(Image by NEIVANMADE)
.@yarotrof writes that on the eve of war the US have Ukraine a paltry 90 Javelins, compared to 2,000 NLAWs supplied by the UK. https://t.co/mrG05xvTHr
— Shashank Joshi (@shashj) January 9, 2024
The Washington Post has an excerpt from Yarislov Trofimov’s forthcoming book on Russia’s genocidal re-invasion of Ukraine: (emphasis mine)
Ukraine’s foreign minister, Dmytro Kuleba, was flying home on a Turkish Airlines plane from New York when Russia invaded. He had just been welcomed into the White House by President Biden. It felt like he had been diagnosed with Stage 4 cancer, he thought. The warm handshakes, the empathetic smiles were meant to be final farewells — for him, and for his country.
In Washington, and in most European capitals, no one expected Ukraine to survive in February 2022. The CIA director, William J. Burns, had secretly flown to Kyiv at Biden’s request, warning Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky that Russia was planning to assassinate him.
“They spoke about the physical liquidation of our leadership, about the creation of filtration and concentration camps,” said Zelensky’s national security adviser, Oleksiy Danilov. “But what could we do? We kept asking: give us weapons. But they didn’t really give weapons to us.”
As the United States shut down its embassy in Kyiv ahead of the invasion, it did ship some weapons to great fanfare, such as Javelin antitank missiles. But the quantity was puny: only about 90 Javelins, according to Danilov. Then-British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, while also briefed about the hopelessness of the Ukrainian cause, had overruled internal objections and authorized a heftier load of about 2,000 NLAW missiles. Still, those were weapons best suited for a guerrilla campaign, not a conventional war.
At the time, Ukraine’s military leadership, under Gen. Valery Zaluzhny, had successfully kept Kyiv’s war planning secret — and not just from the Russians. Neither Washington nor many senior officials in the Zelensky administration knew Zaluzhny’s blueprint. “We were pessimistic about Ukraine holding out in part because the Ukrainians didn’t share any of their preparations or planning with us,” a senior Pentagon official told me later. “And the preparations and plans that they did share with us were military deception.”
Poland, perhaps because of its history, was the only nation that didn’t despair in these early hours. Rerouting his connecting flight, Kuleba attended Poland’s national security council meeting on Feb. 24, the day of the invasion. The Polish government, like other NATO members, had been told by the alliance’s intelligence that a swift collapse of the Ukrainian state was near certain. Still, Warsaw refused to give up. Immediately, Poland sent several truckloads of ammunition and heavy weapons. “The Poles believed in us more intuitively than fact-based, because all the facts spoke against us at the time,” Kuleba recalled.
The mood was very different in other European capitals. “Nobody was giving the Ukrainians any chances,” Johnson said. “If this is going to happen, the best thing is that maybe it should happen quickly,” a senior aide to German chancellor Olaf Scholz told him at the time.
There is much more at the link if you can stomach it.
We should be ashamed. We did nothing of significance to deter Putin, nor to assure our allies and partners. Then we provided a parting gift of 90 javelins, turned tail, and ran. That shame has now been compounded by the wreckers that are the House majority GOP caucus:
What an absolute moral cesspit the Republican Party has got itself into with Ukraine. Treating the survival of a country as a political weapon and bargaining chip. For shame. https://t.co/2ZHoPVjD12
— Shashank Joshi (@shashj) January 9, 2024
The Ukrainians are not going to stop no matter how often we continually let them down.
Here is President Zelenskyy’s address from earlier today. Video below, English transcript after the jump.
Every aspect of logistics in the army needs to be expedited – address by the President of Ukraine
9 January 2024 – 19:32
I wish you health, fellow Ukrainians!
I will begin with the Staff.
Today was a special meeting – with the direct, in-person participation of all major commanders and heads of operations.
Together with the Commander-in-Chief, the General Staff, the Ministry of Defense, the Ministry of Strategic Industries, and the Ministry of Digital Transformation, we analyzed the supply of shells and drones in detail. Distribution between brigades and units. Daily needs. Actual costs. The bottom line is that every aspect of logistics needs to be expedited. We also discussed the launch of new production lines for weapons and ammunition in Ukraine – at our enterprises and together with partners.
