Today 🇺🇦 Hero Jr. Lt. Dmytro “DaVinci” Kotsyubailo, killed in a battle near Bakhmut, was given his final honors.
Thousands attended his farewell ceremony, including @ZelenskyyUa @MarinSanna @oleksiireznikov @CinC_AFU
Sincere condolences to his family and fiancee @Mykhailova_A pic.twitter.com/FVXxpz05x3— Defense of Ukraine (@DefenceU) March 10, 2023
— Alina Mykhailova (@Mykhailova_A) March 10, 2023
Here is President Zelenskyy’s address from earlier today. Video below, English transcript after the jump: (emphasis mine)
Ukrainians are strong when they take care of each other, and free when they defend themselves – address of President Volodymyr Zelenskyy
10 March 2023 – 20:24
The meeting of the Staff of Supreme Commander-in-Chief has just ended.
The commander-in-chief, commanders of the task forces reported on the situation on the front line, generally in the defense of the state. East and south, border. Bakhmut and our opportunities to strengthen there. Our responses to terrorist attacks. Protection of Kherson and communities of Dnipropetrovsk region. Chernihiv region, Sumy region. Our ammunition and supply needs.
Today, I spoke about the provision of Ukrainian soldiers and, in general, the support of our state in defense against Russian aggression during international negotiations.
The Prime Minister of Finland, a country that quite actively supports us, visited Kyiv. I thanked him for the aid packages already provided, we discussed new opportunities to strengthen our defense, increase pressure on Russia – a new defense package for Ukraine, already the 14th.
We also talked about cooperation in the European Union structures, and supporting our initiatives to punish Russian murderers.
Today, I also met with the Minister of Defense of Norway. In general, we have achieved an extremely strong relationship with Norway in many areas. This also concerns weapons: thanks to Norway, we strengthened our air defense, artillery, and other types of troops. Norway also launched a long-term budget support program for Ukraine – $7 billion for five years – which can and should become an example for our other partners.
We discussed additional steps that we can take together with Norway to make this spring a success both for Ukrainian defense and for the prospects of pan-European security.
By the way, we are starting to communicate with Norway about the possibilities of a training mission for our pilots.
I talked today with representatives of the American political community – senators, experts – at the site of the American Enterprise Institute. It is one of the strong American think tanks – institutions involved in policy-making.
I briefed on the current situation, our possibilities to break Russian aggression and return security to Ukraine. I thanked America for its unwavering and principled support, and the leadership that can bring our victory much closer.
Today, I would like to pay particular attention to our soldiers who are defending Ukraine in Donetsk region. Every day they give good reasons for gratitude, give good results for Ukraine. Marines of the 35th and 36th separate marine brigades, the 55th separate artillery brigade, paratroopers of the 79th brigade… Thank you, soldiers! And separately, I would like to thank today the soldiers of the Defense Intelligence Shaman unit – for Bakhmut, for their strong participation in the defense of the city.
Thank you to the soldiers of the 44th separate artillery brigade, who are fighting near Zaporizhzhia. Skillfully destroy enemy positions and equipment. Thank you guys for this!
Today, I signed another decree on honoring our soldiers with state awards. In particular, soldiers of the 24th separate assault battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
Today, I had the honor of handing “Da Vinci” Dmytro Kotsiubailo his Cross of Military Merit to his mother. Farewell to Dmytro took place today. And I thank everyone who came to the farewell ceremony for “Da Vinci.” To everyone who would like to come, but is currently at the front, in the army, in the hospital. It is very important.
It is important that Ukraine honors its heroes and demonstrates to the world what kind of people give their lives for the freedom of our people and the whole of Europe. I’m grateful to everyone. Remember Dmytro today, please remember all those who were taken from us by this war – since February 24, since 2014. Eternal memory to the heroes!
And one more. All day I receive reports about the restoration of our energy facilities and networks after the Russian terrorist attack.
