit before, but I’ll find it on a different site, thanks.
Frankensteinbeck
Is it just me, or are those nuns ADORABLE?
Ruckus
@TheOtherHank:
Well he does know ass, he looks at it in the mirror way too many times a second. Of course what he sees and what he thinks he sees standing facing a mirror are two way different things.
WaterGirl
@satby: I got a login page, but i just clicked the gray button on the left – something like “I’m over 18” and then it let me see it without logging in.
zhena gogolia
@Baud: Cool!
satby
Not to defend the Church, but both of the organizations claiming to speak for it are independent PACs that also fight against Catholic theology being liberalized in any way. They absolutely don’t speak for the Church. Their ideal pope was the previous NAZI youth one.
zhena gogolia
@WaterGirl: Me too.
Baud
@satby:
Transcript
satby
Non-reddit link. Ooops, too slow, Baud beat me.
tokyokie
My estimation of Lil Marco was already astoundingly low, but it’s now somewhere beneath the Marianas Trench. Seriously, this is how he works for his constituents? By stomping on a group of good-hearted people who happen to dress and sometimes act outrageously? What have the Sisters ever done to him or anybody in Florida? And what does his pissy tirade accomplish? Other than demonstrating that Lil Marco is a despicable coward whose penance should include an apology and a resignation from public office.
Elizabelle
I think a lot of Dodgers fans should attend in non-binary, or drag queen, or some kind of supportive clothing and fashion. Lipstick would be fine. Wear some of the colorful ribbons.
Make them wonder. All the Dodgers see is green.
Elizabelle
@satby: Yup. Donohue no doubt hates Pope Francis.
Steeplejack
@satby:
Someone is saying “fuck” on Reddit! 🙀
satby
@Steeplejack: You know the kumbaya police are out of control if they’re trying to make reddit PG
Frankensteinbeck
@Steeplejack:
Profanity on Ballon Juice… my fainting couch… my pearls…! I shall have the vapors!
dmsilev
As noted, the Catholic League is basically just one guy with a big mouth. This is not new information; he’s been at this for years and years now. Anybody who ‘caves’ to him was likely just looking for an excuse to do whatever ‘caving’ represents anyway.Which does not speak well of the Dodgers ownership.
The LA Times has been giving this extensive coverage since the whole mess started.
Yutsano
@Steeplejack: Quelle horreur!
Geminid
@satby: Another zinger from the G7 meeting: when reporters asked President Zelenskyy if he was disappointed that Brazilian President Lula did not meet with him, he replied that Lula should be the one who’s disappointed.
satby
@dmsilev: Yeah, just was reading this article from yesterday:
eclare
@satby:
Same. And I don’t want the reddit app.
eclare
@Baud:
Still can’t view.
satby
@Geminid: nice, and Zelenskyy is right.
Another Scott
@satby: It probably has to do with things like a new-ish law in the UK. Standard.co.uk:
Cheers,
Scott.
satby
@eclare: same story at the yahoo link, plus Baud put the quote @36
eclare
@WaterGirl:
I don’t have the reddit app, I don’t even get that page.
satby
@Another Scott: interesting. But I can usually find an alternative source fairly quickly. Google and I are very fond of each other 😉😂
schrodingers_cat
How is this Marco Rubio’s business?
OT:
Can I share something I just finished coloring?
From Johanna Basford’s Magical Jungle.
eclare
@satby:
Thanks!
Another Scott
@eclare: If it’s all blurry, then your ad blocker is preventing you from seeing the popup where you can click to verify your age.
Horse’s Mouth – Whitehouse.gov:
Hehe.
Cheers,
Scott.
satby
Anyhoo, so what’s the over/under on the Dodgers changing course or the event being cancelled (which would be a PR disaster)?
zhena gogolia
@tokyokie: I agree.
Princess
*This* is cancel culture.
zhena gogolia
@schrodingers_cat: Gorgeous!
eclare
@Another Scott:
Thank you!
eclare
@satby:
I have no idea, but wow, talk about horrible marketing/pr! Allowing Marco to have a voice in what happens in LA? Heads should roll in the Dodgers organization, this was so unnecessary.
schrodingers_cat
@zhena gogolia: Thanks! I tried several experiments, my first attempt at a bokeh background and coloring only in one color. I also used a fountain pen for some line work.
japa21
@schrodingers_cat:
That is gorgeous. Thank you for sharing.
Steeplejack
@schrodingers_cat:
Nice blue on blue on blue.
schrodingers_cat
@Steeplejack: Thanks! It was difficult to limit myself to just one color.
schrodingers_cat
@japa21: You are most welcome!
satby
Ok, then I’m going OT to share that I bought a slice of cake like this from a new and incredible baker’s booth at the farmer’s market. It’s my delayed birthday cake treat (Thursday I turned 68, yes, I had a delightful day, thanks in advance). Trying to hold off eating it until at least 7:30pm and will probably fail.
eclare
@schrodingers_cat:
Oh that is gorgeous!