Of course, we considered the supplies we expect to receive this year. Despite all the challenges in the world, our careful, clear approach to every requirement and every opportunity can provide the Defense Forces with everything necessary. We see how we can realize Ukraine’s priorities this year: what is needed, who is needed, and what signals can work.
We analyzed the work of our Air Force, all our defenders of the sky, separately and in detail. The results of shooting down Russian missiles and drones. The aspects we succeeded in. And the results we must achieve. We continue to work with all our partners to bolster our air defense. And at the same time, to increase pressure on Russia. The world’s sanctions are definitely working. And they are working well. There is clear evidence of a slowdown in the Russian defense industry. But for the sanctions to be one hundred percent effective, the schemes for circumventing the sanctions must also be one hundred percent blocked. New global steps are also needed against those who continue to help Russia. Everyone in the world knows this small list of terrorist accomplices. We will discuss this further with our partners.
Today I have already held three phone calls with the leaders: the President of Romania, the President of Poland, and the Prime Minister of Belgium.
I thanked Romania for the level of cooperation we have already achieved. We are having remarkable results in the Danube region, in the Black Sea cooperation, and in the overall interaction between us. We appreciate Romania’s support on our way to the European Union. We definitely have the potential to increase cross-border cooperation, particularly in the Ukraine-Romania-Moldova triangle. Today, we also discussed with President Iohannis some promising issues in the defense sector – the ways we can shore up our positions together. In particular, we discussed the training of our F-16 pilots.
There was a good conversation with the President of Poland. I am grateful to Poland for its unwavering assistance to Ukraine in matters of our accession to the European Union. No matter what happens, strategically we are still working together in Europe. Today, we discussed, in particular, our cooperation in matters of NATO – Ukraine must become a member of the Alliance. I briefed President Duda on the situation at the front, on the continued Russian attacks, our defense, and our needs. In particular, our needs for support. I appreciate President Duda’s words about the unity we so critically need.
I also had an important conversation with the head of the Belgian government. Belgium has now begun its presidency of the Council of the European Union, and I am grateful that support for Ukraine and international law is one of the priorities of the Belgian presidency. Together with Belgium, we have achieved some truly groundbreaking things, including the use of Russian assets to support Ukraine. And this is one of those examples where Belgian leadership is of global importance. I am grateful for the support of sanctions against Russia, as well as for the clear support of our European integration. This year, we can make significant progress both in the accession negotiations with Ukraine and in the issue of a more decisive attitude of the world towards Russian assets. The aggressor must pay for what he has done. This is only fair.
Of course, I also spoke with all the leaders about our work on the Peace Formula, as the meeting of advisors in Davos is coming up. We are working to make it both representative and meaningful. We are succeeding, and I thank everyone who contributes to the cause!
Glory to all who work for freedom, to all who fight for freedom! To those who do everything to make freedom stronger and to make terror – namely terror – lose. Every week there should be fewer opportunities for Russia. Every week there should be more opportunities for Ukraine.
Glory to Ukraine!
The cost:
You know, there's a mall in Bucha along the Warsaw Highway.
Not far away from my place of living in town.
The mall, along with endless shops, also hosts a clinic, part of a large private healthcare services brand that often accepts war veterans for rehabilitation care.… pic.twitter.com/JdLYzPJWi8
— Illia Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 (@IAPonomarenko) January 10, 2024
You know, there’s a mall in Bucha along the Warsaw Highway.
Not far away from my place of living in town.
The mall, along with endless shops, also hosts a clinic, part of a large private healthcare services brand that often accepts war veterans for rehabilitation care.
Amputees. Mostly young dudes.
I often see them having a smoke or just sitting in wheelchairs next to the clinic’s entrance, just taking the air and silently looking at people passing by and minding their own business at the mall.
I often see them because I sometimes feed stray dogs that hang around near window shops, waiting for some bleeding heart to buy them a treat.
And every time, there’s a new face of a legless soldier looking at the city in front of him.
So the other day, I was walking toward my car parked near the mall.
And I saw yet another disabled veteran in a wheelchair at the clinic’s door. A guy in his early twenties, AirPods in his ears, one leg amputated above his knee.
The guy was petting one of my ‘sponsee dogs.’ He gave the dog a treat, ruffled its head, and wheeled toward the clinic entrance to get back inside.
The automatic sliding door wouldn’t open.
He tried again and again, but nope. The sensor wasn’t seeing the wheelchair vet.
It was pretty late in the evening, and there were few people around to pay attention.