Kharkiv – many subscribers are still disconnected, the city has communication problems. It was possible to provide electricity to critical infrastructure, all services are working to restore the energy supply to consumers. Truly heroic efforts of our energy workers and repair crews.
Kharkiv region – as of evening, electricity supply has been restored to most consumers.
It is still not easy in Zhytomyr: although the system has generally been balanced, there may still be outages. Energy workers are working.
Zaporizhzhia – everything is being done to protect people and the city’s energy system.
Kyiv – heating networks are being restored.
I thank everyone who is involved in these works, thank everyone who helps!
Ukrainians are strong when they take care of each other. Ukrainians are free when they defend themselves.
Glory to our beautiful people!
In memory of our soldiers who gave their lives for our country!
Glory to Ukraine!
A warrior’s funeral.
When the General-in-Chief, the defense minister, the Chief of the General Staff, the military intelligence head, and the full of the Maidan bow down on their knees.
Zelensky and @MarinSanna were there, too.
Rest in peace, DaVinci. pic.twitter.com/sNIWregEDq— Illia Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 (@IAPonomarenko) March 10, 2023
More of the cost:
Ukrainian father and son. They fought together and died together in the battle of Bakhmut. https://t.co/zNklsu8wo9
— Christopher Miller (@ChristopherJM) March 9, 2023
Here is former NAVDEVGRU Squadron Leader Chuck Pfarrer’s most recent assessment of the situation in Bakhmut:
BAKHMUT /1550 UTC 10 MAR/ After a sustained and costly series of attacks, Wagner PMC forces report attaining a lodgment in the village of Dubovo-Vasylivka. RU attacks on Orikhovo-Vasylivka were repelled. UKR units are reported to have advanced south-west of Bakhmut. pic.twitter.com/qVz6xI7fsf
— Chuck Pfarrer | Indications & Warnings | (@ChuckPfarrer) March 10, 2023
Well this is going to be interesting:
Prigozhin said that after the capture of Bakhmut, he intends to "reboot" the Wagner PMC in order to turn it into an army with an ideology.
Which ideology? Some kind of colony of benevolence for crooks or something? pic.twitter.com/B3ybf5sRE4
— NOËL 🇪🇺 🇺🇦 (@NOELreports) March 10, 2023
Four days ago the Institute for the Study of War posted that Ukraine was undertaking a tactical retreat from Bakhmut despite Ukraine’s National Command Authority and the theater commander making it clear no such thing was taking place. The theater commander, Colonel General Syrsky, has repeatedly visiting his forces contesting for Bakhmut over the past week to ten days. Yesterday the ISW posted that Wagner has taken a tactical pause in its attempt to take Bakhmut despite Wagner initiating dozens of attacks. Today the ISW posted that even if Russian forces could take Bakhmut, Russia would be unable to generate operational effects from doing so.
This concludes the lesson of why I never use anything from the Institute for the Study of War.
