We went through months and months of extraordinarily tedious Discourse about the very complicated, very nuanced nature of Critical Race Theory bans and so far it's turned out to be exactly what any idiot could've told you it was. https://t.co/kUttyt5VSG
— Nathan Goldwag 🇺🇦 (@GoldwagNathan) January 11, 2023
It's made all the better because there was a whole panic about how the Left was canceling Dr. Suess.
— Airship Chronos says TRANS RIGHTS!🇺🇦 (@CooperDoyle1) January 11, 2023
There's a bit more context, but none of it is exculpatory. The occasion was a visit from NPR's Planet Money, which was recording an episode about how economics gets discussed and taught in children's books. One of the readings that day was The Sneetches. And you can see why. pic.twitter.com/5aDM9l4AM5
— Jeffrey Sachs (@JeffreyASachs) January 11, 2023
If you're a teacher, this is gold. Noah, a 3rd grade student, has connected the book to something else he knows. He's thinking things through, analyzing a text, applying what he's learned. Parents, you know what I'm talking about. It's magic.
— Jeffrey Sachs (@JeffreyASachs) January 11, 2023
Our children are so much smarter than Christopher Rufo gives them credit for.
— The Afrofuturist Woman (@quitafor) January 11, 2023
But the kids still really want to know how The Sneetches ends! Beeman tries to fend them off with some nonsense about standing up for your bellies, but they remain unsatisfied. So she says to go ask your parents. pic.twitter.com/o0PYl6Km8M
— Jeffrey Sachs (@JeffreyASachs) January 11, 2023
Per the Columbus Dispatch:
The assistant director of communications for Olentangy Local School District abruptly stopped the reading of the Dr. Seuss book “The Sneetches” to a third-grade classroom during an NPR podcast after students asked about race….
NPR reporter Erika Beras spent the day in Robek’s class with Beeman for the podcast. As part of the district stipulations, politics were off limits. Six books were selected ahead of time by Beras and the district — including “The Sneetches.”
“I don’t know if I feel comfortable with the book being one of the ones featured,” Beeman is heard saying on the podcast during the middle of “The Sneetches” reading. “I just feel like this isn’t teaching anything about economics, and this is a little bit more about differences with race and everything like that.”
“The Sneetches,” published in 1961, is a book about two kinds of Sneetches: those with stars on their bellies and those without stars. The Plain-Belly Sneetches are judged negatively by their appearance, so capitalist Sylvester McMonkey McBean makes money selling them stars for their bellies. Meanwhile, the Star-Bellied Sneetches don’t like associating with the Plain-Belly Sneetches, so they start paying to have a machine take their stars off.
The Seuss family has said the book was intended to teach children not to judge or discriminate against others because of their appearance and to treat people equitably….
Beras tried to tell Beeman that “The Sneetches” is about preferences, open markets and economic loss, but Beeman replied, “I just don’t think it might be appropriate for the third-grade class and for them to have a discussion around it.”
On the “Planet Money” episode, Beras reached back out to Beeman to ask about what happened. Beeman replied, “When the book began addressing racism, segregation and discriminating behaviors, this was not the conversation we had prepared Mrs. Robek, the students or parents would take place. There may be some very important economics lessons in ‘The Sneetches,’ but I did not feel that those lessons were the themes students were going to grasp at that point in the day or in the book.”…
Looking back, Beeman said she does wish she had handled the situation differently by talking to Robek separately to figure out a way to continue the Seuss book and have the discussion geared more toward economics…
And that, said Jeffrey on Twitter that day
Is the stupidest thing I've heard anyone say.
Should teachers need parents to give their consent
Before any second of class time is spent
On answering students with questions on race?
My God. How'd we ever wind up in this place?— Jeffrey Sachs (@JeffreyASachs) January 11, 2023
This reminded me that I used to use this book to teach my college students about the social construction of race and its consequences when I first became a professor. I was reading it to my preschooler one night and then I knew it would go on my syllabus.
— Tennille N. Allen (@TennilleNAllen) January 11, 2023
Listen to the original Planet Money story here: https://t.co/JKlRVr6IZW
— NPR's Planet Money (@planetmoney) January 11, 2023
Wokeness Update Open Thread: *First* As Farce…Post + Comments (175)