‘Hey, let me do this for you,’ I came along.
‘I’m afraid they forgot about me and locked the door for the night…” the veteran got a bit shy. ‘No worries, I’ll try and call somebody who’s inside.’
I waved my hand up closer to the sensors, and the sliding door opened up.
Yeah!
The guy gladly wheeled into the shadow of the clinic’s entrance.
‘Could you please…’ he also shyly looked at a hinged door into the lobby.
Sure.
‘Oh God, thank you so much for this… Phew!’
No, man, thank YOU for everything.
I mean… I hope on that night, the guy went to bed in his hospital ward without thinking that no one cared about him, never appreciated his battlefield sacrifice, or even failed to take notice of him in the streets.
Who knows how many more of us will have to go to the trenches when it’s our turn. Who knows how many more of us will eventually end up alone in a wheelchair trying to get back in.
For those who will see the end of this fucking war in one piece, it’s going to be a lifetime duty to be helping disabled vets.
I know I’m being idealistic, but I believe true veteran care begins with a very simple sign of respect by a random dude from a parking lot.
The reason:
Ivan: "I am from the village of Oleshnyk in Vynogradiv district, Zakarpattia region. I joined the army on March 1, 2022, despite being 57 years old. I couldn't stay home. My wife assumed I was joking when I mentioned I was heading to the military recruitment office. My call sign… pic.twitter.com/lhWBfgttj6
— Defense of Ukraine (@DefenceU) January 9, 2024
Ivan: “I am from the village of Oleshnyk in Vynogradiv district, Zakarpattia region. I joined the army on March 1, 2022, despite being 57 years old. I couldn’t stay home. My wife assumed I was joking when I mentioned I was heading to the military recruitment office. My call sign is “Vujko” (Uncle), but the lads just call me “Dido” (Grandpa).
📷: Serhii Hudak
The New York Times has a deep dive into the conditions at the Zaporizhzhia front: (emphasis mine)
ZAPORIZHZHIA REGION, Ukraine — Under the cover of darkness, leaning forward under the weight of packs and rifles, a squad of soldiers walked along a muddy lane and slipped into a village house.
They were Ukrainian infantrymen of the 117th Separate Mechanized Brigade, assembling for a last briefing and roll call several miles from Russia positions before heading to the trenches on the front line. Stolid men in helmets and rubber boots, they listened in silence as an intelligence officer briefed them on a new route in to their positions.
“Morale is all right,” said the deputy battalion commander, who uses the call sign Shira, standing nearby to see the men off. “But physically we are exhausted.”
Ukrainian troops along most of the 600-mile front line are officially in defensive mode. Only in the southern region of Kherson are they still on the offensive in a tough assault across the Dnipro River.
But the fighting has not eased and Russian forces are now on the offensive.
The capture of the town of Robotyne in the southeastern Zaporizhzhia region was as far as Ukrainian troops managed to advance in their summer counteroffensive. No breakthrough occurred. Now, in the trenches around Robotyne, Russian units are attacking daily. Ukrainian troops try to counterattack immediately if they lose ground, commanders said.
Indeed, Ukrainian soldiers and commanders interviewed in recent weeks along a broad stretch of the central and eastern front said that Russian attacks were so intense that operating near the frontline has never been so dangerous.
Russia has in recent days turned its focus to bombing Ukraine’s big cities to wear down civilians; for weeks its ground forces have been mounting attacks to claw back territory lost last summer and to seize long-prized Ukrainian redoubts along the eastern front.
Well accustomed to Russian artillery fire, soldiers said that since March they had suffered the additional devastating power of glide bombs, half-ton explosives unleashed from planes that smash through underground bunkers.
“They would send them two by two by two, eight in an hour,” said a 27-year-old soldier known as Kit, of the 14th Chervona Kalyna National Guard Brigade. Like others interviewed, Kit identified himself by his call sign, according to military protocol. “It sounds like a jet coming down on you,” he said, “like hell’s gate.”
The destruction wrought by glide bombs is visible in towns and villages near the front line. The town of Orikhiv, about 12 miles north of Robotyne, once served as a command center for the counteroffensive. Now it is an empty shell, the main street deserted, the school and other buildings split asunder by massive bomb craters.
A lone workman, Valera, was riding a bicycle through the town. He said he had stayed despite the heavy bombardment because he had paid work, fixing generators. He lived off humanitarian aid and was feeding 20 stray cats at his home, he said.