Dara Massicot, a senior policy researcher at RAND, has done an interesting assessment of Russian missile use. First tweet in the thread below followed by the rest from the Thread Reader App:
I’ve been comparing Russian missile strikes against Ukraine over the last few months with what is known about their doctrine and launch capacity. I’d like to share a little about recent trends below. /1 pic.twitter.com/KCdS43uCA1
— Dara Massicot (@MassDara) March 10, 2023
Before I do: there are Ukrainian civilians who suffering and dying from these strikes. I’ve said before, Ukraine needs sustained air defense systems and interceptor missiles and other support, as there is an effort underway to exhaust Ukrainian SAMs over time.I haven’t made my way through all strikes since 2022, so far just 2023 today. I’ve compiled launch points where known, missile type, and interception rates. Sources for now are UAF and western media. I will catalogue Russian info next. /2(Speaking of interception rates, @konrad_muzyka has great information on this, if you are not already subscribing to the UCM , I recommend it!) /3The attack this week (81 missiles) was not the largest in 2023 – the largest was one month ago with 105 total. This attack was different in terms of type of systems used, launch locations, variation of launchers and missile trajectories, making it complex to defend against. /4It featured 6 Kinzhal hypersonic ALBMs – the largest salvo so far of them in the war and the largest recorded for combat use of this missile. Russia doesn’t have large numbers of this system, rumored in the dozens. More on that: /5 washingtonpost.com/world/2023/03/…Ukrainian officials say they cannot intercept Kinzhal, Kh-22 ASCMs and S-300 (SA-20) air defense missiles repurposed for land attack roles. too fast, trajectory is difficult. They claim Russia has fired 210 Kh-22 since 2022, none of them intercepted. /6The Kh-22 (AS-4) Soviet-era ASCM was designed to be an aircraft carrier killer. It is not very precise, but it is supersonic. /7Air Force: Ukraine needs Patriot to down Kh-22 missiles Russia used to hit high-rise in DniproUkraine’s Air Force Command reported that Russia used five Tu-22М3 long-range supersonic missile carrier bombers to fire five Kh-22 missiles against Ukraine on Jan. 14. They were launched from Russia’…https://kyivindependent.com/news-feed/air-force-ukraine-does-not-have-means-to-down-kh-22-missilesFrom the info that I have, there is no set pattern to the makeup of the strike packages this year. Many are ASCMs or SAMs purposed for land-attack roles. A few reasons for this in no particular order: experimentation to see what works, stockpile issues, launcher readiness. /8Note, no SS-26/SSC-7 in quite some time, probably as inventory is low. They are using different combinations of balloons, Shaheds, timing waves of missiles, shifting launch locations, and so on, to reduce interception rates. /8Not depicted in the chart – each strike originates from slightly different locations. They haven’t launched much from Belarus in the last month, according to Ukrainian officials. It’s a mix from Belgorod, Caspian+ Black Sea, Rostov, Kursk, and occupied Zaporizhzhia. /9While the Russians likely know the limitations and strengths of Ukraine’s soviet/Russian origin SAMs, they are likely trying to probe weaknesses in NASAMS or IRIS-T performance. /10Back in November, NASAMs had a 100% success rate according to SECDEF Austin. /11NASAMS air defense system have 100% success rate in Ukraine- Pentagon chiefU.S.-provided NASAMS air defense systems have had a 100% success rate in Ukraine intercepting Russian missiles, U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said on Wednesday, as NATO said an errant Ukrainian …https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/nasams-air-defense-system-have-100-success-rate-ukraine-pentagon-chief-2022-11-16/As for overall targets – most of these strikes are continuing to target the power grid, an oil refinery, defense industrial targets – what is called “critical infrastructure” in Russian mil strategy. However, missiles are striking residential buildings. /12Ukraine is repairing their grid. The strikes are lethal, yet they backfire too, as Ukrainians are more resolved against Russia with each wave. Nor do I see how they directly support the Donbas effort/13That being said, I do worry that this wears down Ukrainian SAM inventory; I don’t know how many interceptors they expend for each Russian missile launched. /14Is Russia following their CONOPs for PGMs? Yes and no. On one hand there is an adherence to striking critical infrastructure, but on the other hand they not found lasting effects from this approach and haven’t switched to a fundamentally different strategy. /15If interested, we have a new report on the subject. We discuss aspects of Russian PGM targeting and launch capacity by platform. It was written in 2021 (prewar), but only recently approved for public release. /16As we noted then (but were unable to discuss here until approved) there was a large gap between their theory and the force, to achieve effects with PGMs, EW, and counterspace capabilities. Led by Clint Reach w/contributions from me and a great team.Russia’s Evolution Toward a Unified Strategic OperationIn this report, RAND researchers examine the reasons behind Russia’s evolution toward a unified strategic operation, as well as the capabilities that would be necessary to execute key conventional off…https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA1233-8.htmlFinal thought – Russia is facing PGM inventory issues and is experimenting with what it has left. These attacks strain Ukrainian air defenses and this is a problem over time. The attacks come every few weeks. thanks for reading/end.