Another Scott
@satby: H(D)B2U!
Cheers,
Scott.
eclare
@satby:
Happy belated birthday!!!!
satby
@Princess: Ironically, the main cancelees will likely end up being the Dodgers. 😂
satby
@Another Scott: @eclare: Thanks, it was. Appreciate!
I mean, did you look at that CAKE???? Awesomeness.
WaterGirl
@eclare: I don’t have the reddit app, either. Or a reddit account.
Maybe what you see is browser specific?
eclare
@WaterGirl:
Maybe…I got the gist. Just weird.
tokyokie
@eclare: Especially since the Dodgers moved their spring training site from Vero Beach to Arizona in 2009.
Elizabelle
@satby: Enjoy every layer of that cake. Yum! Happy birthday week!
piratedan
@eclare: it’s just another token in how people who have a LOT of money feel that their being rich means that their voices carry more weight than others, even on events that have nothing to do with them.
That reminder that being rich is a skill, just like many others, but in context of any given moment not of any more worth than many others.I call it the Great Escape Principal, they needed people of many talents to pull of the escape, forgers, surveyors, tailors, thieves, tunnelers, distractors…. everyone was necessary.
eclare
@satby:
I don’t subscribe so all I saw was the description…but it sounds wonderful!
Goku (aka Amerikan Baka)
@Another Scott:
@satby:
Whatever happened to parents being responsible for what their kids do and see? This is what parental controls are for as well. All this will do is force social media companies to crack down on things the morality police deem “wrong”
NotMax
@satby
Woo-hoo! Have a belated happy.
Baud
@satby:
🎁🎈🎂🍰
Dan B
Trae Crowder and a couple other comedians are doing drag at a show in Knoxville. Actually it should be called skag drag because beards and Sisters style makeup. Maybe no wigs either. Gotta love that man!
Goku (aka Amerikan Baka)
@satby:
Happy Belated Birthday!
Baud
@schrodingers_cat:
👍
MomSense
@schrodingers_cat:
That’s awesome!
I bought some edibles today. I’m going to take one before bed and see if it helps me sleep.
eclare
@tokyokie:
I don’t understand the move. This is not snark, I don’t really follow baseball, how is the move related to this issue?
Again, no snark.
Steeplejack
@satby:
Happy birthday! 🎂
eclare
@Dan B:
Awesome! I went to college at UT!
VeniceRiley
zhena gogolia
@satby: Mmm. I have a friend who makes a cake like that, but it’s a Siberian honey cake — it has a nutty frosting and is incredibly delicious.
karen marie
@Baud: I’m old enough to remember that JFK had to swear his Catholicism would have no influence on his decision-making as president.
How low we’ve sunk.
Jackie
@Baud: It wants me to download the app to view. Nope.
I’ll have to take your word for Biden’s awesomeness.
Steeplejack
@eclare:
Presumably no connection to, or influence from, Florida now.
eclare
@Jackie:
Yeah, that is what I got.
Sure Lurkalot
I can say without fact checking that the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence have done more good for people in this country than the empty soul that is Marco Rubio.
WaterGirl
@eclare: Scott’s transcript was 10x better than the short video. So you’re all good.
Frankensteinbeck
@Goku (aka Amerikan Baka):
The morality police tried to use it to keep their children completely ignorant of the existence of sex, much less the existence of other lifestyles. It keeps failing, so they’re trying to completely remove everything they don’t want their kids to accept from public view.
eclare
@Steeplejack:
Oh, gotcha, just a big FU to Florida. I am not a toddler so I missed the temper tantrum.
Sure Lurkalot
@satby: happy birthday, you’ve caught up with me at last!
Elizabelle
@VeniceRiley: that sounds great to me.
satby
@NotMax: @Baud: @Goku (aka Amerikan Baka): @Steeplejack:
Thanks guys!
satby
@Elizabelle: Missed you, thanks!
@Sure Lurkalot: caught up, but for how long 😉
@zhena gogolia: Your friend must be amazing because I can’t imagine the patience required to make anything with that many layers.
I’m catching a hint of raspberry in the chocolate icing. Yep, I caved, but could only eat half, it’s that rich.
HinTN
@Dan B: Some relatively well known musician played a recent Nashville show in drag.
satby
@karen marie: Again, those aren’t official Catholic organizations any more that the SCOTUS Handmaid’s wacky group is. All of them believe the official Catholic Church has gotten far too liberal. Which just shows how off the rails these groups are. The Westboro Baptists of Catholicism.
satby
@HinTN: James McMurtry, and his
fiddleaccordian player was too; she’s female so she wore a suit. God help me, the best pic is on reddit 😂Bill Arnold
@Another Scott:
Here’s the video of the tail end of that transcript segment, including the “it is for them”.
https://youtu.be/nGNHZquYlhE?t=2198
UncleEbeneezer
This bullshit is one of many reasons I’m an atheist. F*** Marco Rubio and any Catholic person who uses their faith to bash LGBTQ people. I hope the Dodgers make things right and honor the Sisters as intended, and if they don’t I will happily spread the word and join any protests, calls or other actions to maximize the Dodgers’ discomfort.