Soldiers moved cautiously in the area, mostly living in basements and staying undercover, out of sight.
That is because the latest menace is Russia’s use of F.P.V. kamikaze drones, which has forced Ukrainian soldiers largely to abandon vehicles in frontline areas and operate on foot.
A cheap commercial drone, the F.P.V. — for first person view — has become the latest weapon of the moment in the Ukrainian war. It can fly as fast as a car, carries a lethal load of explosives and is guided to its target by a soldier sitting in a bunker several miles away.
Both the Russian and Ukrainian armies are using them to hunt and attack targets because they cut out the delay of relaying back coordinates and requesting artillery strikes. Ukrainian soldiers said they often use the drones instead of artillery because shells were increasingly in short supply and the drones are a cheap, quick weapon for attacks on nearby Russian vehicles, bunkers and infantry.
The men of the 117th Brigade, who were deployingto the front line in the Zaporizhzhia region on a recent night, faced a four-mile hike through rain and mud, the intelligence commander said. If they were wounded and captured, Russian troops would execute them, he warned them.
The long, arduous slog to carry in ammunition and food to supply troops and to carry out the wounded was one reason Ukraine could not sustain its counteroffensive, a company commander, Adolf, 23, said.
Ambulances and supply vehicles came under fire from kamikaze drones so often that his unit stopped using them, resorting instead to a four-wheeled buggy that volunteer engineers rigged up to carry a stretcher. The buggy was hidden under some trees beside his command post several miles from the front line.
Ukrainian units are dealing out the same treatment with F.P.V. drones on Russian lines and say they were the first to start using drones to attack targets. But the Russians have copied the tactic and flooded frontline areas with drones in recent weeks, to lethal effect, Ukrainian soldiers and commanders said.
“My impression is Russia is interested in drones at the state level,” the soldier known as Kit said, but in contrast, Ukraine still largely relied on volunteers and civilian donors for its drone program. “My sense,” he said, “is the government should be doing more.”
Much more at the link!
Germany:
The pressure on Olaf Scholz to release the TAURUS cruise missile is mounting.
After former German President Joachim Gauck, the opposition leader of the CDU, Friedrich Merz, demands from Scholz to give up his hesitancy on this question.
"I welcome Scholz' call on our allies to… pic.twitter.com/8KAFWfYCxw
— (((Tendar))) (@Tendar) January 9, 2024
The pressure on Olaf Scholz to release the TAURUS cruise missile is mounting.
After former German President Joachim Gauck, the opposition leader of the CDU, Friedrich Merz, demands from Scholz to give up his hesitancy on this question.
“I welcome Scholz’ call on our allies to increase their effort in supporting Ukraine. It is a good message, but it is more credible when we do our part, by delivering the TAURUS missiles.”
Within the government coalition voices among the Greens and the FDP are getting even more louder.
Source (German): https://rp-online.de/politik/deutschland/friedrich-merz-zoegern-bei-der-taurus-lieferung-muss-aufhoeren_aid-104783739
Good, Scholz should be ashamed too!
Avdiivka, Donetsk Oblast:
Авдіївка, Донеччина
Ворог продовжує рівняти місто з землею pic.twitter.com/kAGKyYipTL— Мисливець за зорями (@small10space) January 9, 2024
Tatarigami has a new assessment regarding the railroad construction the Russians have been doing in parts of Ukraine that they’re occupying. First tweet from the thread, the rest from the Thread Reader App:
Geospatial Analysis: Railroad Construction on Occupied Territories. 🧵Updated Thread:
1/ Frontelligence Insight examined satellite imagery of railroad constructions in occupied territories, specifically south of Donetsk and in Mariupol. Here is what we know: pic.twitter.com/7oZkOQnr22
— Tatarigami_UA (@Tatarigami_UA) January 9, 2024
2/Burne – Malovodne branchTo enhance logistics between Russia, Donetsk, and Mariupol, Russians are actively constructing a new railroad branch to the south of Donetsk. This branch aims to bypass a risky section of the frontline near Mariinka and Vuhledar.