This whole a group of private Ukrainian operators drove over 5,000 lbs of explosives from Poland to Germany and then packed it plus all the diving gear into a 45 to 50 foot sailboat and then dove on the deepest part of the NordStream pipelines, which would’ve required a decompression chamber, and none of these highest of high speed and lowest of low drag operators thought to wipe the yacht down for explosive residue reporting is now completely out of hand.
“The report in Der Spiegel traces the Andromeda’s route around the Baltic from its home marina in Rostock on 6 September to the German island of Rügen and then finally to the Danish island of Christiansø, close to the site of the blasts on 26 September.” https://t.co/fX9z8YLwpd
— Shashank Joshi (@shashj) March 10, 2023
“Diving experts say such extended deep dives would have required a decompression chamber for the divers, which would not fit on a yacht. There are also question on whether there would be room for the required explosives” https://t.co/fX9z8YLwpd
— Shashank Joshi (@shashj) March 10, 2023
New Spiegel article gives a bit of new information:
– Apparently one forged Bulgarian passport
– Group size and whether there was a woman in the group is unclear
– Andromeda may have been back in Wiek a second time to stock up and refuelhttps://t.co/hePwzCHIUV— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
So apparently it was a complete coincidence that the authorities found out that someone had smuggled a large amount of explosives into Germany if they story is true.https://t.co/Dau5ks1yyX
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
One point I haven’t seen brought up by any media regarding the Andromeda Nord Stream story.
A non-state sponsored actor was apparently able to smuggle an enormous amount of explosives into Germany and the authorities apparently didn’t know until months after.
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
If this story is true, it seems to have massive implications. What happens if the hostile actors weren’t interested in “just” sabotaging the Nord Stream pipeline?
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
Alexander has a full write up with lots of AIS imagery at his substack showing why this reporting doesn’t add up. You can find that at this link.
He’s also got an update thread:
It just so happens to not only happen directly above the Nord Stream pipeline sabotage locations, but also at the exact same time as the currently suspected Andromeda is supposedly placing explosives in the same location.
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
It then proceeded to the Petersburg Oil Terminal in Saint Petersburg on the 18th where it stayed until the 20th September. pic.twitter.com/1xOALSHY2Z
— Oliver Alexander (@OAlexanderDK) March 10, 2023
Each but of this reporting just creates more questions and gaps in the information being fed to the reporters. Additionally, given what we’ve seen over the past six months about how Russia has compromised a number of German intelligence and security personnel, as well as Germany’s investigations into and arrests of neo-fascist German extremists in the military and law enforcement suggests we should take anything German intel says with a very large grain of salt.
That’s enough for tonight.
Your daily Patron:
Here @MarinSanna shows how she wanted to hold me. But we haven’t met during her visit to Ukraine 🫤 (yet). Photo @igorlachenkov TG channel. pic.twitter.com/hFayDrjKrh
— Patron (@PatronDsns) March 10, 2023
And a new video from Patron’s official TikTok:
@patron__dsns Контент на мільйон?😂 #песпатрон
The caption machine translates as:
Content for a million? 😂 #песпатрон
Open thread!
Alison Rose
That tweet from Patron made me smile. I hope Ms Sanna’s people saw it and will work to rectify the situation with all due speed!
United24 has an intercepted and translated call from a russian orc to a relative. Apparently he got fired on by one of his own who was drunk. They’d also been hit by their own helicopters and tanks. Brilliant fighters they got there. The work of a master strategist strikes again!
The NordStream stuff feels like a Tom Clancy book that his editor rejected because it sounds too bananas.
Thank you as always, Adam.
Freemark
Thank you Adam!