Cameron
I sorta see Scooter’s reasoning. If Ronald Puddinghands thinks it’s Florida’s business to ship immigrants from Texas to New England, why shouldn’t he blast a local event on the other side of the country? Boy keeps getting out of his lane like that, he’s gonna start showing up in DC in some of those sassy white boots.
Dan B
@satby: Happy Birthday!
Don’t spoil your dinner. /s
The saying goes, Eat dessert first, life is uncertain!
satby
@Dan B: Thanks!
Frankensteinbeck
@satby:
There is a bizarre contradiction there, where the Catholic congregation leans liberal, the American leadership is extreme right wing, and the international leadership – Pope Francis – has the stated position that if you’re worried about sex-related sins while humans still live in fear and poverty, you are part of the problem.
Jackie
@WaterGirl: That would be awesome! I bet he’d do it if asked.
WaterGirl
@Jackie: I’m sending him the mind meld, hoping he is receiving.
Another Scott
@Bill Arnold: Interesting, at the very end he seemed to be saying that he’s expecting the issue to end up in the courts and that they will have to decide what the 14th Amendment means. Meaning, as I understand it, he hopes this will be the last time the Confederates can try to crash the world economy by holding the national debt captive.
From the WH.gov transcript:
That would be a great thing. Make the courts take a stand. If they say the 14th Amendment doesn’t apply, or something similarly nonsensical, then it will light a(nother) fire under the Democrats to flip and keep the House and Senate and get rid of the stupid extra step to raise the limit (make the “Gephardt Rule” the default).
Cheers,
Scott.
Jackie
@Another Scott: Thanks for that, Scott!😊
japa21
@Frankensteinbeck:
Less and less of the US leadership is far right wing. Pope Francis has been working, as openings become available, to put in, at worst, moderate clergy, and if possible, more liberal leaning ones.
Also, If Francis has anything to say about it, expect to see women serving as Deacons in the not too distant future. Not full priesthood yet, but only a small step away.
karen marie
@satby: Have you ever seen or heard the “official” Catholic church making any indication that these busybodies don’t speak for the church? I sure haven’t.
karen marie
@tokyokie: He’s still trying to live down his days as a drug mule working for his brother-in-law.
Jackie
@UncleEbeneezer: I’m beginning to think Marco’s and other GQPs Catholicism is not the Catholic faith of Biden and his ilk. I wonder how Pope Francis would react to Marco should they meet?
Or is there a different pope for the GQP?🤔
karen marie
@satby: When I was a kid in White Plains, there was a bakery that made what we called a thousand layer cake. I recently ran across something similar, if not identical, at Sally’s Baking Addiction. She calls it a Smith Island Cake. It doesn’t look too terribly difficult to make, although in the comments lots of people couldn’t squeak out the full eight layers from the batter.
I can still taste those thousand layer cakes from my youth. So good!
satby
@karen marie: They’re PACs that often berate the Church for whatever bug they have up their ass. They’ve frequently questioned Francis’ legitimacy.
satby
@karen marie: Smith Island cake is what the baker here calls it.
Goku (aka Amerikan Baka)
@Another Scott:
Why couldn’t a few platinum coins succeed in that time? Or issuing consol bonds? Why is the 14th amendment, that has to be litigated and wouldn’t have the immediate effects the two options I mentioned, seem to be the solution that’s being focused on?
Jackie
This made me LOL!
CNN.com pointed out that DeSantis was polling at the same level as conspiracy theorist Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who’s running as a Democratic presidential candidate.
satby
@Jackie: Technically, it’s not; the extreme conservative PACs, especially CatholicVote, were founded to make common cause with Evangelical Protestants. But those churches, while happily using conservative Catholics to reach goals like overturning R vs W, don’t even consider Catholics Christian and espouse faith, not works as the road to salvation. Catholicism requires not just faith, but follow through in works.
I am not a Catholic, just a recovering one that had 8 years of Catholic school training. But Biden lives the faith as I was taught.
schrodingers_cat
@Baud:
eclare:
@MomSense:
Thanks so much!
Cacti
Bad form Dodgers.
An absolute essential of west coast culture is not giving a fuck what the eastern half thinks about how you live.
Jackie
@satby: Thanks for giving me a thoughtful reply to my somewhat snarky post. Being that I’m agnostic about religion, your explanation actually taught me something new: I had no idea evangelicals hooked up with a rigidly conservative sect (is this correctly defined?) of Catholics and basically created their own version of religion.
Is this the same as christian nationalism?
Timill
@satby:
Kids these days and their instant gratification…
Tim
(who turned 68 on the 10th and is thus 8 days older than satby)