3/ The new branch starts in the village of Burne and links up with the existing railroad at Malovodne. Based on satellite imagery, significant progress is evident in the construction of this railroad branch, making our team believe that it might be completed in 2024.4/ Comparative analysis highlights a slowdown due to the construction of a bridge over the Kal’mius River. While composing this analysis, reports from the adviser to the Mariupol mayor suggested that Ukrainian forces had targeted the bridge while still under construction5/ The vulnerability of this single point of failure to Ukrainian weaponry increases the likelihood of future strikes even after completion, impacting the functionality of the entire railroad branch.6/ Taganrog – CrimeaRussians are also working on the railroad connecting Taganrog with Mariupol and Crimea to the rest of Russia. This serves as an alternative to the Crimean Bridge, aiming to shorten travel time. Frontelligence Insight has identified early construction stages
7/ In contrast to the previously mentioned railroad between Burne and Malovodne, this railroad branch is much longer and is still in the early stage of construction. Consequently, we assume that Russia won’t be able to complete this project by the end of 2024.8/ Sattelite imagery shows that Russians also successfully restored the gas pump station and worked on the restoration of a gas pipeline between Mariupol and the broader continental region of Russia.9/ This pipeline is likely a component of the Mariupol-Taganrog natural gas system. The significant investment in infrastructure suggests that the Russians are intending to transform the region into a fortified frontline stronghold with a robust military presence.10/ To effectively target railroad bridges, Ukraine would require more powerful missiles designed for bridge destruction, like the German Taurus missiles. Overall, Russia is anticipated to improve and expand its military infrastructure on occupied territories in 202411/ With Ukraine facing challenges such as ammo shortages, undermanned units, and limited assistance from the US in 2024, a defensive approach will likely be adopted. Concurrently, Russian forces are expected to intensify their efforts in expanding their military infrastructure.12/ The full analysis is accessible on the website listed in my bio. Kindly consider supporting us through BuyMeaCoffee, as our expenses rely solely on your public support, and maintaining quality without financing is still challenging for us. Don’t forget to share and like!13/ This is an updated thread to address inaccuracies and incorporate additional imagery. In the previous version, an image near Mariupol was mislabeled as a railroad instead of a pipeline, which is now corrected. We apologize for any confusion.
Oryol, Russia:
/2. Results of the UAV strike on Russian oil depot in Oryol. pic.twitter.com/jNh1piGJGd
— Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦 (@bayraktar_1love) January 9, 2024
That’s enough for tonight.
Your daily Patron!
-20 in Ukraine today 😮🥶 pic.twitter.com/tXW9HHXpoN
— Patron (@PatronDsns) January 9, 2024
And some adjacent material:
47 seconds that may restore your faith in humanity.
We in Ukraine are now having pretty unusually cold weather ❄️
And this dude from Irpin named Viktor saved a dog that couldn't make it out of an iced pond.
The world still has good people. pic.twitter.com/apZr3EIINX— Illia Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 (@IAPonomarenko) January 9, 2024
Best buddies stand for protecting our freedom. pic.twitter.com/BeUjv3CSiz
— Defense of Ukraine (@DefenceU) January 9, 2024
Open thread!
AlaskaReader
Thanks Adam
japa21
Plenty of shame to go around. I, like many people, felt this would totally turn into a guerilla style conflict very quickly. Shame on me.
Alison Rose
Jesus motherfucking Christ. I suppose it’s too much to hope that the aide got punched in the teeth after saying that.
I also wish all Republicans would get punched in the teeth once a day.
Photo of Zelenskyy with Romanian President Klaus Iohannis, who is…a big dude.
I had to use Google to determine that -20 Celsius is -4 Fahrenheit. NOPE.
Thank you as always, Adam.
Adam L Silverman
@AlaskaReader: You’re welcome.
Adam L Silverman
@japa21: Nope. This is on the senior decision makers and now, in the US, the GOP members of the House and Senate.
Omnes Omnibus
@Adam L Silverman: I place it squarely on the GOP. I understand your position, but I am not willing to bothsides this.
Jay
Thank you Adam.
YY_Sima Qian
So, Boris Johnson came through during the initial days of the invasion, & also during the negotiations in Apr. 2022.
Yes, I threw up a little typing that.
Also, US intelligence was convinced that a Russian invasion was imminent, but there was no plan ready to go to immediately provide additional material aid to Ukraine once the invasion happened?
Dr. Jakyll and Miss Deride
What about the suggestion by the anonymous senior Pentagon official that Ukraine was partly responsible for everyone’s feelings of despair before the reinvasion began because it didn’t share its true military plans with anyone? Is there any merit to that, or is it pure CYA?