Anonymous At Work
Oliver is focusing on opportunity, both UA and RU had the means, but what’s the motive of the NORD-2 bombing? I always thought it was an excuse to shut off oil exports to EU to drive up prices so suddenly and sharply as to force the EU to back off. Pro-Putinists are claiming that UA had a better motive in disrupting Russian export capabilities.
Thoughts?
Jay
@Anonymous At Work:
woke trans environmentalist illegal immigrants to the EU did it,………….
Another Scott
@Anonymous At Work:
I think the story at the Substack makes the most sense:
It was kinda obvious that VVP always intended to use the northern pipelines for blackmail. He had a history of doing that in the pipelines running through Ukraine, so of course he was going to do the same in Germany and the EU. Having the explosives in place by the time of the re-invasion of Ukraine would give him maximum flexibility. NS2 springing a leak messed up the plans.
I have no special knowledge though, so …
Cheers,
Scott.
Anonymous At Work
@Another Scott: I trust a former Navy SEAL (Pfarrer), aka the underwater demolition Spec Ops soldier, on his evaluation that NORD-2 was a professional underwater demolition.
Jay
GibberJack
So Prigozhin wants to turn his Wagner PMC into an army with an ideology.
He thinks he’s going make his murdering and raping dregs of Russia into Sardaukar. Yeah right.
Ruckus
@Anonymous At Work:
Given all the effort required to dive on the pipeline and still be alive after completing the dive a sailboat of that size seems like a ridiculous story. Even doing the dive in the first place takes quite a bit of experience and surviving without decompression is rather unlikely so the sailboat seems a very ridiculous story to draw attention away from whoever actually did the deed.
Adam L Silverman
@Another Scott: That’s why I posted his analysis the other night.
@Anonymous At Work: This would fit in Alexander’s theory of what happened.
coin operated
@GibberJack:
That deserves a repeat….
coin operated
Two questions…
Was Nord Stream 1 or 2 insured?
Who gets paid?
Jay
Carlo Graziani
Sorry, Adam, but that’s BS. If you were to apply that same standard to Pfarrer’s output, you would have dropped him like a flaming turd by last summer. Remember his Bakhmut “salient” map from last week, that misled you into announcing that the Ukrainian counterattack was at hand? And the next day, his map had magically healed the dent along that NW-SE highway, and he pretended that nothing had happened?
You understand perfectly well that all such analysis is “through a glass, darkly,” amounting to making calls using ambiguous evidence under uncertainty. ISW at least shows you what their evidence is (I’ve run down their footnotes through Deeple many times). Pfarrer gives nothing but his projected authority, and his silly, obviously under-informed maps. Changing one’s views and showing you why is called “marking one’s beliefs to market.” Changing them silently as if one has never held them is bullshit artistry.
Jay
Urza
@Another Scott: Accelerating the plan all of 17 hours doesn’t account for sneaking explosives into Germany before that.
YY_Sima Qian
This Nord Stream sabotage story just keeps getting weirder. However, it is also the current US intelligence assessment that there is no evidence that Putin ordered the sabotage.
Urza
@YY_Sima Qian: It may be true they don’t see any evidence of Putin, but how does anyone else actually profit from it?
Jay
Adam L Silverman
@YY_Sima Qian: There is a long history of Russia’s intelligence and security services, as well as the oligarchs/Bratva leaders simply doing things that fit within what seems to be Putin’s objectives without being given any actual orders. This appears to be the pattern with the wetwork program.
Adam L Silverman
@Jay: I posted that last night in the actual post.
Again, is it too much to ask you actually look and see what I put in the posts before you repost it in the comments?
Adam L Silverman
@Carlo Graziani: Again, and for the last time, this is how the US military makes these types of maps of a battle space. The US military is going to continue to do so whether you like the format or not.
Jay
Carlo Graziani
@Adam L Silverman: Oh, I didn’t know about this. We have information that the Skripal novichok poisoning and Litvinenko radionuclide poisonings were freelance work by FSB/GRU?