Bill Arnold
@japa21:
Looking back through notes, there was sort-of-convincing public open source work suggesting that the Russians had not deployed a sufficient logistics tail (especially fuel trucks) immediately prior to the invasion to support a full mechanized large-force invasion. This was confusing since Putin and team were obviously poised to invade, but they surely couldn’t be so incompetent as to fuck up such basics. But they were…
(The Ukrainians also defended brilliantly, if that needs to be said.)
Am still surprised nearly two years later, though, that USA (government) military analysts got it so wrong.
Adam L Silverman
@Omnes Omnibus: Who was president when Ukraine was reinvaded?
Adam L Silverman
@YY_Sima Qian: I guarantee there was a plan. What there wasn’t was any intention on the part of the administration to implement the plan.
wombat probability cloud
This isn’t my wheelhouse, so my naiveté is more than evident, but looking at the original Lend-Lease Act of 1941, I’m gobsmacked at how parallel and appropriate it is to the current situation. I understand that the GOP’s goal is to hobble any Dem president but wonder if there’s any way to introduce a new Lend-Lease for 2024, in combination with as much pressure as can be brought, to provide a way for reps and senators who still support democracy.
Another Scott
@YY_Sima Qian:
Whitehouse.gov – March 16, 2022:
Remember Biden was telling everyone for weeks/months that VVP was going to invade, and was burning up the phones and making trips to Europe to keep NATO together as a unified alliance. I think the hope* was that by being so explicit – “We have significant intelligence capability” – telling him we know what you’re planning, he was hoping to convince VVP to back down. But there were obviously DoD plans in place to get weapons to Ukraine quickly if she was able to hold on long enough to accept them once VVP took that step. He didn’t want to give VVP any plausible excuse in advance that he “had to invade” because the west was going to invade first if he didn’t (or some similar nonsense).
It wasn’t a stupid approach at the time, IMHO.
* – Yes, hope is not a strategy.
My $0.02.
Cheers,
Scott.
Adam L Silverman
@Dr. Jakyll and Miss Deride: CYA. Give Trump’s attempted shakedown of Zelenskyy, despite Biden having replaced him, you can’t blame the Ukrainians for keeping their cards close to their vest.
Omnes Omnibus
@Adam L Silverman:
Luckily, it was Biden. If it had been Trump, we would have done nothing. As I said, I understand your argument. That doesn’t mean I have to agree with it.
Adam L Silverman
@Bill Arnold: DIA stands for do it again.
We got it right here though.
Gin & Tonic
@Dr. Jakyll and Miss Deride: Ukraine also shouldn’t have worn such a short skirt, and so much makeup.
GFY.
Dr. Jakyll and Miss Deride
@Gin & Tonic: I wasn’t endorsing that claim by the anonymous official — just asking for Adam’s take on it, since he hadn’t commented on it up to then.
hrprogressive
“Shame” as a motivating or accountability factor has been dead in this country for at least a generation, if not longer.
People in power do whatever they want, whatever they think will preserve their own asses, and the public by and large lets it happen, because we’re all so shackled by the miserable systems we’ve allowed unfettered corporatism to become that meaningful resistance of same is more or less futile.
It’s pathetic, really.
YY_Sima Qian
@Another Scott: Substantial aid only arrived after the Ukrainian defenders had already bogged down the Russian thrusts. What matters on the battlefield is not when aid is announced, or the USD figure of the aid, but the quantities of equipment & munitions sent, & the timing of their arrival.
I guess the US IC really did assess that Ukraine would be defeated w/in weeks if not days, & any military aid would be money down the drain, or worse captured intact by the Russians.
Another Scott
@YY_Sima Qian: Biden probably wouldn’t have sent Ukraine $1B in stuff before February 2022 if he thought that it was hopeless.
Cheers,
Scott.
YY_Sima Qian
@Another Scott: IIRC, what was sent before the current invasion was part of the long standing military collaboration w/ Ukraine since 2014, training and some equipment, not a crash program of material support to face the imminent invasion.
Carlo Graziani
@YY_Sima Qian: My recollection is that there was also considerable miscommunication and mutual incomprehension between the US and Ukrainian governments between October 2021, when US IC started issuing red alert warnings, and February 2022, when it all went down.