Adam L Silverman
@Carlo Graziani: It’s a theme carried through all the parts of Buzzfeed’s investigative reporting on these attacks. I think there’s like eight or nine articles in their series on the wetwork program.
Carlo Graziani
@Adam L Silverman: No, it is not. Pfarrer adjusts his maps daily, based on the latest batch of translated tweets and Telegram posts, and he doesn’t bother to do any due diligence on whether what he’s representing cartographically makes any sense. He’s basically an optimistic automaton for turning social media noise into maps. Any US analyst who followed his methodology would be fired in short order, for valid reasons.
Omnes Omnibus
@YY_Sima Qian:
Absence of evidence does not equal evidence of absence.
Jay
@Adam L Silverman:
yeah I know, but people need to be reminded.
there was another Russian terror bombing in Kherson earlier this week, and every day since, the death toll has gone up,……..and up,….
Adam L Silverman
@Carlo Graziani: And it’s not freelancing per se. There’s just no specific approval from Putin for them. Basically each agency is competing against the other to achieve what they think are his objectives.
Mike in NC
@Jay: I’ll need to get one of those Russian tank models to go with my Black Sea flagship “Moscow”. Somebody clever did a bogus box art showing empty seascape.
Carlo Graziani
@Adam L Silverman: That makes bureaucratic sense.
Adam L Silverman
@Carlo Graziani: I cannot recommend highly enough that you drop this topic.
Omnes Omnibus
@Adam L Silverman: Henry II never ordered anyone to kill Becket. Things like that have happened throughout history.
Redshift
Ukraine fundraiser by astronaut Scott Kelly (now a Ukraine24 ambassador):
Geminid
@Carlo Graziani: I think Pfarrar’s maps are fine for what they are and no one’s forcing me to look at them. If you don’t like his maps, go look at Noel Reports’ or ISW’s maps and stop carping about someone else’s work
Pfarrar’s maps may not be perfect, but as far as I’m concerned the glass is half full. Your position seems to be, “the glass is half empty and I’m getting really strung out over it!” That’s a choice, and a poor one I think.
Andrya
@Omnes Omnibus: Nazi Germany also had a “working towards the Fuhrer” rule meaning “do what Hitler wants without making him say it explicitly”.
I’ve been reflecting, the last couple of days, of how many ways putin’s statements and actions resemble Hitler’s.
a. Some principle of the universe/deity wants us to conquer our neighbors? Check.
b. Telling lies for the great cause is OK? Check.
c. Confusing language with race? Check. (In the late 1930’s, JRR Tolkien, a linguist by profession, was queried by a German publisher whether he was Aryan- they were interested in publishing “The Hobbit” in German. Tolkien replied, with undoubtedly maddening linguistic accuracy, that as far as he knew, none of his ancestors had spoken either Iranian or Indic languages- that is what “Aryan” actually means. The deal did not go anywhere.)
d. Pretending that speakers of one’s own language are being oppressed/subject to genocide in the country he wants to attack- when in fact this is a total fabrication? Check.
Carlo Graziani
@Geminid: The original point, which I fear cannot be discussed rationally here, is the comparative analytic methodologies of Pfarrer and ISW. But, right, done.
Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom
@Andrya: Love that story! I’m actually surprised it got that far. Too few know or realise that Tolkien was a veteran of WW I, a survivor of the Battle of The Somme in fact. Fortunately for the future of fantasy literature, he developed Trench Foot & was ushered out of the British army. Alas, most of his friends did not survive that stupidest IMHO, war. So he couldn’t have had much warm feelings for Germany.
Andrya
@Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom: Tolkien was himself of German ancestry, and he also said that (despite WW1) he never felt ashamed of his German ancestry until the Nazi regime. He particularly detested Nazi anti-Semitism.
Andrya
@Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom: I should have added, thanks for the kind words. I did worry, being an extreme Tolkien fan, whether my contribution was appropriate.