During that time, there was not clear evidence that Zelenskyy’s government was taking US war warnings seriously. In fact, there were many signals that the Ukrainians were downplaying the threat. On the US side there was also serious, and justified, concern about Russian penetration of Ukrainian military and security apparatuses, which led to constraints on collaboration, let alone alliance.
Certainly the level of trust between the two governments was not high until well after the invasion was underway. And while it may seem crazy in hindsight, the judgement that Zelenskyy’s government was not long for this world was certainly far from indefensible in the war’s very early stages. In my opinion, efforts to portray such judgments as somehow craven, rather than part of a realistic spectrum of opinion given facts on the ground, amount to very poor, tendentious history.
Zelenskyy changed everything by virtue of his personal conduct in the first few days. “I need ammunition, not a ride!” was a world history-changing moment that refocused Western dialog on Russia and the war. Another Ukrainian President in his place might actually have shown the skeptics to be correct. Thus, historical contingency.
Prescott Cactus
“The Australian Army will reportedly scrap 45 MRH 90 Taipan helicopters that were retired last year instead of selling them off or donating them to Ukraine. The MRH 90 fleet was permanently grounded last year following a fatal 28 July crash in the Whitsunday Islands in Queensland,
A 7 January podcast by Asia Pacific Defence Reporter (APDR) editor Kym Bergmann said that, instead of a previous plan to store the helicopters for possible future use in a civil or military emergency, they will instead be dismantled and their remains buried. This is despite the aircraft having served barely half of their planned service lives and having plenty of serviceable hours remaining on their airframes and dynamic components.
This report aligns with information Region has also heard, including that the Jervis Bay ditching was caused by an engine failure in one engine, which would ordinarily be recoverable in the twin-engined helicopter. However, indications are that the remaining engine was shut down in error. Bergmann also reported that the Ukrainian Embassy has formally requested some or all of the MRH 90s in the wake of Australia’s early retirement but has yet to receive a response to the request.”
YY_Sima Qian
@Carlo Graziani: I do agree, & I don’t think the Biden Administration was acting cravenly, & I do recall commentary at the time that suggested any supply of lethal weapons to Ukraine (that might kill Russians) was too escalatory & could lead to thermonuclear war.
If fact, outside of Ukraine, I am in greater sympathy w/ the left wing critique that US foreign policy under Biden remains far too primacist, too heavily weighed toward military tools & coercive sanctions, too much under the spell of Great Power Competition, & too economically nationalist.
However, the US could have rushed over much larger batches of Javelins & Stingers from Army stockpiles in Europe immediately after the invasion.
Perhaps the single thread is not being risk averse per se, but being beholden to decades old foreign policy conventional wisdom – primacy is central to US national interest, great power competition can help smooth over domestic political division, US credibility is on the line everywhere all the time, the US is always indispensable, deterrence is an end in itself & achievable in perpetuity, can’t have daylight w/ Israel, & avoid risk of shooting wars w/ nuclear powers at all costs (particularly by mistake). The only thing that has changed is that global neoliberal trade regime has been tossed (good!) in favor of economic nationalism & mini-lateral blocks (not so good). Conventional wisdom is better than Trumpian recklessness, but has caused plenty of problems for the US & the ROW.
Another Scott
@YY_Sima Qian: I think that the best explanation of the Biden administration’s buildup, or lack thereof, before February 24 is the stated (and acted) requirement for NATO unity. Hungary, for example, wasn’t going to go along with “going on a war footing”, or declaring Article 5 was active, or putting the Big Red 1 on the border or even inside Ukraine (even if Ukraine requested them, and she didn’t). NATO countries, and the GQP, and the US Congress, would have absolutely freaked out as well. (Remember the protests about Reagan’s INF buildup in Europe.). US support depended on NATO support as well (logistics at the very least).
The politics of military preparedness cannot be ignored. War is politics by other means, after all.
Of course, some things could have been done differently in hindsight – that is always the case…
My $0.02.
Thanks.
Cheers,
Scott.
YY_Sima Qian
@Another Scott: The US’ material effort immediately after the invasion could have matched that of Poland, who is also a member of NATO.
In advance of the invasion, I do think the Biden Administration managed the geopolitics vis-a-vis Russia & the ROW, as well as alliance politics in NATO & w/ the EU & other parts of the West, very well.