YY_Sima Qian
@Urza:
@Omnes Omnibus:
I don’t disagree, but USG is not currently suggesting that Russia or Russian-aligned groups being responsible for the sabotage, not even via leaks. That’s what makes the recent disclosures all the more strange.
YY_Sima Qian
@Adam L Silverman: Allowing such freelancing is a remarkably risky way of doing business, but an arrangement that Putin has to be fine w/ & finds useful.
Shalimar
@Carlo Graziani: If by “cannot be discussed rationally”, you mean you can’t force others to agree with you, then yes, you are right. Stop trying.
YY_Sima Qian
China just brokered a deal between Saudi Arabia & Iran to renormalize relations & hopefully cool the proxy fights between the GCC & Iran across the region.
The Carnegie Endowment’s Karim Sadjadpour has a good Twitter thread on what this means & doesn’t mean for the region, & the emerging Sino-US competition in the Middle East.
It does make it interesting how the US attempt to broker a more formal anti-Iranian alliance between Israel & Saudi Arabia proceeds, & how Saudi’s Arabia balances the two parts of its foreign policy. Perhaps the Saudis are realizing that the U.S. will not pay the price it is asking for to consummate the alliance.
If the Great Power Competition is a race to see who can be the more effective peacemaker/mediator, by all means bring it on. (Alas, we know that will not the case).
YY_Sima Qian
I don’t think this has been posted, but sheesh DOD!
Uncle Cosmo
@Jay:
Did “people also need to be reminded” about that “Russian tank model” you reposted from a February 23 tweet? Or did you just crave another jolt of attention from the blog?
Next time try buying better coffee, maybe?
Geminid
@YY_Sima Qian: The U.S. would like the Saudi-Israeli alliance to be formalized. But the two countries have been the ones negotiating an informal security arrangement. The process that has been ongoing for the last two decades, mostly covertly but more openly in the past few years.
One significant waypoint was the initiation of formal relations with Israel by Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates, two nations that had steadfastly refused to recognize Israel ever since its founding. They would not have done this without a green light from the Saudis.
A second one was the Pentagon’s transfer of Israel to its Central Command security framework. Israel had been lumped in with the Pentagon’ European command framework since its founding because the Arab countries participating in Central Command framework would have nothing to do with Israel. Some still won’t, but the Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Bahrain are the ones who count for most in this informal alliance, and they assented to the inclusion of a country they already were coordinating with. A tangible result was seen last year when a couple Israeli Navy vessels sailed alongside Arab ships in a CENTCOM exercise in the Red Sea. That was a small step, but it would have been unthinkable just a few years ago. Still, the more important aspects of the Israeli-Saudi relationship, such as air defense cooperation, are primarily being worked out bilateraly, with some U.S. facilitation.
Personally, I think the resumption of diplomatic relations between Saudi Arabia and Iran is good for every nation in the region including Israel. Israeli politicians are not so sure, though. The initial politiical reaction to this development saw the former PM, Mr. Bennett, blame the current government for its ineffective handling of the Saudi relationship, while a senior member of the current government said this would never have happened had it not been for Bennett’s ineffective handling of the Saudi relationship.
The Mossad chief may have told the Shin Bet and the IDF chiefs, “This isn’t neccesarily about us, but I’m meeting with my Saudi counterpart in a couple weeks anyway and I’ll let you guys what he says about it. Have a happy Sabbath.”
Geminid
@Geminid: One positive aspect of renewed relations between Iran and Saudi Arabia is that they may help bring the war in Yemen to a close. Neither side can “win” it, and they and their sponsors might as well negotiate a durable ceasefire and start rebuilding their respective territories. The Yemeni people have suffered enough.
Charles
No mention of Seymour Hersh’s substack article? Too fringe for BJ?
Adam L Silverman
@Charles: I’ve dealt with it several times, it’s bullshit and requires complete credulity from the reader. If you ask one more time m blacklisting you.